The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Episoder

• 
  Best Of Giants on WFAN: The Harbaugh Effect is Showing 06.10.2026 39min

  WFAN presents a collection of discussions celebrating the Giants' 36-24 win over the Arizona Cardinals to take sole possession of first place in the NFC East, featuring Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Carton Show. The shows react to the full "Jameis Winston Experience," Deonte Banks’ game-clinching pick-six on 4th down, Theo Johnson’s touchdown, and Arvell Reese stepping up with Brian Burns sidelined. That and more on Best Of Giants on WFAN!
• 
  Best Of Jets on WFAN: Unpacking a Brutal Loss to the Bears 06.10.2026 33min

  WFAN presents a collection of discussions reacting to the Jets' dismal 23-12 loss to the Chicago Bears from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Carton Show. The guys react to mind-boggling stats—including Chicago running 89 plays and racking up 34 first downs while the Jets managed just 32 total plays—plus Frank Reich's questionable play-calling, Garrett Wilson only getting 4 targets, and whether Aaron Glenn can turn things around. That and more on Best Of Jets on WFAN!
• 
  Full Show: Giants Take First Place While the Same Old Jets Hit Rock Bottom 05.10.2026 3t 12min

  Craig and Big Mac discuss the diverging paths of New York football after the Giants moved into first place and the Jets suffered a humiliating defeat against the Bears. They also analyze the Yankees' offensive struggles and lineup decisions heading into a pivotal Game 2 against the Rays. (00:01:50) Jets Fail, Giants Win (00:05:45) Frank Reich's Failing Offense (00:10:05) Giants Take The Division (00:16:05) Yankees Game 1 Frustrations (00:22:05) Jets Coaching Change Options (00:29:10) ALDS Game 2 Lineup (00:34:40) Final Predictions And Picks
• 
  Hour 1: Carton Blasts Jets' Failure as Giants Secure First Place 05.10.2026 36min

  Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the contrasting states of New York's football franchises following a weekend of highs and lows. They critique the Jets' lack of competitive spirit and offensive identity while praising the Giants' ability to make mid-game adjustments under pressure. The discussion also touches on potential coaching candidates for the Jets and the realism of the Giants' current lead in the division. (00:01:20) Giants Win & Jets Loss (00:04:42) Frank Reich & Jets Offense (00:07:17) Coaching Impact Comparison (00:09:40) Giants' 3-1 Start Reality (00:14:12) Giants' Defensive Stand (00:16:45) Jets' Offensive Incompetence (00:21:42) Jets' Coaching Search Ideas (00:24:45) Week 5 Matchup Outlook
• 
  Hour 2: Jameis Winston Survives the "Experience" as Giants Move to 3-1 05.10.2026 39min

  Craig and Big Mac break down the New York Giants' narrow victory and the inconsistent play of quarterback Jameis Winston. They also debate potential coaching candidates for the New York Jets, including Mike Tomlin and Bill Belichick, before criticizing Austin Wells for a costly baserunning error during the Yankees game. (00:01:20) Jameis Winston's Performance (00:05:15) NFC Playoff Contenders (00:09:50) Jets Coaching Search Debate (00:14:05) Austin Wells' Baserunning Gaffe (00:20:45) Boone's Management Critics (00:24:20) Yankees Offensive Struggles
• 
  Hour 3: Mike Tomlin to the Jets: A Realistic Solution for Woody Johnson? 05.10.2026 53min

  Carton Show Big Mac analyzes the New York Jets' struggles and evaluates whether Mike Tomlin could be the answer to their coaching woes under Woody Johnson. They also preview the Yankees' critical Game 2 matchup against the Rays, debating the starting lineup and the pitching performance required from Clarke Schmidt. (00:01:20) Yankees Postseason Outlook (00:06:40) Mike Tomlin Coaching Rumors (00:10:45) Giants Ownership Critique (00:14:30) Eli Manning Legacy Debate (00:20:15) Tropicana Field Ground Rules (00:23:30) Jameis Winston Performance (00:30:05) Giants Win Over Titans (00:35:15) Future NFL Head Coaches
• 
  Hour 4: Craig and C-Mac Debate Yankees Lineup and Giants QB Future 05.10.2026 28min

