The Holly Pivec Podcast
Holly Pivec
0
The Holly Pivec Podcast is a Christian discernment show about recognizing deception inside and outside the church. Each episode helps listeners identify modern cons, cults, and counterfeit spiritual movements. Holly Pivec teaches practical ways to detect and debunk false teaching and to think carefully about faith claims. The podcast encourages listeners to become more discerning and grounded in biblical truth.
Episodet
-
EP 41 | Are you Married to Someone in the NAR? Biblical Advice 19.09.2026 23minCan Christians in a spiritually mismatched marriage preserve their union while keeping a clear conscience before God?In this episode, Holly explores the tension that occurs in marriages when one spouse is part of the New Apostolic Reformation and the other is not.She unpacks what a "spiritual mismatch" is through 1 Corinthians 7, where Paul instructs believers who are married to an unbeliever, and she shows how his advice can also apply to those believers who are married to someone in NAR. She also examines conscience and authority through Acts 5:29 and the examples of Shadrach, Meshach, Abednego, and Daniel, concluding that obedience to God comes before human authority, and that marriage vows never require participating in false teaching.In this episode, you'll learn:* What a spiritual mismatch is and its implications in a marriage.* What to do if you are in a mismatched marriage, based on 1 Corinthians 7:12-16 and Acts 5:29.* How Acts 5:29 warns against joining others in disobedience to God.* How to handle the tough issues arising from a spiritually mismatched marriage.* The importance of keeping your conscience clean before God.Have you or someone you love ever faced a spiritually mismatched marriage? Tell us about it in the comments.Resources & Links:Join Holly's Substack Book Club: https://hollypivec.substack.comRead more about NAR tactics in Holly's co-authored book, Counterfeit Kingdom: https://a.co/d/08kKR5j9#christianpodcasting #NAR #christianmarriage #falseteachers -
EP 40 | Is Your Church Leadership Actually Healthy? 3 Revealing Signs 04.09.2026 14minDoctrinal soundness, quite simply, is not enough. A church can be biblically sound and still be led by unaccountable, unhealthy leadership.In this episode, Holly breaks down three fundamental characteristics of healthy leadership, highlighting the importance of accountability, transparency, and character traits drawn from 1 Timothy 3:1–7 and Titus 1:5–9. These passages show us how to discern whether a church's leadership is actually healthy beyond biblical soundness.In this episode, you'll learn:- Why "doctrinally sound" doesn't necessarily mean "safe"- The pervasive reality of "paper elders" who do not hold the senior pastor accountable- What 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1 actually require of elders- Why governing bylaws are essential (and how they are often neglected)- The authoritarianism test: Do your leaders truly welcome questions?Resources & Links:Join Holly's Substack Book Club: https://hollypivec.substack.comRead more about NAR tactics in Holly's co-authored book, Counterfeit Kingdom: https://a.co/d/08kKR5j9Have you ever experienced "paper elder" leadership: strong in theory, but impotent in practice? Tell us in the comments.#christianpodcasting #NAR #healthytheology #apologetics #falseteachers -
EP 39 | How to Find a Biblically Sound Church (Without Chasing Perfection) 21.08.2026 23minHow do you know if a church is actually solid? In this episode, Holly breaks down what to look for: biblically sound teaching and healthy leadership, not perfection.She walks through the warning signs of deviant doctrines like the "prosperity gospel" and NAR teachings, and shares a practical filter for reading a church's statement of faith. Does it show real reverence for Scripture? Are there red flags pointing to NAR influence?For anyone struggling to find a biblically sound community, Holly offers practical advice. And for those already rooted in a good church, the call is to dig in and serve, not just sit backIn this episode, you’ll learn:* What Makes a Church Biblically Sound* A Mature Believer’s Role* Denominational Flexibility & the Importance of Fellowship* Why You Should Evaluate Teachings & Statements of FaithResources & Links:Join Holly’s Substack Book Club: hollypivec.substack.comRead more about NAR tactics in Holly’s book, Counterfeit Kingdom: https://a.co/d/08kKR5j9#NAR #KathrynKrick #Discernment #FalseTeachers #Apologetics -
