The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Episode

• 
  Best of the NFL on WFAN: Could Giants and Jets start 2-0? 19.09.2026 1j 5mnt

  Phil Simms joins Boomer and Gio to give his take on Jaxson Dart making the leap in year two after a promising Week 1 performance. Plus, Evan Roberts says fans should embrace the optimism from Week 1 and believe that both New York teams could be on the rise. The Evan and Tiki crew wonder if Tyrone Tracy's job is at risk if he struggles again in Week 2, while Gio believes both the Giants and Jets are catching their Week 2 opponents at just the right time.
• 
  Best of the Mets on WFAN: Pete Alonso returns 19.09.2026 1j 12mnt

  Pete Alonso returned to Queens this week, and it brought about PLENTY of debates. Gio says Alonso hitting his 300th career home run to tie the game in the ninth for the Orioles, and getting a curtain call as a visiting player afterward, cemented 2026 as the most embarrassing season in Mets history. Plus, KFC Barstool called in to Boomer and Gio to rip Sean Manaea for criticizing Mets fans for calling for that curtain call. Tiki Barber called out Manaea as well, while Evan sounded off on Alonso for taking the curtain call. On The Carton Show, Craig and C-Mac debate how David Stearns must feel about Alonso's return, and how it might impact Steve Cohen's thought process about the future.
• 
  Full Show: Aaron Judge’s IL Stint Stuns Yankees While Jets Target a 2-0 Start 18.09.2026 2j 37mnt

  Craig and Big Mac react to the shocking news that Aaron Judge is heading to the IL with a calf strain, casting a shadow over the Yankees' postseason run. They also preview the Jets' pivotal matchup with the Packers and address heated caller feedback regarding their on-air dynamic. (00:01:55) Football Friday Kickoff (00:05:45) Bills Offensive Dominance (00:09:20) Knicks Mantra Discussion (00:16:00) Jets Whiteout Debate (00:22:25) Bullying Allegations Clash (00:34:05) Aaron Judge Injury (00:45:55) Yankees Postseason Outlook
• 
  Hour 1: Craig Carton Thinks Jets Can Beat Packers for Historic 2-0 Start 18.09.2026 38mnt

  Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the New York Jets' potential for a 2-0 start as they prepare for a rainy matchup against the Green Bay Packers. They analyze the dominance of the Buffalo Bills and debate whether the Jets' success is being overlooked compared to the Giants. The conversation also explores Craig’s 'What Would the Knicks Do' mindset and the origins of Lorna Doone cookies. (00:01:20) Football Friday Opening (00:04:36) Bills Dominant Performance (00:08:22) Knicks Winning Philosophy (00:12:30) Morning Show Redux (00:17:13) Jets Whiteout Uniforms (00:20:20) Jets Versus Giants Debate (00:24:00) Shortbread Cookie History
• 
  Hour 2: Craig Carton Confronts Caller Over Big Mac Bullying Allegations 18.09.2026 37mnt

  Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle analyze the New York Jets' outlook against the Green Bay Packers and the potential impact of rain on the stadium's whiteout event. They also address a heated caller's accusations of on-air bullying and share their reactions to recent viral moments from Mina Kimes and Pat McAfee. (00:01:35) Jets Packers Whiteout Preview (00:06:10) Giants and Cowboys Analysis (00:09:45) Show Weather Reporter Search (00:15:30) NFL Week 2 Predictions (00:21:45) Confronting Bullying Accusations (00:28:20) Pat McAfee ESPN Reaction
• 
  Hour 3: Carton & C-Mac: Jets 2-0 Hopes and the Canadian Anthem Rant 18.09.2026 28mnt

  Craig Carton and C-Mac reflect on the last time the New York Jets started a season 2-0 while debating whether Geno Smith can lead them to victory against the Packers. They also dive into a heated discussion regarding UB40 cover songs and critique the Buffalo Bills for playing the Canadian national anthem. The conversation concludes with Giants injury updates and a comparison between collegiate and professional male cheerleaders. (00:01:00) Jets 2-0 History (00:07:49) UB40 Song Debate (00:13:35) NFL Male Cheerleaders (00:17:10) Giants Injury News (00:20:59) Canadian Anthem Critique
• 
  Hour 4: Aaron Judge Hits IL, Clouding Yankees' Playoff Future 18.09.2026 52mnt

