The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Épisodes

• 
  Max Fried DOMINATES in long-awaited return | 'Go Get 'Em' 24.07.2026 1h 22min

  Chris McMonigle reacts to Max Fried's stellar outing in his return from injury, sealing a series win for the Yankees. Still, it wasn't all positive, as C-Mac tears into the Yankee offense once again, which continues to struggle without Aaron Judge. Chris reacts to the team's much-needed rally late in game two of Wednesday's doubleheader, the failure to capitalize on Gerrit Cole's strong outing in game one, and what options Brian Cashman and company have to get this listless lineup going again.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS4:13 - Optimism around the pitching staff after Cole and Fried pitch on the same day for the first time.13:58 - Praising the bullpen, specifically Bednar and Blackburn, while looking for one more shutdown reliever.21:00 - Evaluating Will Warren's surprise appearance in the ninth inning.28:30 - The offense is a "disaster."34:55 - Deep frustrations with Bellinger and Goldschmidt expanding the strike zone.45:05 - Why Caballero and Volpe aren't the answer, and why the Yankees need to call up Lombard NOW.46:13 - Thoughts on Caballero's pitch clock antics, his clash with Dennis Santana, and MLB's response.1:01:00 - Potential moves for Mason Miller, Shea Langeliers, and Luis Arraez.1:07:38 - "Shill or Shame" Segment.1:18:28 - Looking ahead to the pitching matchups for the upcoming weekend series against the Phillies.
• 
  Full Show: LeBron James Holding the Knicks and NBA Schedule Hostage 23.07.2026 3h 34min

  Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle argue that the NBA is delaying its season schedule release solely to accommodate LeBron James, leaving the New York Knicks and their fans in limbo. They also analyze the Yankees' rotation stability and potential trade deadline acquisitions while debating a controversial column concerning Caitlin Clark. Additionally, they share personal stories including a family dispute involving Aaron Rodgers and a high-stakes shaving bet. 02:15 - Football Season Anticipation 06:50 - NBA Schedule Delay 11:45 - LeBron Holding Hostage 16:10 - Mets Fan Therapy 20:50 - Partnership Drama Explained 27:10 - Yankees Rotation Analysis 31:50 - Trade Deadline Strategy 38:10 - Rodgers Family Feud 45:20 - Home Security Incident 30:00 - Shaving Bet Discussion 34:40 - Media Industry Shakeups 42:15 - WNBA Racial Discourse 50:15 - Controversial Column Analysis 01:03:30 - Marijuana Brand Concepts 21:20 - Bon Jovi History 34:20 - Caitlin Clark Debate 39:45 - Malik Nabors Status
• 
  Hour 1: Carton Rips LeBron James for Holding Knicks, NBA Schedule Hostage 23.07.2026 44min

  Craig and Big Mac criticize the NBA for delaying the season schedule release to accommodate LeBron James' free agency. They also analyze the Yankees' trade deadline needs and recount the origin of Aaron Rodgers' family feud. 01:20 - Football Scent In The Air 03:06 - Yankees Pitching And Offense 05:45 - NBA Schedule LeBron Drama 16:20 - Therapy For Mets Fans 19:50 - Big Mac's Gotham No-Show 24:00 - Yankees Trade Deadline Talk 39:25 - Aaron Rodgers' Family Feud 44:20 - Open Door Policy Debate
• 
  Hour 2: Carton Slams Mets for "Hubris" and High Parking Fees 23.07.2026 1h 4min

  Craig Carton and C-Mac tear into the New York Mets' ticket pricing strategies and the organization's disconnect from its fan base. They analyze current StubHub prices for future games and discuss Pete Alonso's anticipated return to Citi Field with the Baltimore Orioles. Additionally, the conversation shifts to media industry egos and Craig's review of the film, The Odyssey. 01:50 - Summer Sun And Shaving 07:48 - Media Egos And Retirements 17:10 - Mets Ticket Price Analysis 23:46 - Pete Alonso Return To Queens 31:12 - Carton Reviews The Odyssey 44:09 - LeBron James NBA Hostage 50:05 - Rant Against Station Management 58:08 - Parking And Concession Issues 01:02:48 - Carton New Weed Strain
• 
  Hour 3: Nancy Armour's 'Dumbest Column Ever' on Caitlin Clark & Emmett Till 23.07.2026 54min

