Courtroom Confidential
Joshua Ritter
0
Courtroom Confidential is a weekly podcast hosted by Joshua Ritter, a former Los Angeles County prosecutor now working as a criminal defense attorney. Each episode covers the latest developments in high-profile criminal cases across the United States. Joshua offers analysis and context on the evolving legal landscape, drawing on his professional experience. The show aims to help listeners better understand how the legal system operates.
Episodes
-
Dwain Hall: 5 Things to Know About the Sonia Exelby Murder Case 18.11.2026 47mSonia Exelby traveled from England to Florida to meet a man she knew online. Days later, investigators found her buried in a shallow grave. Dwain Hall claims she wanted to die, but messages she sent a friend describe fear, pain and a belief that she couldn’t escape. Joshua Ritter is joined by Angenette Levy, host of Law&Crime’s Crime Fix, to break down five things you need to know about the Dwain Hall murder case. They examine Sonia’s background, the timeline of her disappearance, Hall’s... -
Lindsay Clancy Will Face a New Jury. What Changes This Time? 17.11.2026 1h 16mLindsay Clancy’s retrial is set for March 29. What could change when the case goes before a new jury? Criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter opens tonight’s show with his solo breakdown of the hearing, what the Commonwealth and defense might do differently after the mistrial, and what could still affect the court’s timeline. Then, Angenette Levy of Law & Crime’s Crime Fix joins Josh to preview the Florida trial of Dwain Hall, who has pleaded not guilty to first-deg... -
Alex Murdaugh’s Defense Says the Grand Jury Was Misled. Could It Undo the Case? 14.11.2026 40mAlex Murdaugh’s defense says misleading blood-spatter testimony helped secure his murder indictment. Could that justify dismissal, and why might he still face trial even if the defense succeeds? Broadcasting from Walterboro, South Carolina, criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter breaks down the November 13 hearing, Jim Griffin’s argument, Creighton Waters’ response and the significance of the judge’s questions about the planned April retrial. Jump to 9:37 for the dispu... -
Charlie Kirk Murder Trial Set for 2028. Why the Long Wait? Plus, Lindsay Clancy Denied & Matthew Farwell Jury Deadlocked 10.11.2026 31mJury selection in Tyler Robinson’s trial over the killing of Charlie Kirk is set for June 21, 2028. Why the long wait, and why has Judge Tony Graf reserved 105 court days? Joining from Utah, criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter questions the timeline and examines the competing demands of trial preparation, a capital prosecution and the Kirk family’s wait for justice. At 11:28, Josh examines the denial of Lindsay Clancy’s motion to dismiss, the proposed investigation ... -
True Crime Q&A: Matthew Farwell, Naresh Bhatt, OJ Simpson, Lindsay Clancy and More! 09.11.2026 2h 3mCould Matthew Farwell have been better off putting his case before a judge instead of a jury? Criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter answers your Sunday Funday Q&A questions about bench trials, who must agree to them, and the federal issue at the heart of the prosecution over Sandra Birchmore’s death. Also in this episode: Naresh Bhatt’s testimony and why admitting conduct does not automatically require a guilty plea; Lindsay Clancy’s custody after a mistrial and t... -
Naresh Bhatt Admits Hiding Mamta’s Body. Can Jurors Believe His Explanation? 07.11.2026 1h 5mNaresh Bhatt admits dismembering and concealing his wife Mamta Kafle Bhatt’s body, but denies killing her. Criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter welcomes Paul from Reporting Live From My Sofa to examine Bhatt’s changed account, his explanation for not calling 911 and the cross-examination confronting his earlier lies. What do those admissions establish, and what must prosecutors still prove? At 36:11, Josh breaks down the closing arguments in Matthew Farwell’s federal... -
Matthew Farwell: The Defense Rests. Did Prosecutors Prove Their Case? 05.11.2026 1h 9mMatthew Farwell’s defense rested on November 4 without calling the former police detective to testify. Federal prosecutors allege Farwell killed Sandra Birchmore and staged her death. His defense disputes that account. Criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter examines the competing expert opinions and what the forensic evidence can tell jurors about how Birchmore died. In Virginia, Naresh Bhatt took the stand in his own defense against the charge that he murdered his wif... -
Lindsay Clancy: What’s Standing Between Her and a Second Trial? With Special Guests Billy Bush & Nate Eaton 03.11.2026 50mLindsay Clancy’s November 2 hearing ended with major questions still unresolved. Criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter welcomes Billy Bush, host of Hot Mics with Billy Bush, to examine the defense’s effort to prevent a retrial, the Commonwealth’s response and the dispute over questioning the holdout juror. They also discuss Kevin Reddington’s courtroom approach, juror privacy and the proposed gag order ahead of the November 16 status hearing. At 26:09, East Idaho News... -
Matthew Farwell: Her Phone Went Silent. Can the Defense Explain Why? With Special Guest Randolph Rice 30.10.2026 58mSandra Birchmore’s final recorded phone activity came minutes before Matthew Farwell left her apartment building, according to testimony discussed in this episode. What does that timeline establish, and how could the defense challenge its significance? Criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter joins attorney Randolph Rice to examine the competing interpretations, William Kilroy’s testimony and the defense’s effort to raise reasonable doubt. Farwell has pleaded not guilty. ... -
Michelle Parker: Ex-Fiancé Arrested Nearly 15 Years After Mom Vanished. What Changed? With Special Guest David Mack 28.10.2026 59mNearly 15 years after Michelle Parker vanished, what finally changed in the case against her former fiancé? Criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter joins investigative reporter and Body Bags podcast co-host Dave Mack to examine the newly unsealed arrest affidavit, the disputed timeline, phone evidence and questions surrounding the original investigation. Dale Smith Jr. has pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder. Parker’s body has never been found. Then, Josh examine... -