EP 38 | Beyond Kathryn Krick: The Hidden Danger of "Subtle" NAR Teachings 07.08.2026 13minKathryn Krick, the 35-year-old lead pastor of 5F Church in Los Angeles, has gone viral for her dramatic deliverance services, theatrical style, and followers laying gifts at her feet. But while critics label her a "cult leader," many are missing a much bigger threat. In this episode, Holly reveals the critical mistake people make when evaluating flashy figures like Krick: assuming the danger is limited to sensational performers. Behind Krick’s viral clips is a core doctrine standard across the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR)—the "Fivefold Ministry." Holly breaks down how NAR teachings, apostolic authority, and coded language like "Mama" and "Papa" are being promoted by soft-spoken, seemingly balanced pastors in local churches nationwide.In this episode, you’ll learn:* Why Katherine Krick’s viral book-signing and 5F Church reflect standard NAR doctrine.* What the "Fivefold Ministry" doctrine actually teaches—and how Ephesians 4:11 is taken out of context.* The hidden meaning behind titles like "Mama," "Papa," and laying gifts at a leader's feet.* Why "subtle" NAR churches can be even more dangerous than high-profile, theatrical leaders.Resources & Links:Join Holly’s Substack Book Club: hollypivec.substack.comRead more about NAR tactics in Holly’s book, Counterfeit Kingdom: https://a.co/d/08kKR5j9#NAR #KathrynKrick #Discernment #FalseTeachers #Apologetics -
EP 37 | Why Did It Take Plagiarism to Expose The Passion Translation? 23.07.2026 14minIn this special "On My Radar," episode, I dive into key issues surrounding the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) and why biblical discernment is more urgent than ever.I address a commonly asked question: Are prosperity gospel teachings connected with NAR? From there, I discuss recent revelations surrounding Brian Simmons and The Passion Translation, asking why it often takes plagiarism allegations or public scandals for eyes to open, when false teaching should be tested against Scripture first.Drawing from Acts 17:11 and Revelation 2, I show what true Berean discernment looks like—and why Christians must test claims, prophecies, and leaders against God's Word before major harm is done.TIMESTAMPSProsperity Gospel and the NAR Movement Connection - 0:00Prosperity Gospel in NAR Churches - 4:39The Passion Translation and NAR Influence - 6:31Historical Warnings about TPT and Current Realizations - 9:41Encouragement for Biblical Discernment - 13:43Join Holly's Substack community for more on discernment and the New Apostolic Reformation: https://substack.com/@hollypivecHave these false doctrines affected your walk with Christ? If so, how?Let us know in the comments 🙌79bbtgqc'79bbtgqc'#ProsperityGospel #NewApostolicReformation #BiblicalDiscernment #FalseTeachings #ChristianApologetics -
EP 25 | The Dangers of "Hearing God's Voice" on the Mission Field: A 2-Part Interview with Aaron and Chelsea Hunter (Part 1) 17.07.2026 57minWe Left the Mission Field: The Reality of "Beyond" and the Theological Drift in Modern MissionsWhy would an ethusiastic, committed missionary couple walk away from their life’s work? In this deep-dive, two-part interview, Aaron and Chelsea Hunter share their jarring experience with the missions organization "Beyond." They reveal how the pressures to "hear God's voice" and document numerical growth have led to a "Jesus Hermeneutic" that replaces sound doctrine with subjective impressions, and why they believe these "Church Planting Movements" are hindering the gospel and world missions.Watch to discover:The perceived tension between "theological purity" vs. "reaching the nations."A first-hand account of when "Discovery Bible Studies" bypass God's objective Word in Scripture.The dangers of "Listening Prayer" and New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) influence on the mission field.Advice for churches and aspiring missionaries on how to select sound missions organizations to partner with. CHAPTERS:00:00 Introduction to the Hunters' Missionary Journey03:13 Understanding Beyond: The Organization's Role in Missions06:01 Concerns Arising: The Influence of YWAM08:53 "Hearing God's Voice": The Central Pillar of Beyond12:12 The Dynamics of Listening Prayer14:55 The Pressure of "Obedience": A Burden on Missionaries17:46 The Harmful Impact of Listening Prayer on Missionaries' Relationships with God21:03 The Unbiblical Role of Listening Prayer in Decision-Making23:55 The Process of Listening Prayer: Steps and Practices27:11 Urgency in Missions: The 2025 Goal29:51 The Dangers of Presuming God's Voice and Prophecy41:51 Testing Divine Revelation and Insufficient Criteria46:56 Hyper-Spiritualization: Leaving No Room for Simple Encouragement50:54 Prayer Declarations and Their Influence54:08 Strategic-Level Spiritual Warfare: Understanding Strongholds RESOURCES MENTIONED:Nine Marks: https://www.9marks.org/ (Resources on biblical missions)ABOUT THIS PODCAST:The goal of this conversation is not to discourage missions, but to call the church back to a foundation of sound theology and biblical integrity. We believe that true "success" in missions is measured by faithfulness to God's Word in Scripture, not the pursuit of "hearing God's voice" outside of Scripture or rapid multiplication.#Missions #Beyond #ChurchPlanting #Theology #Christianity #Discernment #Gospel #BibleStudy -