  Craigie and Big Mac slam Nancy Armour’s controversial column linking Caitlin Clark to the memory of Emmett Till. They also preview an upcoming interview with Plaxico Burris where he debunks myths about his 2008 shooting incident. The conversation concludes with a deep dive into classic films and iconic Brooklyn food destinations. 01:50 - Nancy Armour's Column 09:14 - Emmett Till Comparison 17:10 - Plaxico Burris Story 30:04 - Racism Debate Caller 41:03 - John Fusco's Filmography 46:34 - Brooklyn Food Crawl 55:26 - Bay Ridge Weed Talk
• 
  Hour 4: Giants Training Camp: Malik Nabors' Health and the Jaxson Dart Era 23.07.2026 49min

  Chris McMonigle analyzes the start of New York Giants training camp and the news that Malik Nabors will not begin on the PUP list. He evaluates the pressure on Jaxson Dart as the new franchise quarterback and discusses the challenge of shifting the team's losing culture under the current coaching staff. The conversation also touches on Eli Manning's Hall of Fame credentials and recent news regarding Brett Favre's health. 01:24 - Malik Nabors Training Status 04:30 - Jaxson Dart Franchise Pressure 09:10 - Giants Schedule Analysis 12:45 - Coaching Culture and Speeches 16:15 - Brett Favre Health News 19:45 - Giants Offensive Strategy 25:30 - Defensive Roster Evaluation 29:30 - Restoring the Giants Identity 36:50 - Eli Manning Hall of Fame
• 
  Big Mac's Power Trip & A Brooklyn "Weed Buffet"?! 23.07.2026 13min

  Craig Carton returns to the studio only to find out that Big Mac completely lost his mind while hosting the show!
• 
  Craig Carton DESTROYS "Patently Stupid" Caitlin Clark Column & Plaxico Burress Debunks Sweatpants Myth! 23.07.2026 20min

  Things get fiery on this segment of The Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle tackle a highly controversial sports column, and drop a massive New York Giants teaser!
• 
  "The Dumpling Shop!" Craig Carton is Creating His Own Weed Strain?! 23.07.2026 9min

  Craig Carton drops a massive, hilarious bombshell on Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle during this segment of The Carton Show!
• 
  Mets Fans Are Getting Ripped Off, The Carton Show Demands Justice 23.07.2026 8min

  Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the Mets’ struggling fan experience and ask whether Steve Cohen needs to do more to bring fans back to Citi Field. With the Mets struggling on the field, Craig argues the organization should lower ticket prices, parking costs, and concessions to show fans they understand their frustration. Would cheaper games, affordable food, and family-friendly pricing help get fans back in the stands?
• 
  Yankees Offense, LeBron's NBA Takeover & "The Odyssey" Review 23.07.2026 20min

  Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down everything happening in New York sports on the Carton Show. The Yankees are struggling at the plate, Aaron Judge's return remains uncertain, and Craig says Brian Cashman has to make major moves before the MLB Trade Deadline. Can the Yankees fix their offense in time?
• 
  Craig Carton TORCHES the Mets for Their Biggest Mistake Yet 23.07.2026 26min

  The Mets' disastrous 2026 season has reached a new low, and Craig Carton isn't holding back. Craig and Chris McMonigle break down why the Mets' decision to hold back second-half tickets completely backfired, how cheap Citi Field tickets have become, and why fans are walking away from their season tickets.
• 
  Yankees' Trade Deadline Is CLEAR: Fix the Offense or Forget the World Series! 23.07.2026 23min

  With the MLB Trade Deadline just days away, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down exactly what the Yankees need to do to become legitimate World Series contenders. Is pitching already good enough? Should Brian Cashman focus on bats instead? The guys debate the Yankees' biggest needs, including catcher, shortstop, bullpen help, and whether George Lombard deserves a shot in the Bronx. They also discuss Aaron Judge's return, Giancarlo Stanton's status, Cody Bellinger's struggles, and why the Yankees can't rely on their pitching staff to carry a lifeless offense all October.
• 
  Craig Carton ERUPTS Over LeBron Holding the NBA Hostage! 23.07.2026 22min

  Craig Carton sounds off on LeBron James and the NBA after the league delays releasing the 2026-27 schedule while waiting for LeBron's decision. Carton argues the defending NBA Champion New York Knicks deserve to be the center of attention—not a 43-year-old superstar deciding his next team.
• 
  Full Show: Craig Rips Cringe John Harbaugh Speech and Yankees Slump 22.07.2026 52min

