The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Odcinki

• 
  Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone do NOT appear to be on the same page | 'Go Get 'Em' 26.09.2026 1godz 20min

  Aaron Judge intends to play in the Wild Card Series, which is a far cry from Aaron Boone's previous comments. Is there a miscommunication between the manager and the captain? C-Mac has some strong thoughts on Judge's approach to his own injury updates, if he should try to push it and play against Boston, and whether the Yankees would be better off without Judge at less than 100 percent. Meanwhile, Clarke Schmidt is no longer a Wild Card Series option due to a biceps injury. Is the Yankee bullpen strong enough for a playoff run? Plus, debating what the series against the Rays potentially showed in terms of who deserves what role in the playoffs. EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS 1:25 - Bright spots from the recent series, focusing on Carlos Rodon's strong start and Lombard's impressive defensive and offensive output. 9:40 - The Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone disconnect: Analyzing Judge's frustration over Boone publicly detailing his "moderate" calf strain. 26:01 - The playoff lineup dilemma: Debating the risks of playing an injured Judge versus relying on Ben Rice or Paul Goldschmidt against left-handed pitching. 31:41 - Evaluating potential postseason roster returns for Giancarlo Stanton and Trent Grisham as late-game pinch-hit options. 33:04 - The argument for leaving Ryan McMahon off the playoff roster despite his recent grand slam and five-RBI game. 39:57 - Wild Card rotation strategy: Weighing whether Cam Schlittler or Max Fried should take the mound for Game 1. 57:51 - Bullpen concerns mount as Clarke Schmidt hits the 15-day IL with biceps tendinitis, exposing the front office's failure to acquire relief help at the deadline. 1:09:37 - Defending Aaron Boone's managerial performance and the team's achievement of winning 92 games despite Judge missing three months of the season.
• 
  Full Show: Craig Carton Defends Yankees' Move for CC Sabathia Day 25.09.2026 2godz 55min

  Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle address the backlash surrounding the New York Yankees' decision to reschedule CC Sabathia's honoring ceremony due to a major storm. They debate the merits of various postseason pitching rotations and review NFL Week 2 results. The conversation also explores a recent investigation into Tim Tebow and includes personal anecdotes about high school athletics. (00:01:55) Sabathia Ceremony Controversy (00:10:55) NFL Week 2 Reaction (00:17:10) Postseason Rotation Debate (00:27:20) Tim Tebow Investigation News (00:14:20) High School Sports Memories (00:10:45) NFL Week 3 Picks
• 
  Hour 1: Craig Slams "Selfish" Fans Over Yankees Storm Schedule Changes 25.09.2026 34min

  The Carton Show addresses the controversy surrounding the New York Yankees rescheduling CC Sabathia's jersey retirement due to an impending storm. They criticize fans for prioritizing bobbleheads over public safety and debate whether Clarke Schmidt should start Game 1 of the playoffs against the Red Sox. (00:01:25) CC Sabathia Ceremony Changes (00:04:36) Fan Safety vs Bobbleheads (00:10:23) NFL Week 2 Reactions (00:13:53) Yankees Ticket Policy Explained (00:17:11) Playoff Pitching Rotation Debate (00:25:15) Red Sox Pitching Matchups
• 
  Hour 2: Big Mac and Craig Debate Fried vs. Schlittler for Yankees Game 1 25.09.2026 43min

  Craig and Big Mac engage in a fiery debate over the Yankees' postseason pitching rotation, specifically whether Max Fried or Cam Schlittler should start Game 1. They also honor CC Sabathia's legacy at Yankee Stadium and discuss iconic music moments involving Prince, Tom Petty, and the history of sketch comedy. (00:01:29) CC Sabathia Ceremony (00:04:40) Yankees Rotation Debate (00:08:00) Playoff Bye Analysis (00:13:10) Iconic Guitar Solos (00:18:00) Sketch Comedy History (00:22:10) Yankee Rotation Logic (00:25:45) Defending Rotation Arguments
• 
  Hour 3: Giants Game in Limbo as Storm Cancels AC/DC at MetLife 25.09.2026 58min

  They discuss the cancellation of the AC/DC concert at MetLife Stadium and how severe weather conditions might force a postponement of the upcoming Giants game. The conversation also covers the team's quarterback depth, debunking rumors of a trade for Shedeur Sanders, and stories of rejecting famous guests like Meghan Markle. (00:01:40) TV Cameos and Rock Legends (00:05:55) Disney World vs Concierge Medicine (00:09:25) AC/DC MetLife Concert Canceled (00:15:35) Rejecting Markle and Bieber (00:22:20) Honoring New York's Bravest (00:28:05) Happy Days and TV History (00:34:25) Shedeur Sanders Trade Rumors (00:42:25) Giants Quarterback Depth Analysis
• 
  Hour 4: Carton and Big Mac Defend Tim Tebow Amid LifeSurge Investigation 25.09.2026 39min