EP 36 | Exposing False Teachings Without Losing Your Soul 10.07.2026 21minHow to grow in discernment and not turn cynical? In this episode, Holly shares the subtle line between spotting doctrinal error in the church and not trusting anyone or anything. While this may sound troublesome, she shares her personal experience and growth through three things that have kept her from going down that road, drawing from the church at Ephesus in Revelation 2 and Elijah's meltdown in the cave in 1 Kings. 0:08 Why Discernment Can Tip Into Cynicism4:38 We're All at Different Places in Our Walk9:13 Don't Only Focus on the False13:51 Fill Your Mind With What's True and Good18:33 Finding Your People (and Why It Matters)20:00 A Final Word from Galatians 6:9Join Holly's Substack community for more on discernment and the New Apostolic Reformation: https://substack.com/@hollypivec?r=1rh7cc&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=stories&shareImageVariant=blurWhat's helped you stay non-cynical? Let us know in the comments. 🙏#SpiritualDiscernment #Cynicism #Theology #FalseTeachings #ChristianLife #Discernment -
EP 35 | Is NAR Theology Fueling Your Anxiety? A Biblical Counselor Explains 27.06.2026 24minCan certain so-called "Christian" teachings contribute to anxiety, depression, and feelings of failure?In this conversation, biblical counselor Mark Baker explains how negative narratives, perfectionism, performance-based thinking, and false teachings can deeply impact our mental health. He also shares practical tools for identifying harmful thought patterns, finding hope in the midst of depression, and learning to trust God.0:00 Negative Narratives and Mental Health3:10 The Danger of Self-Condemnation5:50 Why Perfectionism Fuels Depression8:00 Practical Steps for Anxiety and Depression10:20 How False Teaching Creates Pressure and Fear12:00 The Link Between Depression and Hopelessness15:00 One Question to Ask When You're Depressed17:20 Where Are You Struggling to Trust God?19:10 Using Scripture to Renew Your Mind21:00 Why Bible Verses Aren't Magic Formulas23:00 Final EncouragementCheck out Mark Baker's book Re-Minded: https://amzn.to/4dXP4iPSee his other resources here: https://www.hopeforlifeonline.com/Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!#SpiritualDiscernment #MentalHealth #Theology #FalseTeachings #ChristianMentalHealth #Discernment -
EP 34 | How Spiritual Discernment Directly Impacts Your Mental Health 11.06.2026 20minIs your mental health suffering because of bad theology? Discover how growing in spiritual discernment can free you from the anxiety, guilt, and emotional damage caused by false teachings.Many modern Christians are caught in a cycle of subtle shaming, false hope, and spiritual burnout. In this video, we break down why true biblical discernment is actually your greatest mental defense mechanism and a true faith builder.Learn how to spot "wolves in sheep's clothing," develop a healthy theology of suffering, and guard your mind against counterfeit spirituality.00:00 - What is biblical discernment?01:05 - The 3 faculties of the mind02:13 - The "gymnasium" of the mind03:16 - Exposing mysticism and false teachings04:32 - How bad theology hurts mental health05:18 - The danger of fake revivals06:35 - True love warns people08:21 - Social media scrolling vs. mental peace09:57 - Why NAR theology causes anxiety12:22 - Spiritual abuse and "shame-bombing"14:31 - Judging leaders by their fruit15:38 - Developing a theology of suffering17:52 - How God uses hardship to train us20:16 - Rejecting the "quick-fix" gospel21:55 - Overcoming negative narrativesIf you want to grow deep in the Word and learn to guard your mind, make sure to subscribe and hit the notification bell!Check out Mark Baker's book Re-Minded: https://amzn.to/4dXP4iPHave you ever experienced spiritual "shame-bombing" or struggled with a "quick-fix" theology? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!#SpiritualDiscernment #MentalHealth #BiblicalTheology #FalseTeachings #ChristianMentalHealth #Discernment #Hebrews514 -
