Talking Talmud
Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon
0
Talking Talmud is a podcast that explores the daily Talmud page (daf) with insights and discussion. Hosted by Yardaena Osband and Anne Gordon, it offers a taste of the daf for both those learning and those curious about Talmud study. The podcast invites listeners to join the conversation and deepen their understanding of Jewish texts.
Episodes
-
Erkhin 2: People's Worth 19.11.2026 18mAn introduction to the tractate on "valuations" -- how much given people are worth, as per standardized values from the Torah. Starting with the first mishnah! Everyone valuates and is valuated -- "everyone," with some exceptions. Also, who does that "everyone" come to include? Note that every time the term "all," or everyone" appears, it is designed to include those whom we might have thought would be excluded. -
Bekhorot 61: Tithing Via Representative 18.11.2026 12mIn the case of 2 animals that leave the pen together - simultaneously, as the tenth (and technically also the eleventh), perhaps they should all be treated as sanctified. Alternatively, they will all be eaten in the blemished state, as stipulated. Or, lastly, they would all need to be left to die. With careful attention paid to the count. Also, the case of a shaliach -- representative -- for tithing one's animals. And what if the shaliach makes an error in the count? -
Bekhorot 60: Errors in Counting the Tithe 17.11.2026 18mThe final mishnah! Two animals that come out as one -- from the pen, when one is trying to count out the tithe -- can mess up the count, because the 11th might be counted as the 10th, and so on, with the mix-up of two exiting at the same time. Ditto the 9th. Note the dispute between Rabbi Meir and Rabbi Yehudah, with the latter's concern about a substitute animal functioning as a substitute already. Also, can the designation of consecrated for the tithe be transferred, and if so, how? Or is the mistake established and that's it? Plus, the fact that there's no need for a general principle to de... -
Bekhorot 59: Fit to Be Tithed 16.11.2026 19mOn the view that the tenth animal is automatically consecrated as the tithe. But what if one calls the ninth one "the tenth"? The ninth would be eaten in a blemished state, and the tenth would be considered the tithe. Note that what the owner calls each animal in the count has impact on the consecration of the tenth. Also, the case of the owner of 14 lambs, all of which are in the pen for counting the tithe. Then 6 leave one side of the pen and 10 leave the other side, which is 10, but they aren't together, so they don't combine for the tithe. With other permutations of the same, of course. -
Bekhorot 58: Counting Ten 15.11.2026 17mMore on the 3x/year of tithing animals, and the debate over "2 weeks before Pesach" vs. the 29th of Adar, which may turn out to be the same day or may be a day off, depending on the year. Plus, gearing up for the Elul/Tishrei tithing, and the debate over the last day of Elul vs. the first day of Tishrei, which isn't eligible, because tithing is prohibited on the holiday (Rosh Hashanah). Also, a new mishnah, on the process of tithing -- counting them off. Enticing the animals might involve convincing them to follow their mothers or to go for food -- but with care taken to keep tithed animals fr... -
Bekhorot 57: Coming Together to Be Tithed 14.11.2026 21mAnother 2 mishnayot! 1 - All the animals are gathered in a pen to be tithed. Except for those that are not -- for example, those that are exempt from being tithed. Plus, the source text that provides for the exceptions. Also, on the case of a mother that dies with her hide intact, and wrapping its infant if need be. 2 - 3 dates are designated for tithing animals - Nisan, Sivan, and Elul/Tishrei. But when does the animal tithing year began? Given the salience for how many animals are tithed when. And whether they can be counted together, to reach the tithing. This entails designating the tenth... -
Bekhorot 56: Gifts, Inheritance, and the Animal Tithe 13.11.2026 16m2 mishnayot! 1 - Someone who buys an untithed animal or is given one as a gift does not need to include that animal in his own tithing. Plus, the case of one who bought animals in utero -- they would be tithed. But isn't that a contradiction?! Consider the implications for the animal not being fit for tithing at the time of purchase. 2 - When brothers are partners and inherit from their father, they need to add a premium to their census tax, but not for the animal tithe. Note the term "kalbon," as the premium census fee. Now, if these brothers inherited adult animals and baby animals -- say, g... -