  Craig Carton and Big Mac question why Tim Tebow was the primary face of a fraud investigation into LifeSurge despite other high-profile athletes being involved. They also break down upcoming NFL matchups for the Jets and Giants while sharing nostalgic stories about their high school sports careers. (00:01:32) LifeSurge Investigation Analysis (00:05:08) Allegations Against Tim Tebow (00:09:15) NFL Weekend Odds Breakdown (00:14:17) High School Sports Stories (00:18:23) Broadcasting From Yankee Stadium (00:23:44) Giants And Jets Analysis (00:10:10) Weekly NFL Picks Segment
• 
  Carton's Emotional FDNY Visit & Shaking Off Shedeur Sanders Rumors 25.09.2026 23min

  Craig Carton describes his early morning visit to a legendary FDNY firehouse and the respect he has for the speed and bravery of firefighters. He and Big Mac then discuss the career trajectories of the Friends cast before analyzing rumors surrounding the Giants and Shedeur Sanders. They also reflect on Kevin Stefanski’s leadership following a powerful speech described by Bijan Robinson. (00:01:00) FDNY Firehouse Visit (00:07:20) Friends Cast Career Debates (00:15:47) Giants Trade Rumors (00:23:30) Stefanski's Moving Team Speech
• 
  Craig Carton Recalls Turning Down Meghan Markle and Justin Bieber 25.09.2026 18min

  Craig Carton recounts his cameo on the television series Royal Pains and explains the high-end world of concierge medicine. Discussion turns to the last-minute cancellation of the AC/DC concert at MetLife Stadium and how severe wind warnings might affect the New York Giants. They also reflect on past booking decisions, including turning down future stars Meghan Markle and Justin Bieber. (00:01:50) Finding TV Through TikTok (00:03:32) Cameo on Royal Pains (00:06:28) Disney World VIP Experience (00:09:15) AC/DC Concert Cancellation News (00:16:52) Rejecting Markle and Bieber
• 
  Big Mac Defends Controversial Yankees Pitching Strategy 25.09.2026 16min

  Craig and Big Mac reminisce about iconic music moments, including Prince's legendary solo and Big Mac's own musical theater past. They also debate the Yankees' postseason pitching rotation with callers and pay tribute to the career of CC Sabathia. (00:01:07) Iconic Guitar Solos (00:04:20) Host Musical History (00:08:15) Bobbleheads and Plagiarism (00:12:13) Yankees Rotation Debate (00:15:55) CC Sabathia Tribute
• 
  Wild Card Rotation Debate: Max Fried or Cam Schlittler? 25.09.2026 12min

  They debate the pitching rotation for the wild card series, specifically focusing on whether Max Fried or Cam Schlittler should take the mound for Game 1. They also discuss George Harrison's post-Beatles success and the ethics of ordering food delivery during an impending major storm. (00:01:00) George Harrison Discussion (00:03:43) MLB Postseason Stats (00:08:04) Game 1 Pitching Debate
• 
  Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for Week 3 in the NFL | 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' 25.09.2026 45min

  Kickoff with Boomer Valenti: The Chiefs Dynasty is back, the Packers and Chargers might stink, and Jaxson Dart's season is over. The guys give their Week 3 picks and wrap up with a game of "QB or HC"
• 
  Big Mac Debates Yankees' Wild Card Pitching: Schlittler vs. Fried 25.09.2026 16min

  Big Mac and a caller clash over the Yankees' postseason rotation strategy and whether Cam Schlittler belongs in Game 1. They examine the historical success of Wild Card teams and discuss CC Sabathia's impact ahead of his stadium ceremony. The conversation also previews the Giants' upcoming matchup against the Titans. (00:01:27) Sabathia's Yankee Ceremony (00:03:40) Yankees Wild Card Rotation (00:08:02) Wild Card Success Stats (00:11:41) Rotation Strategy And Pressure (00:16:47) Giants vs Titans Preview
• 
  Craig Slams "Selfish" Fans for Valuing Bobbleheads Over Storm Safety 25.09.2026 17min

  Craig and Big Mac address the New York Yankees' decision to reschedule CC Sabathia's ceremony on The Carton Show while criticizing fans frustrated by a shifted giveaway. They transition into a debate regarding the playoff pitching hierarchy and preview the New York Giants' upcoming game against the Titans. (00:01:00) CC Sabathia Day Update (00:02:30) Bobblehead Backlash Rant (00:08:34) Fan Call On Storm (00:11:00) Yankees Pitching Rotation Debate (00:15:29) Giants Titans Game Preview
• 
  Debating the Yankees Rotation and Sabathia's Ceremony Schedule 25.09.2026 8min