EP 33 |The Hard Work of Heart Work: Why NAR Shortcuts Fuel Anxiety 29.05.2026 23minIs the "quick fix" culture of modern church movements actually hurting your mental health? In this clip, we break down why true biblical peace isn’t a supernatural "zap," but a daily process of heart work—and how movements like the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) might be driving people into anxiety and dependency.If you’ve ever felt exhausted trying to manufacture supernatural experiences or control things outside your hands, this video is for you. We dive deep into the difference between coping mechanisms and true sanctification.Key Moments in This Video00:00 Intro: deception, shortcuts, and false teaching01:10 The “hard work of heart work” vs instant spiritual fixes04:22 False hope, anxiety, depression, and coping mechanisms09:25 Dependency on supernatural experiences and emotional highs12:06 NAR promises, impossible expectations, and control17:54 Spiritual warfare distractions and losing focus on the gospel21:27 Dominion theology and “another gospel”True spiritual growth takes time. In this discussion, Mark Baker unpacks Chapter 4 ("The Hard Work of Heart Work") and Chapter 8 of his book Re-Minded, exposing how the obsession with signs, wonders, and immediate deliverance can create a toxic loop of emotional highs and crashes. By shifting our focus from what we can't control to what we can, we find the sound mind that God actually promised us. Subscribe for more discussions on spiritual discernment and biblical truth!#SpiritualDiscernment #MentalHealth #NAR #BiblicalTruth #Sanctification #ChristianPodcast #FaithAndMentalHealth -
EP32 | How False Teachings Damage Your Mental Health: A Biblical Perspective 14.05.2026 36minIs your spiritual life causing more anxiety than peace?In this episode, I'm with biblical counselor and author Mark Baker to expose the overlooked link between false teachings—specifically within the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR)—and mental health struggles like depression and chronic guilt.If you’ve ever felt like you "weren't performing enough" for God, or felt trapped by the pressure to hear a "word from God" for every decision, this conversation is for you. We dive deep into why subjective, feelings-based Christianity often leads to a "breaking point" and how you can reclaim a sound mind through the objective truth of Scripture.In this episode, we discuss:Biblical Counseling vs. Secular Psychology: Explaining different frameworksThe NAR Mental Health Fallout: Why doctrines like "Heaven on Earth" and "Modern Apostles" often result in hopelessness.The Rise of "Christian" Mysticism: The subjective mystical practices, like "grave soaking" and "trips to heaven" (via guided visualizations), that are infiltrating the churchReclaiming a Sound Mind: The vital connection between self-discipline and mental clarity (2 Timothy 1:7).The "Crack" in the System: How catching one lie or false prophecy can be the first step toward spiritual freedom.Timestamps:00:00 – Intro: Reconnecting with Mark Baker.01:02 – What is biblical counseling and why is it unique?04:02 – The secularization of pastoral care in modern seminaries.08:47 – How false teaching creates an "unsound mind."13:26 – Does NAR attract or create mental health issues?16:45 – The burden of "performance-based" Christianity.23:22 – How one "crack" via a false prophecy can lead to freedom.28:10 – The danger of "subjectivity" and the "Touch not the anointed" trap.31:25 – Understanding the role of self-discipline in a sound mind.34:58 – The hard work of "heart work": Avoiding spiritual shortcuts.Resources Mentioned:Mark Baker’s Book: Re-Minded: How to Renew Your Mind, Quiet Your Soul, and Transform Your Life - https://www.amazon.com/Re-Minded-Renew-Your-Quiet-Transform/dp/B0DDP78BK6Have you experienced anxiety or spiritual burnout from these types of teachings? Share your story in the comments below. We’re building a community of truth-seekers and would love to hear from you.Don’t forget to SUBSCRIBE and hit the 🔔to stay updated on our latest deep dives into theology and discernment.#HollyPivec #MarkBaker #NAR #BiblicalCounseling #MentalHealth #Discernment #SpiritualAbuse #SoundMind #ChristianPodcast -
EP31 | Prophecy or Prop: How Magicians Replicate Modern "Miracles" 30.04.2026 50minIs it a miracle from God, a manifestation of the demonic, or just a clever trick?In this deep-dive interview, professional magician and mentalist Terry Holley pulls back the curtain on the "signs and wonders" appearing in modern movements like the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR). From gold dust and "glory clouds" at Bethel to the secrets of "words of knowledge," Terry explains how mentalism and cold reading can perfectly replicate what many claim to be supernatural.We also tackle the tough theological questions: Did Pharaoh’s magicians actually perform miracles? Can Satan control the weather? And why do so many Christians give the enemy more credit than the Bible does?If you’ve ever wondered if what you’re seeing on stage is real or just "extrasensory deception," this episode is for you. IN THIS EPISODE:Mentalism vs. Prophecy: How "Question & Answer" routines mimic prophetic words.The "Glory Cloud" Demystified: Comparing modern church manifestations to Las Vegas illusions.Theology of the Miraculous: Why creating life (snakes and blood) is a boundary only God crosses.Occam’s Razor & The