Bekhorot 55: The Jordan River and the Source of Blood 12.11.2026 19mIf the animals are grazing on different sides of the Jordan River, they cannot be combined for the purpose of tithing. Which leads the Gemara to a long detour of reflection on the Jordan River, including its role as a border (or not) for the land of Canaan. Also, the source of the Jordan - in the Cave of Pamyas, where an oath about the water at the source may well have impact on the permissibility about the entire rest of the river. Plus, the supposition that the source of blood is the liver (it's marrow, but it's true that the liver is home to more blood than other organs). And the source of... -
Bekhorot 54: Mixing and Matching 11.11.2026 21mMore on not combining most species for tithing -- with the explicit exception of sheep and goats. The biblical source for this brings us back to terumah (and ma'aser) on different species. Plus, the implications of actual "kilayim," mixtures of the different species -- and when that prohibition would be violated. Also, a new mishnah! On the distance that the flocks could be apart from each other and still join together for the count of the tithing: 16 "mil" [What's What: A "mil"]. -
Bekhorot 53: Tithing the Flocks 10.11.2026 15mChapter 9! On tithing animals... and the verses from the Torah that prescribe this fairly broad mitzvah, throughout the world and regardless of whether the Temple stands. Sacrificial animals, however, are not part of the tithe. "Herds" (cattle and so on) cannot be tithed in a group that includes various species, however, when it comes to "flocks," even sheep and goat, can combine for tithing purposes. And not "new" and "old" together... Plus, diving deeper into combining species and into the old/new restriction, using a fortiori logic. Also, can the tithing of animals be compared to the tithin... -
Bekhorot 52: A Double-Portion 09.11.2026 14m2 mishnayot: 1 - A first-born son receives a double-inheritance from his father's property, though not his mother's property. (Note: The potential modern will complications (which are largely avoidable, but still) would be in Israel, not elsewhere). But improvements to the property after the father's death and other kinds of property would not be counted as a double portion. Nor a woman receiving her ketubah, nor daughters receiving mezonot, nor a yavam. 2 - During a jubilee year (yovel), the land reverts, but there are exceptions -- including the double-portion of the first-born. Note the Gem... -
Bekhorot 51: Rabbi Tarfon Gave Back the Money 08.11.2026 13m2 mishnayot! 1 - Redemption of the first-born son has to be done via the 5 silver coins (not via objects or land or promissory notes). Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi says - Anything but promissory notes would work, which indicates that his view is not the view of the mishnah. 2 - If the father paid the coins at once, that fulfills the obligation, but what if he handed them over one by one, or to several kohanim? Or if the kohen takes the payment and then returns it? Note how wealthy Rabbi Tarfon didn't keep the coins. -
Bekhorot 50: Mathing the Math (with Unholy Coins) 07.11.2026 16mOn the 5 silver coins for the redemption of the first-born son, and how they were valuated in other currencies. Which meant getting the math exactly right -- as the example of Rav Ashi sending to R. Acha, who was a kohen, and they need to send back and forth to get the currency exactly right. From the money/coins of the pidyon ha-ben -- when the dedicated coinage to the Temple, there was concern that the Hadrianic and Trajan coins would be all mixed up and profaned that money. Then a verse in Ezekiel calmed the sages down, because it was no longer considered to be consecrated. But there's so m... -