  Craig and Big Mac dissect the New York Yankees' recent offensive slump, highlighting Cody Bellinger's lack of production and the team's listless performance. They also debate a viral clip of John Harbaugh's speech and discuss a rumor about the New York Jets moving their practice facility back to New York. 01:20 - Yankees Offensive Struggles 07:14 - Stanton Injury Update 10:55 - Harbaugh Speech Debate 24:00 - Koreatown Massage Story 30:18 - Jose Caballero Antics 35:36 - Military Perspective Debate 43:08 - Jets Relocation Rumor
• 
  Cody Bellinger Struggles, John Harbaugh & a SHOCKING Jets Rumor! 22.07.2026 26min

  It's a wild hour on The Carton Show! Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle rip into the Yankees' lifeless offense, question Cody Bellinger's disappointing season, debate John Harbaugh's viral Giants speech, and Craig drops a surprising rumor about the New York Jets potentially moving their practice facility back to New York. Plus, the guys take hilarious calls, react to ESPN's Ryan Clark situation, and go completely off the rails with classic Carton storytelling.
• 
  Craig Carton RIPS Yankees' Lifeless Offense & DESTROYS John Harbaugh's Giants Speech! 22.07.2026 15min

  The Yankees' offense has become painful to watch, and Craig Carton isn't holding back. Craig and Chris McMonigle break down another frustrating loss, rip Cody Bellinger's struggles, discuss Giancarlo Stanton's possible return, and debate whether Brian Cashman can save the lineup before the trade deadline. They also react to John Harbaugh's first speech to the New York Giants and Craig absolutely unloads, calling it one of the most embarrassing coach speeches he's ever heard. Do Giants fans have reason to worry already?
• 
  Full Show: Carton and Zach Gelb Debate Yankee Hopes & Jets' New White Uniforms 21.07.2026 2h 51min

  Craig Carton and Zach Gelb examine the New York Yankees' postseason outlook and the impact of Jazz Chisholm Jr. They discuss the New York Jets' new white-on-white uniforms and are joined by Jim Leyritz to reflect on his 2001 9/11 home run. The conversation also highlights Bobby Valentine’s take on Mets analytics and the messy firing of Ryan Clark from ESPN. 02:11 - Intro With Zach Gelb 06:45 - Yankees World Series Outlook 12:15 - Jets New White Uniforms 28:05 - Jim Leyritz Joins Segment 35:50 - AI Pitch Calling Debate 29:30 - Lionel Richie Concert Snub 16:10 - Bobby Burack Firing Analysis 19:15 - Bobby Valentine Joins Segment 30:35 - Hoffman Birthday Celebration
• 
  Hour 1: Jim Leyritz Blasts AI Pitch Calling and Anthony Volpe's Performance 21.07.2026 44min

  Zach Gelb joins to discuss the Yankees' momentum and Jazz Chisholm's dynamic role on the team. Former Yankee Jim Leyritz shares his perspective on the shift toward analytics and AI in baseball management. They also evaluate Anthony Volpe's development and debate the outlook for the Jets and Patriots in the AFC East. 01:20 - Zach Gelb Joins 04:53 - Baseball Fights Debate 09:53 - Jazz Chisholm Impact 13:16 - Jets Uniform Reveal 16:55 - AFC East Predictions 27:35 - Jim Leyritz Interview 37:03 - AI Pitch Calling 42:35 - Anthony Volpe Struggles
• 
  Hour 2: Craig's Beef with Lionel Richie and the Return of Pig Spanking 21.07.2026 39min

  Craig and Zach Gelb praise the Yankees' handling of a rainout before airing a personal grievance against Lionel Richie for a late concert cancellation. They debate the musical legacy of Bruce Springsteen and Bob Dylan while confirming the return of the Pig Spanking tradition at MetLife Stadium. The conversation also explores awkward fan interactions and viral social media challenges. 01:20 - Yankees Rainout Comparison 05:00 - Lionel Richie Grievance 08:15 - Bruce Springsteen Debate 16:10 - Fan Interaction Criticisms 20:30 - Bathroom Encounter Stories 26:00 - Dawkins Watermelon Challenge 30:25 - Pig Spanking Returns 34:30 - Pink Floyd Dead Air 39:40 - Dramatic Radio Exits