Supernatural: Understanding the 4 natural forces before jumping to "miracle" conclusions.Demons & Objects: The logic (and hilarity) of "demon-possessed" chocolate chip cookies. CHAPTERS:0:00 - Introduction: Can magic explain so-called "miracles"?03:15 - The Q&A Routine: How mentalists "read minds."08:45 - Gold Dust & Snow: David Copperfield’s secrets.14:20 - Pharaoh’s Magicians: Miracle or sleight of hand?22:10 - Signs and Wonders: A Greek word study.30:35 - Can Satan control the weather? (Lessons from Job)38:50 - The "Supernormal" vs. The "Supernatural."45:15 - Debunking "demonized" objects and screaming wood.52:40 - The $25,000 Challenge for a real miracle.58:20 - Final thoughts: Staying within biblical boundaries.RESOURCES MENTIONED:Book: Astrology and Psychic Phenomena by Terry Holley.James Randi’s Alpha Project: How two magicians fooled the scientific community.CONTACT TERRY: [email protected] (For church seminars/performances and questions).Do you think he’s being too cynical, or is this the discernment the church needs today? Let us know in the comments.TWO CORRECTIONS SUBMITTED BY TERRY HOLLEY:1. David Hoy's "Hurling the Headlines" is not a book, but it is a chapter found in his booklet, "The Bold and Subtle Miracles of Dr. Faust."2. I accidentally stated that I sent predictions to David Hoy. I should have stated that I sent them to Gary North. Hoy passed in 1981. My correspondence with North was in the 1990s.#Discernment #Apologetics #NewApostolicReformation #Magic #Theology #TerryHolley #SpiritualWarfare #Mentalism -
EP30 | Signs, Wonders, or Sleight of Hand? A Magician's View of the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) 16.04.2026 1h 5minIs it a miracle, or just a really good trick? In this revealing interview, 55-year veteran magician Terry Holley pulls back the curtain on the "supernatural" claims of the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR).While many believers are amazed by "words of knowledge" and "miraculous" powers, Terry reveals how professional mentalism, data mining, and theatrical illusions can replicate these exact experiences. We explore the historical deception of figures like William Branham and Paul Cain, and the danger of building theology on anecdotal stories that crumble under investigation. If you've ever questioned the "Glory Cloud" or how a prophet knew personal details about your life, this video provides the technical and biblical clarity you need.Inside this investigation:Mentalism 101: How performers "read minds" using natural techniques.The Andre Kole Legacy: Why Jesus’ miracles were impossible to fake.Nailing Jello to a Wall: The truth about levitation stories and "miracle" reports.The "Hot Reading" Scandal: Why some modern prophets are just data mining.Biblical Discernment: How to distinguish between theatrical magic and occult practices.CHAPTERS0:00 – Intro: Why interview a Christian magician?1:25 – Terry Holley 55-year background in magic4:45 – What is Mentalism? (Mind reading vs. tricks)7:20 – Andre Kole and the investigation of Jesus’ miracles17:15 – The difference between theatrical magic and the occult19:10 – Why magicians use equipment (debunking demonic power)21:05 – Magician vs. Illusionist: Why some churches prefer "illusionist"23:30 – "Magic in the Bible": Hebrew and Greek word studies26:50 – Investigating the Kansas City Prophets and Bob Jones30:15 – Correspondence with John Piper and Wayne Grudem38:15 – The "Flying Reindeer" argument: Why we need proof43:50 – The Levitation Myth: Investigating supernatural claims50:15 – Observations on Craig Keener’s Miracles book volumes53:40 – Paul Cain and "Hot Reading" techniques56:10 – The "Sick Cat" experiment: How easy it is to fool people1:02:30 – Data mining and modern prophets (Shawn Bolz)Help us spread the truth:If this video helped you understand the mechanics of deception, please Like and Subscribe.Share this video with anyone currently involved in NAR circles to help them test what they are seeing against the truth.#NAR #Prophecy #Mentalism #BethelRedding #BiblicalDiscernment #Apologetics #FaithHealing #Discernment -
EP29 | Francis Chan’s Public Apology: Does It Go Far Enough? | With Doug Geivett 02.04.2026 1h 18minOn March 6, 2026, Francis Chan released a public apology titled "Tremble at His Words, Be Careful with Your Own." In it, he addresses his associations with leaders in the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR), including Mike Bickle and IHOPKC. But does this apology truly address the root of the problem, or does it sidestep the real issues and dangers?In this special audio-only episode of the podcast, Holly Pivec and Doug Geivett (joining from the Florida Everglades!) break down Chan’s letter and the accompanying statement from his network elders.We dive deep into:The "Integrity" Gap: Was Mike Bickle a man of integrity who "fell," or was