The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Folgen

• 
  Full Show: The Yankees Season is on the Line 07.10.2026 2Std. 58Min.

  Craig and C-Mac are live at Yankee Stadium for Game 3 of the ALDS as they preview a pivotal game for the Bronx Bombers. Jeff Francoeur, Dellin Betances, and Brian Anderson all join the show.
• 
  Hour 1: Must Win Wednesday at Yankee Stadium! 07.10.2026 35Min.

  Craig and C-Mac are live from Yankee Stadium in the Bronx getting set for Game 3 of the ALDS with the Yankees trailing in the series 2-0.
• 
  Hour 2: Is Aaron Boone the Problem? 07.10.2026 38Min.

  Craig and C-Mac discuss the importance of Aaron Boone during this season. Will he make changes to the lineup for Game 3?
• 
  Hour 3: Game 3 Lineup is Out 07.10.2026 45Min.

  Craig and C-Mac give instant reactions to the Yankees' ALDS Game 3 lineup against the Nick Martinez and the Rays. Jeff Francoeur joins the show live from Yankee Stadium.
• 
  Hour 4: The Return on Anthony Volpe 07.10.2026 58Min.

  Craig and C-Mac are joined by for Yankee Dellin Betances and play-by-play broadcaster Brian Anderson to preview Game 3 of the ALDS between the Yankees and Rays.
• 
  Dellin Betances on Yankees’ Lineup Strategy & Game 3 Pressure 07.10.2026 11Min.

  Dellin Betances joins Craig and Chris to analyze the Yankees' postseason approach and the decision to start Anthony Volpe over Jazz Chisholm. He shares insights from his 2017 playoff run and discusses the intense pressure of October baseball. (00:01:00) Dellin Betances Interview (00:01:52) Volpe vs Chisholm Lineup (00:03:59) 2017 Comeback Mentality (00:07:06) Game 3 Score Predictions (00:10:28) Playoff Anxiety Discussion
• 
  Jeff Francoeur on Yankees Lineup Changes and Boone's Gut Decisions 07.10.2026 20Min.

  Jeff Francoeur joins to analyze the Yankees' strategy while facing a must-win situation against the Rays. They examine Aaron Boone’s lineup shifts, the psychological pressure of New York, and the consistency of the Tampa Bay organization. (00:01:00) Jeff Francoeur Interview (00:02:53) Analyzing Lineup Changes (00:06:46) Playoff Pitching Strategy (00:11:49) Anthony Volpe's Impact (00:17:48) Game Night Expectations
• 
  Howie Roseman’s Potential Exit Strategy from Eagles Cap Hell 07.10.2026 13Min.

  Craig and Big Mac weigh in on Lane Johnson's retirement and the long-term financial implications for the Philadelphia Eagles. They also cover the Giants' decision to pass on Odell Beckham Jr. and a fiery debate over Aaron Boone’s leadership of the Yankees. (00:01:00) Giants and Eagles Roster News (00:05:24) Thibodeau and Boone Debates (00:12:13) Yankee Stadium Game Banter
• 
  Will Aaron Boone Survive if the Yankees Fall Tonight? 07.10.2026 10Min.

  Craig Carton and C-Mac analyze the New York Yankees' current slump, debating whether the team's "tight" play stems from coaching or individual performance. They specifically address Jazz Chisholm's recent errors and speculate on Aaron Boone's job security heading into a potential lockout season. (00:01:00) Peanuts and Squeeze Trivia (00:02:24) Yankees Run Production Concerns (00:05:12) Yankees Hitting Strategy (00:08:12) Boone and Chisholm Future
• 
  Suzyn Waldman Solves the Yankee Stadium Peanut Crisis 07.10.2026 17Min.

  Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle share Suzyn Waldman's reporting that confirms peanuts have returned to Yankee Stadium. They debate whether Jazz Chisholm Jr. or Anthony Volpe should start in the lineup before discussing Max Fried's decision to pitch during his girlfriend's pregnancy. The conversation concludes with a heated debate regarding the necessity of paternity leave for professional athletes. (00:01:00) Yankee Stadium Peanut Update (00:03:11) Yankee Lineup Tweak Discussion (00:04:44) Chisholm Vs Volpe Debate (00:13:58) Max Fried Paternity Situation (00:18:21) Paternity Leave Debate
• 
  Yankee Stadium Runs Out of Peanuts; Chisholm vs. Volpe Debate 07.10.2026 11Min.

  Carton and Big Mac discuss a surprising shortage at Yankee Stadium where the venue has reportedly run out of peanuts during the postseason. They also dive into a debate regarding the Yankees' lineup, comparing the offensive potential of Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Anthony Volpe while clarifying MLB paternity leave rules. (00:01:00) Stadium Peanut Shortage (00:06:02) MLB Paternity Leave Rules (00:09:47) Chisholm Vs Volpe Debate
• 
  Big Mac and Mike Debate Yankee Lineup and Aaron Judge Loophole 07.10.2026 13Min.

  Big Mac and Mike evaluate the Yankees' infield defensive options on the Card Show, weighing Jazz Chisholm Jr.'s power against defensive reliability. They also investigate a caller's suggestion to use MLB paternity list rules involving Max Fried as a loophole to add Aaron Judge to the active roster. (00:01:00) Yankees Infield Dilemma (00:07:28) Aaron Judge Loophole (00:13:09) Postseason Roster Strategy
• 
  Max Fried Must Save the Yankees Season Tonight! 07.10.2026 10Min.

  Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle are live from Yankee Stadium ahead of Game 3 of the ALDS between the Yankees and Rays. With New York trailing 2-0 in the series, Max Fried takes the mound with the Yankees’ season hanging in the balance.
• 
  Yankees make FOUR errors in disgusting game two loss | 'Go Get 'Em' 07.10.2026 57Min.

  Chris McMonigle is LIVID after that despicable showing from the Yankees in a crucial game two. He sounds off on the disastrous fielding miscues in the first and fifth inning, from Jazz Chisholm at second base to Ryan McMahon at third. Plus, the offense outside of Ben Rice remains nonexistent through two games in Tampa. Is the series over? C-Mac reveals his thoughts on the series moving forward, and what it would mean big picture if the Yankees cannot complete a miracle comeback.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS1:30 - Breaking down Ryan McMahon's tone-setting misplay on the very first play of the game.2:24 - Evaluating Cam Schlittler's struggles on the mound, finishing with only two strikeouts amidst terrible defensive support.11:47 - Jazz Chisholm's costly throwing error and questionable decision-making in the infield.16:26 - The Yankees' offensive woes, with Ben Rice providing the team's only runs via two solo home runs.23:51 - The backbreaking throwing error by Lombard that allowed two extra runs to score.31:20 - Defending manager Aaron Boone and placing the blame squarely on the players for failing to make routine defensive plays.39:19 - Addressing the lineup's collective 0-for-38 slump, excluding Wells, Rice, and Bellinger.41:50 - Looking ahead to Game 3 at Yankee Stadium. Max Fried takes the mound against Nick Martinez in a desperate bid to keep the season alive.
• 
  Full Show: Craig and C-Mac Blast "Embarrassing" Yankees Loss to Rays 06.10.2026 3Std. 24Min.

  Craig Carton and Chris Mack analyze the New York Yankees' defensive collapse and lack of offense following a devastating loss to the Tampa Bay Rays. They evaluate Aaron Boone's job security while looking ahead to Max Fried's high-stakes start in Game 3. (00:01:50) Yankees Defensive Debacle Breakdown (00:05:43) Critical Errors By Jazz Chisholm (00:10:42) Evaluating Aaron Boone's Management (00:15:15) Yankees Series Comeback Odds (00:18:29) Lane Johnson Announces NFL Retirement (00:21:43) Yankees Offense Missing Approach (00:25:50) Historical Yankees World Series Comparisons (00:33:56) Nancy Reads Her 1960 Diary
• 
  Hour 1: Big Mac and Carton Blast "Embarrassing" Yankees Loss vs. Rays 06.10.2026 33Min.

  Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the New York Yankees' defensive "abomination" against the Tampa Bay Rays that has them on the brink of elimination. They critique Aaron Boone’s managing style and the team's inability to execute fundamental plays under pressure. The discussion includes audio from Boone regarding his lineup decisions and a look ahead to Game 3. (00:01:20) Yankees Loss Analysis (00:05:15) Defensive Disaster Breakdown (00:09:08) Offensive Struggles Discussed (00:14:45) One Word Descriptions (00:18:48) Spencer Jones Incident (00:22:05) Boone Lineup Decision Talk
• 
  Hour 2: Craig & Big Mac Scathe Yankees' "Embarrassing" Defensive Meltdown 06.10.2026 47Min.

  Craig and Big Mac tear into the Yankees' fundamental failures and defensive errors following a demoralizing postseason loss. They analyze the franchise's long-standing offensive disappearances in October and debate whether Aaron Boone’s tenure should continue. (00:01:20) Yankees Defensive Meltdown (00:04:53) Analyzing Fundamental Failures (00:09:12) Postseason Offensive History (00:13:45) Ranking The Failure (00:18:30) Comparing Team Defenses (00:21:46) Handing Out Gas Faces (00:27:32) Boone Performance Review (00:33:45) Yankees Managerial Future
• 
  Hour 3: Yankees Must Win Game 3 as Lane Johnson Unexpectedly Retires 06.10.2026 58Min.

  The Carton Show features Craig and Big Mac analyzing the Yankees' high-stakes Game 3 against the Rays while evaluating potential first-pitch candidates to energize the crowd. They break down the shocking mid-season retirement of Eagles tackle Lane Johnson and address the complex situation surrounding Max Fried's availability during his partner's pregnancy. The discussion extends to NFL coaching performances and historical Yankee tragedies, including the electrocution accident involving Mariano Rivera's family. (00:01:20) First Pitch Debate (00:04:11) John Harbaugh Discussion (00:10:22) Lane Johnson Retires (00:14:47) Mental Health Discussion (00:19:33) Max Fried Imminent Birth (00:23:56) NFL Coaching Update (00:27:42) Mariano Rivera Tragedy (00:31:46) Yankee Roster Decisions (00:37:47) Kurt Cignetti Analysis (00:42:06) Game 4 Pitching Strategy
• 
  Hour 4: Max Fried’s Baby News and the Great Sweet Muenster Cheese Debate 06.10.2026 27Min.

  Craig Carton and Chris Mack look ahead to a critical Game 3 for the Yankees while discussing the emotional boost Max Fried might get from his impending fatherhood. They dive into a heated debate over the existence of Sweet Muenster cheese and listen to a caller's 60-year-old diary entry about Bill Mazeroski. Craig also insists that producer Pete leave work early to watch his son play football. (00:01:00) Yankees Season On The Line (00:03:51) Nancy’s 1960 World Series Diary (00:10:10) Tommy’s Long Distance Transfer (00:14:40) Great Sweet Muenster Debate (00:18:15) Max Fried’s Imminent Fatherhood
• 
  Hour 5: C-Mac: Yankees Must Reclaim Self-Respect in Game 3 vs. Rays 06.10.2026 36Min.

  Chris McMonagle breaks down the New York Yankees' embarrassing performance against the Tampa Bay Rays in the ALDS, focusing on defensive failures and questionable lineup decisions. He debates callers on the job security of Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman while emphasizing that the roster must perform to avoid a sweep. (00:01:20) Yankee ALDS Disaster (00:05:02) Defensive Struggles vs Rays (00:09:13) Debate Over Game 3 Lineup (00:13:05) Top Stars Must Produce (00:17:58) Analyzing Scouting Approaches (00:23:35) Defending Boone and Cashman (00:28:44) Protecting Yankee Stadium Turf