  Craig and C-Mac analyze the high stakes of Yankees-Rays Game 2, focusing on Aaron Boone’s lineup choices and Clarke Schmidt’s start. They also field a call on the Giants' winning potential with Jameis Winston under center. C-Mac details his high-stress pacing rituals for playoff baseball. (00:01:03) Yankees vs NFL Debate (00:02:35) Giants Season Update (00:04:32) Yankees Lineup Strategy (00:07:51) Giants QB Outlook (00:14:24) Playoff Pacing Rituals
• 
  Hour 5: C-Mac Defends Yankees Game 2 Lineup and Postseason Roster Decisions 05.10.2026 35min

  Chris McMonigle breaks down the Yankees' strategy for Game 2 of the ALDS against the Rays, defending the chosen lineup despite fan criticism. He explains the decision to leave Tim Hill off the postseason roster and highlights the necessity of Clarke Schmidt delivering a strong start to even the series. (00:01:00) Yankee Postseason Coverage Schedule (00:02:03) Defending Yankees Game Lineup (00:07:17) Tim Hill Roster Omission (00:08:48) Platoon Matchups Versus Consistency (00:12:00) Third Base Defensive Decisions
• 
  Craig Debates if Mike Tomlin Would Ever Coach for Woody Johnson 05.10.2026 17min

  Craig and Big Mac evaluate the possibility of Mike Tomlin leading the Jets and whether Woody Johnson is truly a meddling owner. They also look ahead to a pivotal Yankees postseason start for Cam Schlittler and discuss the history of quarterback play for New York's NFL franchises. (00:01:00) Football and Yankees Preview (00:07:33) Tomlin to Jets Debate (00:11:37) Jets and Giants Ownership (00:15:23) NY Quarterback History
• 
  NFL Official Suspended for Cursing at Cardinals' Trey McBride 05.10.2026 19min

  Craig and Chris evaluate the unique ground rules at Tropicana Field and debate whether analytics accurately reflect on-field results. They also discuss the suspension of referee Eugene Hall following an incident with Trey McBride and analyze Jameis Winston's recent performance.(00:01:25) Tropicana Field Ground Rules(00:05:15) Mike Tomlin and QB Markets(00:08:29) Giants Defensive Standouts(00:13:09) NFL Play-Calling Critiques(00:19:01) Referee Eugene Hall Suspended
• 
  Yankees' Postseason Struggles & Austin Wells' Baserunning Blunder 05.10.2026 11min

  They analyze a critical baserunning error by Austin Wells during a matchup against the Rays, questioning the hit ruling and the impact on the game's momentum. The conversation extends to broader frustrations with the Aaron Boone era and the team's inability to beat superior opponents in the postseason. (00:01:00) Debating Wells' Controversial Hit (00:03:42) Late-Game Pinch Running Strategy (00:05:53) Aaron Boone's Postseason Struggles (00:08:28) Listener Defends Austin Wells
• 
  Craig and Big Mac Debate Giants' Success and a Missed Safety Call 05.10.2026 14min

  Craig and Big Mac explore how the Giants' turnaround highlights the importance of finding the right head coach in the NFL. They also detail a controversial interception during the Giants' victory over the Cardinals that they argue should have been called a safety. (00:01:01) Ticket Giveaway (00:02:30) NFL Coaching Impact (00:10:30) Giants Safety Debate
• 
  Jameis Winston's Wild Win and the Jets Coaching Search 05.10.2026 17min

  Carton and Big Mac breakdown the Jameis Winston experience following a New York Giants victory and an injury scare for Malik Nabors. They also evaluate the competitive NFC wildcard race and identify top head coaching candidates for the New York Jets, including Mike Tomlin and Bill Belichick.(00:01:06) Winston's Polarizing Giants Performance(00:05:20) NFC Wildcard Race Outlook(00:07:40) Official Erupts At McBride(00:10:50) Jets Head Coaching Search
• 
  Jets Record-Low Snaps & Should They Hire Kurt Cignetti or Tomlin? 05.10.2026 14min