the foundation flawed from the start?"Fooled Hundreds of Times": Analyzing Chan’s admission of a lack of discernment and what that means for his role as a globally influential leader.The Elder’s Defense: Why claiming "refutation" of NAR accusations is factually incorrect and misleading to the church.The Prophetic Movement: Why a focus on character scandals ignores the deeper crisis of fallible prophecy and theological error.A Call to Action: Will Chan ever give us the biblical criteria for evaluating prophets?Resources Mentioned:-Francis Chan’s Letter: Tremble at His Words, Be Careful with Your Own (Crazy Love Ministries)https://www.crazylove.org/articles/tremble-at-his-words-be-careful-with-your-own -Holly’s Blog: hollypivec.com -The Implosion of IHOPKC: https://www.hollypivec.com/blog/implosionofihopkc -Books by Holly Pivec and Doug Geivett: Counterfeit Kingdom, God's Super-Apostles, and more.https://www.amazon.com/s?k=holly+pivec+and+doug+geivett&crid=2B4DQ2AUNRY85&sprefix=holly+pivec+and+doug+geivett%2Caps%2C216&ref=nb_sb_noss_2 Timestamps: 00:00 – Introduction & Background on Francis Chan04:46 – Framing the Apology: "Those who no longer walk in integrity"15:10 – The avoidance of addressing "false teaching" in the apology21:47 – The stunning admission of being "fooled hundreds of times"35:34 – Analyzing the Elders’ Statement52:40 – Can a "legitimate" prophet be fallible?1:10:00 – Unity vs. Truth: Final thoughts and closing wisdomStay Connected: If you found this analysis helpful, please Like and Subscribe to stay updated on our latest critiques and theological discussions.#FrancisChan #NAR #MikeBickle #IHOPKC #Discernment #Theology #NewApostolicReformation #HoldFast #HollyPivec #DougGeivett -
EP 28 | NAR and the AG: Why Assemblies of God Pastors Must Draw a Line in the Sand (Part 2) 19.03.2026 51minThe ongoing collision with NAR has forced a moment of truth for the Assemblies of God, requiring a clear and final decision on whether it will protect its Pentecostal roots or succumb to apostolic infiltrators.* See a note of correction and clarification from Aaron Mapes below.*In this deep-dive interview, an AG pastor pulls back the curtain on how "Latter Rain" doctrines and modern NAR theology are covertly reshaping Pentecostal churches—and why the stakes for the AG have never been higher.From the controversial "offices" of modern-day apostles and prophets to the devastating impact of "fallible prophecy," Pastor Aaron Mapes and I explore why AG leaders must draw a line in the sand. We discuss the historical link between the 1940s Latter Rain movement and Jim Jones, the theological danger of the "always God’s will to heal" doctrine, and why Pastor Aaron has chosen not to use Bethel Music to protect his congregation.If you’ve ever wondered why your favorite worship song, or a "prophetic word" you've heard, feels like it’s leading to a different gospel, this conversation is for you. Key Topics Discussed:The historical condemnation of "Latter Rain" doctrines by the AG in 1949.Why Jim Jones is a sobering warning for modern charismatic movements.The "fallible prophecy" trap: Can a true prophet be wrong?Why Bethel’s theology is creating a "wrecking yard" of deconstructed faith.The practical reasons why Pastor Aaron has banned Bethel Music in his AG church (and other AG churches should do the same)How to identify "bad fruit" in a movement before it leads to spiritual and sexual abuse.Timestamps:0:00 – Introduction: NAR and the AG04:15 – The 1940s Latter Rain Movement & Jim Jones12:30 – Why the AG Issued New Position Papers on Apostles & Prophets18:45 – The Dangers of "Fallible Prophecy" (Deuteronomy 18)25:10 – Shipwrecked Faith: When "God’s Will to Heal" Fails33:20 – Why We Stopped Singing Bethel Music in Our Church41:15 – The "Cover-Up Culture" and Biblical Discernment50:40 – Truth Over Relationship: How to Talk to People in the AG About NAR58:20 – Final Thoughts: A Bigger Vision for the GospelResources Mentioned:Counterfeit Kingdom by Holly Pivec & Doug Geivett - https://a.co/d/0hncwff4God’s Super-Apostles by Doug Geivett and Holly Pivec- https://a.co/d/0aURrk3lA/G Pastors Concerned about NAR (New Apostolic Reformation) Facebook Group - https://www.facebook.com/groups/1299878327294092/?ref=share&mibextid=NSMWBTAre you seeing NAR influence in your local Pentecostal or other type of church?#AssembliesOfGod #NAR #BethelChurch #ChristianDiscernment #NewApostolicReformation #TheologyMatters #Pentecostal #biblicaltruth A Correction and Note of Clarification from Aaron Mapes:"Thanks, Holly! It was a pleasure to join you for this podcast! I need to make a public correction. In the interview, I stated Jim Jones was an A/G (Assemblies of God) minister instead of Independent Assemblies of God International minister. Very similar in history, relationship and doctrine, but separate organizations with cooperative ties and relationships as well as a shared name and some shared roots, as was the case with many early pentecostal churches and movements as they were emerging. The IAOGI was born out of the Scandanavian Assemblies of God." See Aaron's full note, with additional information about Jim Jones, on Facebook here: https://www.facebook.com/aaron.mapes.9/posts/pfbid0248NMNZNxixLyzLVNCJfZAMLFFPfuYXsBKcAgiFDyhZ6adHMGP5Cd3VrZYYYNJrRtl -
