Delphi Murders: Richard Allen & The Search For The Truth
True Crime Today
0
This podcast investigates the Delphi murders of Abby Williams and Liberty German, focusing on the controversial conviction of Richard Allen. Host Tony Brueski examines alleged failures in the investigation, including ignored evidence and a potentially flawed judicial process. The show features interviews and expert analysis, questioning whether the right person was convicted.
Episodes
-
Delphi: The Investigation That Lost Its Own Evidence and Still Got a Conviction 16.10.2026 56mThis is the complete four-part docu-series covering the Delphi case from the bridge to the appeal. Every lead the investigation buried. Every piece of evidence the jury never heard. And the case the system built from what was left.Part one: two girls walk onto the Monon High Bridge on February 13, 2017. Libby German's phone captures a man's voice and image. The only person who comes forward is cleared by a ghost and lost in a drawer for five years. A composite sketch runs on every billboard for two years before police reverse course. The FBI serves a warrant on the property owner — sealed and... -
Delphi: Judge Gull Excluded Everything. What She Did Before the Appeal Is Worse. 15.10.2026 15mThree appellate judges are now reading the briefs, the surveillance footage, and nine years of investigative decisions in the Delphi case of Richard Allen. They will decide whether Allen received a fair trial or whether the state of Indiana built a conviction on a foundation of failures.On September 21, 2026, those judges heard oral arguments. Defense attorney Mark Leeman argued the state put Allen — a man with depression and dependent personality disorder — into solitary confinement for thirteen months and watched him lose his mind, then walked his confessions into a courtroom.Judge Elaine Br... -
Richard Allen Gave Over 60 Confessions From Solitary. Not All of Them Helped Indiana. 14.10.2026 14mIn October 2022, Richard Allen voluntarily surrendered to police in connection with the murders of Abby Williams and Libby German. He weighed roughly a hundred and eighty pounds. He was a CVS pharmacy clerk. He had no criminal record. He had told a conservation officer in 2017 that he was on the trail that afternoon.The state placed him in Westville Correctional Facility — a state prison — in a maximum-security segregated unit. Solitary confinement. A twelve-by-eight-and-a-half-foot cell. One hour of recreation five days a week. A correctional officer stationed outside his door around the cloc... -
Kegan Kline Failed His Delphi Polygraph. His Phone Search Said the Rest. 13.10.2026 16mBefore Richard Allen was arrested in October 2022, the Delphi investigation had already found other people the evidence pointed to. The defense's Franks memorandum — a hundred and thirty-six pages filed in September 2023 — lays out who they were and what the investigation found.One man's son was dating Abby Williams at the time of the murders. According to the filing, he was a self-described follower of Norse pagan beliefs and posted imagery on social media that allegedly matched symbols found at the crime scene. Knowledge of those symbols was never made public. Another man allegedly confessed... -
Richard Allen Told Police He Was on That Bridge. One Word Made His Name Disappear. 12.10.2026 12mThe Delphi investigation had forty-two thousand tips, an FBI search warrant with probable cause on the property owner, a recording of a man's voice saying three words to two girls on a bridge, and the only person who ever came forward to say he was there that day. It lost nearly all of it.Richard Allen told a conservation officer three days after the February 2017 murders that he had been on the Monon High Bridge trail that afternoon. The tip was entered into the system. Someone wrote one word across the form in red ink. Cleared. It went into a desk drawer and disappeared for five years.The FB... -
Richard Allen Appeal: The Other Suspect, the Bullet and the Sketch 04.10.2026 33mThe Delphi appeal now asks the Indiana Court of Appeals to examine not only what the jury heard about Richard Allen, but what Judge Frances Gull kept out. Defense attorney Bob Motta joins Tony Brueski for a combined look at the Brad Holder alternate-suspect argument, the unfired cartridge evidence, William Tobin’s excluded expert testimony, and Betsy Blair’s missing sketch.Holder was investigated during the original 2017 Delphi murders investigation and has never been charged. At the September 21, 2026 oral argument, Allen’s appellate lawyer Mark Leeman said police later learned of a rune-like... -