  Following a lopsided loss to the Chicago Bears, analysis focuses on the New York Jets' historically low offensive output and the mounting pressure on their coaching staff. The conversation explores potential replacements like Kurt Cignetti or Mike Tomlin before assessing the New York Giants' chances in the wide-open NFC East. (00:02:10) Jets Loss to Bears (00:06:48) Jets Record-Low Snaps (00:11:30) Giants NFC East Outlook
• 
  Big Mac: Giants Play Real Football While Jets Are Embarrassing 05.10.2026 12min

  Big Mac and Craig Carton analyze the contrasting fortunes of the New York Giants and Jets, focusing on the Giants' impressive 3-1 start. They highlight how effective coaching has revitalized players like Deontay Banks and discuss the impact of injuries on the team's season outlook. (00:01:01) Giants 3-1 Start Analysis (00:05:22) Coaching Comparison Discussion (00:07:35) Jackson Dart Injury Fallout (00:10:12) Defensive Pass Rush Improvement
• 
  Craig: Jets Season Is Over After Embarrassing Loss to Tyson Bagent 05.10.2026 12min

  Craig and Big Mac dissect the New York Jets' devastating loss to the Chicago Bears, labeling it a non-competitive embarrassment. They contrast the performance with the New York Giants' fortunate 3-1 start and debate the significance of coaching across both franchises. (00:01:00) Weekend Football Recap (00:02:21) Jets Embarrassing Bears Loss (00:07:19) Coaching Staff Impact Debate (00:09:36) Giants Fortunate 3-1 Start
• 
  Best of the Giants on WFAN: J.J. McCarthy in, OBJ out 03.10.2026 1t

  The Giants released Odell Beckham Jr. after barely using him for three games. Our hosts react to the news and debate if there was ever any point of reuniting with OBJ in the first place. Plus, Evan and Tiki discuss the team's chances in the NFC East without Jaxson Dart, and if J.J. McCarthy has any chance of pushing Jameis Winston for the starting job. Phil Simms joins Boomer and Gio to talk all things Big Blue, including McCarthy and how he may be used the rest of this season.
• 
  Best of the Yankees on WFAN: Bring on the Rays 03.10.2026 53min

  The Yankees steamrolled the hated Red Sox in a two-game Wild Card Series sweep, and we have full reactions from all of our hosts, who were pleasantly surprised at how efficient the Yankee lineup was from top to bottom. Plus, debating whether or not Aaron Judge will play in the ALDS, how the Yankees will set up their rotation, and if the Bombers should be favored against the Rays. Meanwhile, Evan and Tiki feel like the Yanks were a little over the top in celebrating a Wild Card Series win, and Boomer and Gio debate which Yankee is likeliest to carry the team and be their new "Mr. October."
• 
  Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for Week 4 in the NFL 03.10.2026 44min

  From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Boomer and Mike are back to talk all the headlines from week 3, another splashy Cowboys trade, Week 4 picks, Game of the Week, a QB Power Rankings and more!
• 
  Full Show: Craig Challenges Giants' Playoff Hopes Amid Romo Conspiracy 02.10.2026 2t 52min

  Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate the New York Giants' postseason viability and the impact of the Brian Burns injury. They investigate conspiracy theories surrounding Tony Romo's CBS departure and the suspension of Jed York. The discussion also evaluates the firing of Braden Bell and the ethics of gambling in the NBA. (00:01:50) New York Sports Update (00:08:10) Giants Playoff Viability Debate (00:16:07) Romo CBS Divorce Conspiracy (00:21:52) Jed York Suspension News (00:16:22) Yankees Postseason Roster Decisions (00:17:09) Deshaun Watson Interview Analysis (00:31:03) Braden Bell Firing Controversy (00:27:46) NBA Gambling Endorsement Debate