EP 27 | NAR and the AG: The NAR Incursion into the Assemblies of God (Part 1) 06.03.2026 46minIs the New Apostolic Reformation covertly reshaping your church? Join me and 5th-generation Assemblies of God pastor Aaron Mapes for a deep dive into the "smuggling" of NAR doctrine into classical Pentecostalism.While the boundaries between NAR and Pentecostalism have become increasingly blurred, the differences are critical for those concerned about the future of the Assemblies of God. In this episode, we expose how specific terminology—like the "five-fold ministry"—is being used as a gateway to introduce NAR "apostles" and "prophets" into local Assemblies of God churches. Pastor Aaron shares his personal journey of watching a thriving church of 300 dwindle to 80 after a NAR takeover and discusses the high-profile departures of flagship churches from the AG, like James River and Bethel Redding.In this video, you will learn:The vital distinctions between Pentecostalism, charismatic belief, and NAR.Why "five-fold ministry" language is often a red flag for aberrant teaching.The truth behind the "Show Me the Toes" (alleged) miracle and the danger of deceptive "revival" narratives.How the Assemblies of God’s new 2025 position papers address these encroachments.TIMESTAMPS0:00 - Intro: The Encroachment of NAR into the AG2:15 - Aaron Mapes’ Story: A 5th-Generation Heritage5:30 - Pentecostal vs. NAR: Clearing the Confusion9:45 - The "Second Act of Grace" and Initial Physical Evidence14:10 - How NAR Emerged Out of Independent Charismatic Churches17:40 - The "Seven Mountain Mandate" vs. Traditional Eschatology21:30 - Personal Fallout: When a NAR Takeover Splits a Church28:15 - "Smuggling" Doctrine: The Five-Fold Ministry Language35:50 - Case Study: James River Church and the "Toes" Controversy42:10 - The 2025 AG Position Papers: Do They Go Far Enough? RESOURCES MENTIONEDAmerican Gospel: Spirit & Fire: https://www.americangospelfilm.com/spirit--fire-ag3.html#NAR #AssembliesOfGod #Pentecostal #ChurchDiscernment #FiveFoldMinistry #Theology #JamesRiverChurch #BethelRedding #SpiritualAbuse #ChristianPodcast -
EP 26 | Dangers of "Hearing God's Voice" on the Mission Field: with Aaron and Chelsea Hunter (Pt. 2) 19.02.2026 55minIs modern missions work inadvertently hindering the gospel? In Part 2 of our deep dive, former Beyond missionaries Aaron and Chelsea—who were accused by the organization's leadership of being "unteachable"—share their firsthand experiences with the "Church Planting Movement" (CPM) strategy and the controversial "Insider Movements" that allow for religious syncretism. We discuss how the pressure to "hear from God" and meet artificial deadlines, like the 2025 goal, is resulting in unqualified leadership and the compromise of sound Christian doctrine. If you’re a missionary, a church supporter, or interested in the future of global evangelism, this conversation is a must-watch.KEY TAKEAWAYS:Syncretism in Missions: Why some organizations allow "converts" to continue to worship in mosques or give gifts to idolsLack of Transparency: Why missionaries are being instructed to hide syncretistic practices from their sending churches and financial supportersThe Problem with Speed: How fast-tracking missions efforts results in unqualified missionaries on the fieldSubjective Leadings: How some missionary training models have integrated a version of Discovery Bible Studies that shift the focus from the objective meaning of the biblical text to subjective internal impressions RESOURCES MENTIONED:Nine Marks: https://www.9marks.org/ (Resources on biblical missions)#Missions #ChurchPlanting #Theology #Christianity #Discernment #Beyond #YWAM #Evangelism #BibleStudy #Apologetics -