  Craig and C-Mac react to breaking news that Aaron Judge is heading to the 10-day injured list with a calf strain. They explore the Yankees' path forward through the postseason, the building mojo surrounding the Jets, and the financial success of the Knicks' playoff run. (00:01:25) Judge Injury Speculation (00:05:35) Lifestyles And 80s Stars (00:11:48) Knicks Revenue Windfall (00:15:55) Jets Momentum Building (00:19:10) Eileen On Resident Rights (00:26:10) ALS United Walk (00:31:24) Breaking Judge IL News (00:39:05) Postseason Pitching Strategy
• 
  Aaron Judge Injury Update, C-Mac Breaks Down Live on Air 18.09.2026 13mnt

  The boys get an update on Aaron Judge's injury and Chris McMonigle has a hard time keeping it together live on air.
• 
  Carton & C-Mac Talk Jets History, Neil Diamond & Male Cheerleaders 18.09.2026 18mnt

  Carton and Chris McMonigle celebrate a potential 2-0 start for the New York Jets and revisit the team's last success in 2015. They handle a confrontational caller regarding masculinity in sports radio before exploring the surprising origins of the song "Red Red Wine" and debating the athletic merits of collegiate male cheerleaders. (00:01:00) Jets 2-0 History (00:04:45) Masculinity and Bullying Debate (00:08:44) Neil Diamond Music Trivia (00:13:30) Elvis and Footloose Evolution (00:15:44) Male Cheerleader Comparison
• 
  Inside the 50-Foot Underground Bunker Where Vegas Sets Odds 18.09.2026 10mnt

  After reviewing successful NFL picks from Thursday night, the discussion turns to the deceptive nature of paid sports handicapping services and the flaws of trend-based betting. A firsthand account is shared regarding a visit to a high-security, windowless bunker 50 feet below the Nevada desert where analysts determine the betting lines for major casinos. (00:01:03) Friday Morning NFL Recap (00:02:14) Exposing Betting Service Scams (00:07:26) Vegas Odds Setting Bunker
• 
  Are the Lions Spiraling Out of Control? NFL Week 2 Is Upon Us! 18.09.2026 15mnt

  Predictions for the upcoming NFL slate lead into a critique of Dan Campbell’s leadership and the Lions' defensive struggles. A contentious call from Mike in Westchester forces Craig Carton to defend himself against claims of bullying partner Chris McMonigle. Reactions to Mina Kimes' old Josh Allen takes and Pat McAfee's behavior on ESPN conclude the segment.(00:01:31) Week 2 NFL Predictions(00:04:29) Dan Campbell's Identity Crisis(00:06:09) Heated Call On Bullying(00:12:38) Pat McAfee ESPN Reaction
• 
  Carton and Big Mac Prep for a Rain-Soaked Jets Matchup 18.09.2026 15mnt

  Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle analyze the New York Jets' chances against the Green Bay Packers, focusing on the potential impact of heavy rain and defensive injuries. They also field fan calls about the Giants and discuss personal weekend plans involving wood chopping. (00:01:04) Jets Packers Game Analysis (00:06:53) Fan Call & NY Predictions (00:10:29) Searching For A Weather Guy (00:14:46) Craig’s Weekend Wood Chopping
• 
  Craig Carton Denied Entry for Live Cow Milking Segment 18.09.2026 17mnt

  Craig and Big Mac discuss the refusal of building management to allow a live cow in the studio for a milking demonstration. They shift to debating the best American cookies and a bizarre new sport originating in Romania. The conversation also covers elevator etiquette and the upcoming NFL weekend for the Jets and Giants. (00:01:00) Cow Milking Denied (00:03:30) Elevator Small Talk (00:06:26) Lorna Doone Cookie (00:12:46) Romanian Ass Slapping (00:15:37) Jets and Giants
• 
  Is a Jets 2-0 Start as Legitimate as the Giants? 18.09.2026 11mnt