Bekhorot 49: 30 Days to Redemption, Right? 06.11.2026 20mMore mishnayot! 1 - If the first-born son dies within 30 days of birth, there's no redemption to pay and the kohen would return any payment that was already made. After 30 days, the father owes the payment. But what about on the 30th day? 2 - If the father dies, the presumption is that the child is or is not redeemed, based on the timing of the death, compared to those 30 days. What about a first-born father who discovers he himself was never redeemed? Which redemption takes precedence? Note the standard roles in dispute of Rav and Shmuel. Plus, the prevalence, or lack thereof of pidunei ha-be... -
Bekhorot 48: Redeeming Twins 05.11.2026 17mTwo mishnayot! 1 - A woman gives birth to male twins, and it's not known which of them is the first born, the father gives the coins to the kohen, because one of them needs to be redeemed. But what if one of them dies before 30 days? Or after 30 days? Of if the twins are male and female, and you don't know which was born first? What if it's the father who died? Plus, the case of two people with the same name, and how the adjudicate claims against one of them. 2 - If a man has two wives, and each gives birth to a male baby, the father needs to redeem both of them. But what if one dies within 30... -
Bekhorot 47: Who Need Redemption? 04.11.2026 13mMore on the human first-borns -- who is exempt from the need to redeem the first born. The son of a woman from the Tribe of Levi -- but if her husband a kohen or a levi, the child would already not need redemption. So is the father a Yisrael? A non-Jew? Also, would a kohen need to redeem himself? For example, a kohen who has set the kehunah apart from himself. And: a new mishnah! With the kind of first-born statuses for inheritance and for the kohen. Where a miscarriage is explicitly not considered to be a birth. What about a first-born who was delivered by C-section? And what if there is anot... -
Bekhorot 46: Opening the Womb 03.11.2026 21mFinishing out the 7th chapter, about the blemishes among human beings: kohanim need to commit to not making themselves come in contact with a dead body. How is that different from marrying a person who is prohibited to the kohanim? And starting the 8th chapter -- on the process of redeeming the first-born son -- in the new mishnah! Or rather, there are different statuses for which one may or may not be called the first born, such as the inheritance and also for the kohen. With some complicated cases about premature births. Also, defining the moment of birth -- when the forehead emerges, even i... -
Bekhorot 45: If a Blemish Is Corrected, Is It Still a Blemish? 02.11.2026 19mMore blemishes, but some of them are the kind of things that, nowadays, we correct fairly easily (bowleggedness, for example). Or a kohen with an extra digit -- which is not common, but not uncommon either, with a significant genetic component. Nowadays, they are easily removed. Or less changeable, perhaps, but also less identifiable as a blemish these days, like left-handedness. Plus, the question of how many bones are in the human body. Also, other "full-body" exemptions from being able to serve -- blemishes, of a kind, such as drunkenness, among others -- that disqualify a person from servi... -
Bekhorot 44: When You Gotta Go, You Gotta Go 01.11.2026 23mCases of disqualification of kohanim from doing the Temple service for all kinds of eye blemishes, from blindness to pale spots on the eyes or excess tears -- and how they are derived from the verses in Leviticus. Also, mishnayot! 1 - Blemishes that are unsightly physical blemishes, including eyes and other parts of the face. Plus, an assessment of Moshe's height -- based on that of the Tabernacle, so perhaps he was 10 amot high, which would have been too tall, and indeed a blemish of disproportion. 2- Additional blemishes - if a man has breasts that distend like those of a woman; if his stoma... -
Bekhorot 43: From Animal Blemishes to Priestly Blemishes 31.10.2026 16mBlemishes that disqualify kohanim from doing the Temple service -- derived from the verses in Leviticus. There are 3 categories of blemishes -- 1. appear in kohanim and animals; 2. appear in kohanim and not animals. 3. rabbinic disqualifications, especially as "mar'it ayin," in terms of unusual appearances. Including, for example, baldness, where some degree of hair loss is acceptable, but not entirely. Connecting blemishes of a person and those of an animal, even though we often distinguish between humans and animals -- as found in a gezerah shavah from the words in the Torah's verses. Also,...
Popular in
The podcast also appears in the podcast charts of these countries.