EP 24 | You Don’t Have to Do Discernment Alone: An Invitation to “Hold Fast" 22.01.2026 24minIn this episode, I share exciting news about the launch of my new book club and discussion community, over at Substack, called "Hold Fast with Holly Pivec." And I invite you to join us.I explain my vision for Hold Fast with Holly Pivec and share messages from my podcast listeners revealing the need for such a discernment community. I also share my own backstory that motivated me to undertake this new venture.Be sure to watch through to the end to learn about a special launch discount available to my podcast listeners and others who join in the first month.Are you navigating the challenges of the New Apostolic Reformation and feeling like you’re doing it alone? Well, many others are in the same boat. This community pulls together like-minded believers for guidance, encouragement, and study. Listen to this episode to learn all about my new discernment community and see how you can get involved, including coming to the Acts 17:11 Book Club—where we dissect primary NAR texts together and evaluate them by Scripture and careful reasoning—and participating in my monthly live Q-and-As.Subscribe today and join a community dedicated to protecting the body of Christ and holding fast to gospel in an age of new "apostles." For more information and to subscribe, visit Hold Fast with Holly Pivec at https://hollypivec.substack.com/about. And don’t forget to listen to this episode to get the full scoop! -
EP 23 | Is "Listening Prayer" Biblical? How "Listening Prayer Retreats" Hinder Spiritual Growth 09.01.2026 43minIs "listening prayer" the key to intimacy with God, as many Christian teachers claim? In this deep-dive conversation, we discuss a particular view of prayer as "two-way communication" and explore how seeking audible voices or mystical promptings can be a distraction from true spiritual growth. If you’ve ever felt stuck waiting to "hear from God" or worried that you’re missing God's specific instructions for your life, this episode is for you.In this video, we explore a more robust, biblical framework for intimacy with God. The topics we address include:True "Conversation" with God: How God communicates through a mind transformed by Scripture.Wisdom Over Formulas: Why God wants you to grow into an "empowered agent" rather than a puppet waiting for instructions.The Dallas Willard Connection: A personal look at Willard’s approach to "hearing God."The Obedience Key: Why acting on what you already know is the surest path to intimacy with God.RESOURCES MENTIONEDHearing God by Dallas Willard - https://www.amazon.com/Hearing-God-Developing-Conversational-Relationship/dp/1514011573Have you ever felt pressured to "hear a voice" in your prayer life? Let’s discuss in the comments. I’m curious to hear your experiences with "listening prayer." If you want to deepen your spiritual discernment, make sure to subscribe and hit the bell icon! #ChristianDiscernment #HearingGod #DallasWillard #PrayerLife #BiblicalWisdom #ChristianLiving #Discernment #Theology -
EP 22 | Is the Pressure to "Hear God's Voice" Preventing You from Actually Knowing Him?: An Interview with Doug Geivett (Part 1) 25.12.2025 52minIn this episode, I sit down with Dr. Doug Geivett, my co-author and long-time colleague, to discuss a very popular teaching in the church right now: “hearing God’s voice” outside of Scripture.Doug and I have co-authored four books on the New Apostolic Reformation. In this conversation, which is part of my larger series on "hearing God's voice," we address why the modern expectation of daily private messages from God has become so widespread and why it is spiritually risky.We respond to real pushback messages I have received, including claims that relying on Scripture to mediate God's voice means you only have a “relationship with a book.” We explain why that argument undermines both biblical authority and true intimacy with God. We also dig into what the Bible actually teaches about the Holy Spirit’s role in the believer’s life, what “being led by the Spirit” means, and why obedience is the biblical foundation for intimacy with God, not chasing impressions, dreams, or inner promptings.00:00 Intro and who Doug Geivett is01:53 Why this topic hits a nerve and the pushback has been intense03:51 Why “hearing God’s voice” is so appealing and why it became mainstream now06:08 How expectations are shaped by church culture and imitation08:35 The personal draw: intimacy, immediacy, and “God speaking to me”10:35 Main dangers: replacing real intimacy with an artificial metric12:18 The irony: seeking intimacy but actually blocking it14:35 Social pressure, spiritual insecurity, and manufactured experiences19:06 Reading pushback comments: “relationship with a book” and “living God speaks”21:07 Why Scripture still governs the question, even if God speaks in other ways24:19 Psalm 119 and why God’s Word is not “just a book”28:35 Why impressions are also a medium, and the inconsistency in the critique30:37 A sincere concern: “being led by the Spirit” and daily guidance34:47 Acts, decision making, and “it seemed good to us” vs “God told me”37:09 John 14 and what Jesus actually promised about the Holy Spirit41:29 Fruit of the Spirit and what it means to be led by the Spirit43:34 “Does God speak English?” Clarifying what people mean by “God spoke”45:44 Guidance through maturity vs claiming private revealed words47:52 Imagination based practices and why that is a problem50:19 The core claim: intimacy with God is grounded in obedience, not voice chasing52:24 Outro