Matthew Farwell, D4vd, Laura Owens, Faith Hedgepeth & More! True Crime Q&A 26.10.2026 1h 44mTrue crime, legal analysis, and YOUR questions—LIVE! Criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter answers viewer questions on the biggest cases in true crime. Want to ask Josh your true crime legal question for next Sunday Funday? Get your questions in before 11:59pm PT Friday! Click the tab on the right side here: https://www.thecourtroomconfidential.com/ Sunday Funday Playlist: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLiteA2x_mfo3H6cFS91S0tBu600tjCeFJ&si=Afeir78gpaWnjK8K C... -
Faith Hedgepeth Trial: Guilty. Why the Defense Couldn’t Shake the Evidence with Special Guests Elyse Hershon & Scott of Recovery Addict 24.10.2026 1h 6mMiguel Salguero-Olivares has been found guilty in the murder of Faith Hedgepeth. After a trial centered on DNA evidence, disputed testimony and questions about the investigation, Joshua Ritter welcomes Scott from Recovery Addict to break down the verdict, assess the defense’s strategy of calling no witnesses, and discuss the questions that remain. Then, Boston criminal defense attorney Elyse Hershon joins Josh to discuss the Matthew Farwell trial, including testimony from the father of Sandr... -
Faith Hedgepeth: No Defense Witnesses. Will the Strategy Work? With Special Guests Scott of Recovery Addict & R.J. Dreiling 22.10.2026 55mTaking care of your health just got easier, thanks to my sponsor Zocdoc — start here at: https://zocdoc.com/courtroomconfidential ✅ Jump to the Faith Hedgepeth discussion: 26:45. The defense rested without calling a single witness. What can its lawyers still accomplish in closing? Joshua Ritter and Scott of Recovery Addict examine the decision not to present witnesses, the risks of putting the defendant on the stand, and whether prosecutors’ efforts to establish a connection between Miguel ... -
Faith Hedgepeth: The State Rested. Did It Leave Too Many Questions? With Special Guests Gavin Fish and Deana Harley 20.10.2026 1h 9mThe prosecution has rested in the Faith Hedgepeth murder trial, but did it leave the defense an opening? CBS 17 reporter Deana Harley joins criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter to examine the DNA evidence, unanswered questions about Miguel Salguero-Olivares’ connection to Faith, and the revelation that a computer image discussed as handwriting evidence was actually an internet meme. Which gaps could matter to jurors, and which leave the prosecution’s strongest evidenc... -
Can a Holdout Juror Be Removed? Lindsay Clancy, Christa Pike, Matthew Farwell & More! True Crime Q&A 19.10.2026 2h 11mCan a juror be removed for refusing to agree with everyone else? Criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter answers viewer questions about the Lindsay Clancy juror controversy, the distinction between disagreement and misconduct, and the challenges of protecting jurors in a closely watched case. In this Sunday Funday Q&A, Josh also explores the difference between “not guilty” and “innocent,” questions surrounding Christa Pike’s failed execution, the federal case agains... -
Alex Murdaugh Gets DNA Testing. Could It Backfire? 17.10.2026 24mAlex Murdaugh’s defense has been allowed to pursue additional testing of DNA recovered from beneath Maggie Murdaugh’s fingernails. But could finding an answer weaken the defense instead of helping it? Criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter explains why unidentified DNA can create an argument for reasonable doubt, and why identifying its source could change that argument. On location in Lexington, South Carolina, Josh breaks down the October 16 hearing, including the DN... -
Faith Hedgepeth: A Second Bottle Puts the Defense Under Pressure With Special Guest Joel Waldman of Surviving The Survivor 15.10.2026 1h 6mMiguel Salguero-Olivares denied knowing Faith Hedgepeth, but jurors have now heard testimony linking his palm print and thumbprint to a wine bottle found in her bedroom. What do those matches establish, and what remains unresolved? Criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter welcomes Joel Waldman of Surviving the Survivor to examine the latest evidence and the defense’s response. Also, Fox News Digital’s Michael Ruiz discusses the cancellation of Bryan Kohberger’s upcoming ... -
Matthew Farwell: Could His Opening Statement Come Back to Haunt Him? 13.10.2026 1h 5mDid Matthew Farwell’s defense open the door to testimony from three other women? Federal prosecutors are challenging his attorney’s opening statement, asking to introduce evidence of other alleged affairs and accusing the defense of citing text messages they say do not exist. What could these disputes mean for the jury and the case over Sandra Birchmore’s death? Criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter is joined by attorney Randolph Rice to examine the prosecution’s new ... -
Did a Police Detective Stage Sandra Birchmore’s Death? Matthew Farwell Trial - Opening Statements 10.10.2026 55mSandra Birchmore’s death was initially attributed to self-harm. Federal prosecutors now allege former police detective Matthew Farwell killed her and staged the scene, while his defense argues he went to her apartment to end their relationship and did not cause her death. Criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter compares the competing opening statements, including Birchmore’s final texts, surveillance footage of Farwell’s arrival, the alleged motive and the limits of the... -
Matthew Farwell Trial: 5 Things to Know About the Sandra Birchmore Murder Case 09.10.2026 12m23-year-old Sandra Birchmore was eight to ten weeks pregnant when she was found dead in her Massachusetts apartment. Her death was initially ruled a suic*de, but federal prosecutors now allege that former Stoughton police officer Matthew Farwell killed her to prevent her from exposing years of alleged sexual abuse and misconduct. In this episode of Five Things You Need to Know, criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor Joshua Ritter breaks down the people, timeline, and evidence at the...
Popular in
The podcast also appears in the podcast charts of these countries.