  Big Mac & Craig debate the validity of a potential 2-0 start for the Jets compared to the Giants, sparking a discussion about fan expectations in New York. They analyze the strength of upcoming opponents and argue whether the Jets are finally ready to be seen as a legitimate playoff threat.(00:01:04) Jets White Out Game(00:04:15) Boone's Farm Wine Talk(00:06:12) Comparing Jets/Giants Starts(00:10:35) New York Football Divide
• 
  THE JETS CAN’T LOSE THIS GAME! 18.09.2026 13mnt

  Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle are fired up for Football Friday on WFAN! The guys break down the Jets’ Week 2 matchup against the Green Bay Packers and explain why they believe New York has a legitimate chance to start the season 2-0. Is the rain actually going to help the Jets? Can the Jets’ pass rush take advantage of Green Bay’s struggling offensive line? And could Aaron Glenn’s team really be sitting at 2-0 on Monday?
• 
  Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for Week 2 in the NFL | 'Kickoff with Boomer and Valenti' 18.09.2026 48mnt

  Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti: Week 1 reaction, Josh Allen's MVP performances, and Week 2 picks
• 
  Aaron Judge leaves game in potential Yankees NIGHTMARE | 'Go Get 'Em' 18.09.2026 1j 22mnt

  It's hold-your-breath time in Yankees Universe as Aaron Judge exited Wednesday's game with lower right leg tightness. Is it time to panic?? C-Mac reveals his level of concern, and how careful the Yankees need to be until the playoffs. Plus, who will fill the shoes of Judge in his absence, and how long could that absence be? Chris also dives into the Twins series as a whole, including another extra innings loss, the game-ending play involving George Lombard Jr., and if the division is officially out of reach.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTSIntro: A gut-punch loss and the reality of the Rays taking the division.11:58: Breaking down Aaron Judge's early exit and his cryptic injury updates.21:44: Evaluating George Lombard's defensive struggles at shortstop.30:30: Ryan McMahon's offensive drop-off and building an infield vs. Boston's lefties.42:23: Positives on the mound: Max Fried's bounce-back start.45:55: Defending the Yankees' playoff clinch champagne celebration.1:04:52: "Shill or Shame" segment: Shilling for Bellinger, shaming Ramos.1:16:25: Pitching preview for the upcoming series in Arizona.
• 
  Full Show: Steve Cohen Applauds Pete Alonso: A Citi Field Scandal 17.09.2026 3j 13mnt

  Craigie and Big Mac react to Mets owner Steve Cohen giving Pete Alonso a standing ovation at Citi Field after his 300th career home run. The Carton Show also features a conversation with Randy Levine regarding the health of Aaron Judge and the Protect College Sports Act. (00:01:50) 60 Days To Greatness (00:09:25) Aaron Judge Health Concerns (00:17:35) Randy Levine Interview (00:23:42) Scott Boras Fact Check (00:28:56) Steve Cohen Applauds Alonso (00:39:12) Sports Fashion And Masculinity (00:46:00) Mark Jackson Card Story
• 
  Hour 1: Carton: Why You Can’t Trust Aaron Judge in the Postseason 17.09.2026 28mnt

  Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the New York Knicks' apology for a major ticket pricing error and the team's championship banner plans. They also debate the Yankees' postseason reliability, questioning if Aaron Judge and Gerrit Cole can perform at a championship level given Judge's health and the team's inconsistent rotation. (00:01:04) Knicks Ticket Price Apology (00:08:08) Aaron Judge Injury Status (00:13:30) Yankees Playoff Rotation Strategy (00:17:46) Yankee Postseason Trust Ratings (00:19:46) Debate Over Judge Rehab
• 
  Hour 2: Carton and Big Mac on Aaron Judge's Health and the Steve Cohen Video 17.09.2026 40mnt

  The Carton Show dives into the Yankees' injury concerns surrounding Aaron Judge and the strategic implications of his potential move to the DH spot. Carton details a heated phone call from agent Scott Boras regarding the Pete Alonso agent switch and critiques Steve Cohen's reaction to Alonso's 300th home run. They also explore quirky sports collectibles and the declining quality of late-night comedy. (00:01:41) Knicks Roommate Show (00:03:05) Aaron Judge Injury (00:07:44) Yankees Shortstop Debate (00:09:35) Steve Cohen Controversy (00:13:42) Scott Boras Confrontation (00:24:48) Jerry Garcia Collectibles (00:28:28) Leaving Games Early (00:31:27) SNL Comedy Review