  They examine the scheduling changes for CC Sabathia's ceremony and the resulting ticket exchange options for fans. The conversation also covers a debate over the Yankees' postseason pitching strategy and previews upcoming NFL matchups for the Giants and Jets. (00:01:25) Sabathia Ceremony Schedule (00:04:01) Yankees Playoff Rotation Strategy (00:10:02) Yankees PR and NFL Preview
• 
  Carton Defends Yankees Moving CC Sabathia Day Due to Storm 25.09.2026 12min

  Craig Carton and Big Mac address the backlash regarding the New York Yankees rescheduling CC Sabathia's ceremony in light of an impending natural disaster. They also discuss Bijan Robinson's standout performance for the Falcons and a potential pitching rotation shift for the upcoming series against the Red Sox. (00:01:14) Yankees Storm Rescheduling (00:04:37) Fan Frustration and Refunds (00:08:16) CC Sabathia's Rescheduling Input (00:10:24) NFL Recap and Bijan Robinson (00:11:37) Yankees Pitching Rotation Debate
• 
  Full Show: Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone Clashing Over Playoff Availability 24.09.2026 3godz 12min

  Craig and Big Mac discuss the growing tension between Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone regarding Judge's calf injury and wild-card availability. They also analyze the New York Giants' outlook after a season-ending injury to the starting quarterback and compare local rosters. (00:02:42) Judge Boone Injury Conflict (00:11:10) Kuzmenko Father Bear Attack (00:16:41) Hostin Juror Story Fraud (00:21:23) Giants Jets Roster Debate (00:25:11) Teaching Gallo Bike Riding (00:31:03) Tebow Charity Allegations
• 
  Hour 1: Craig Blasts 'Selfish' Aaron Judge Over Yankees Injury Drama 24.09.2026 38min

  Craig and Big Mac analyze the tension between Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone over the captain's calf injury and playoff status. They debate whether Judge’s secrecy regarding his health is selfish while also comparing his injury history to Giancarlo Stanton's frequent setbacks. The conversation shifts to Craig’s viral banana video, a fact-check of Sonny Hostin, and a radio ratings prank. (00:01:20) Weather And Sports Updates (00:04:45) Judge And Boone Tension (00:08:58) Judge Playoff Roster Debate (00:13:45) Viral Content And Urlacher (00:17:00) Sonny Hostin Jury Lie (00:20:48) Judge Injury History Debate (00:25:15) Judge Versus Stanton Comparison (00:30:45) Radio Ratings Prank Story
• 
  Hour 2: Craig Rips Kurt Warner Over His Jayden Daniels Toughness Comments 24.09.2026 42min

  Craig and Big Mac react to the shocking news that Morgan Wallen received zero CMA nominations before diving into the New York Giants' injury crisis. They debate the team's viability with Jameis Winston and criticize Kurt Warner for his comments regarding Jayden Daniels' toughness. The duo also discusses a bizarre hockey tragedy and mocks Gallo for his inability to ride a bicycle. (00:01:20) Morgan Wallen Snub (00:05:30) Giants Injury Updates (00:09:30) Giants Season Debate (00:14:45) Kurt Warner Comments (00:10:50) Andrei Kuzmenko Tragedy (00:14:20) Shaka Salamander Revenge (00:19:45) Madden Movie Trailer (00:23:00) Gallo Bicycle Mockery
• 
  Hour 3: Craig Carton Bets a Giants Fan Over Season Win Totals 24.09.2026 38min

  Craig Carton and Big Mac debate why the Jets currently boast a superior roster over the Giants following the injury to Jaxson Dart. They blast the NFL for imposing heavy fines on celebratory demonstrations while simultaneously promoting alcohol and gambling sponsors. The discussion also covers Yankees postseason updates and a high-stakes bet regarding New York football supremacy. (00:01:20) Teaching Big Mac to Bike (00:04:15) Jets vs. Giants Roster Debate (00:08:50) Criticizing New York Football Coaching (00:14:45) Ridiculous NFL Celebration Fines (00:18:05) Yankees Weather and Stanton News (00:21:25) High-Stakes Win Total Bet (00:23:55) New York's Best Bagel Spots (00:26:50) Big Mac's Weight Loss Journey
• 
  Hour 4: Giants Ticket Prices Plunge Amid Tim Tebow Charity Controversy 24.09.2026 44min

  The crew analyzes the plummeting ticket prices for the upcoming New York Giants game and evaluates potential quarterback replacements after Jaxson Dart's injury. They also critique the state of NFL pregame shows and defend Tim Tebow against recent investigative allegations. (00:01:20) Falcons Primetime Woes (00:04:20) Giants Ticket Price Analysis (00:10:29) Giants Quarterback Future (00:15:15) NFL Media Show Critique (00:19:43) NBA Personal Life Controversies (00:28:31) Tim Tebow Charity Investigation (00:16:29) Jaxson Dart Injury Status (00:22:40) Strange Culinary Discussions (00:26:56) Iconic Football Moments