Richard Allen's Appeal Put Westville Under the Microscope 03.10.2026 53mThis Delphi Channel special is a combination of the “Before the Appeal” commentary followed by discussion of the appeal hearing with defense attorney Bob Motta. The first section lays out Richard Allen’s appellate claims before oral argument. The second returns after the September 21 hearing to examine which issues the judges themselves chose to press.Allen’s lawyers are asking the Indiana Court of Appeals for a new trial after his conviction for the 2017 murders of Abby Williams and Libby German. Their confinement argument centers on the months Allen spent in restrictive housing at Westville... -
Delphi Appeal: Three Judges Heard the State Call Richard Allen's Cell This 01.10.2026 1h 1mThe full Delphi murders appeal hearing, argued September 21, 2026, in the Supreme Court courtroom at the Indiana Statehouse, broken down clip by clip with defense attorney Bob Motta. Judges Nancy Vaidik, Elaine Brown, and Robert Altice gave each side 30 minutes and then some. What the state's lawyer called Richard Allen's thirteen months at Westville is the line that frames everything else.Mark Leeman opened for Allen by calling the proceedings unprecedented, unfair, and unconstitutional: a pretrial detainee taken straight to the hole, kept there as he lost his mind, and convicted on what he s... -
Delphi Case Without Richard Allen's Confessions Comes Down to This 30.09.2026 14mAnyone who follows the Delphi murders case knows the two pillars: the unspent round and Bridge Guy. On September 21, 2026, both were argued in front of the Indiana Court of Appeals, and Richard Allen's lawyer told the judges that without the confessions, that's all the state has.The round first. An unfired .40-caliber cartridge was found in the ground between Abby Williams and Libby German, and Indiana State Police examiner Melissa Oberg testified it had been cycled through Allen's Sig Sauer P226. The defense wanted William Tobin, a former FBI metallurgist, to tell the jury the science behind... -
The Odinism Evidence Richard Allen's Jury Never Saw: A Tattoo Shaped Like This 30.09.2026 19mFor everyone who has followed the Delphi murders case since the Franks memo, this is the segment. On September 21, 2026, Richard Allen's appeal lawyer put the Odinism theory in front of the Indiana Court of Appeals, and the state had to answer it out loud.Mark Leeman told Judges Nancy Vaidik, Elaine Brown, and Robert Altice that Brad Holder was identified in two March 2017 tips and cleared on a landfill time card. Indiana State Police later learned, Leeman said, that Holder had published a bind rune drawn on his hand.In Leeman's telling, the rune combines two symbols into a shape that matches... -
Delphi: What Richard Allen's Prison Psychiatrist Put in Writing on April 14 30.09.2026 28mThe Delphi murders appeal of Richard Allen reached oral argument on September 21, 2026, and one document from Westville Correctional Facility did more work in that courtroom than any other: the psychiatrist's April 14, 2023 order.Judges Nancy Vaidik, Elaine Brown, and Robert Altice heard Mark Leeman describe what that order records. A prison psychiatrist who had not seen Allen for months came to his cell, found a man who could not communicate and had feces coming out of his mouth, and wrote that he was seriously mentally ill and gravely disabled. To medicate him by force, the doctor had to doc... -
A Judge Gave Indiana's 'Protection' of Richard Allen a New Name 24.09.2026 25mThe Indiana Court of Appeals asked the state on September 21, 2026, what would be left of the Delphi murders case without Richard Allen's confessions. Deputy Attorney General Ellen Meilaender had an answer ready: the most powerful evidence, she said, was Allen's own statement to police that he was on the trail walking toward the bridge on February 13, 2017. That is the case the state is prepared to defend if the confessions fall.The search warrant is the other pillar. Detective Tony Liggett's affidavit produced the Sig Sauer P226 from Allen's nightstand and, the state says, the match to the un... -
What Did Richard Allen Actually Say In His First Delphi Confession? 31.05.2026 42mHe didn't say "I did it." He said "I think I did it." That was Richard Allen's first confession to his wife — after five months in the most restrictive solitary cell in a maximum-security prison, after being diagnosed as gravely disabled and psychotic, after being forcibly injected with antipsychotics, after his weight dropped to 135 pounds, and after he started confusing nightmares with reality and believing he'd started World War III.Before solitary, Allen sat across from Detective Holeman during the arrest interrogation. According to defense filings, Holeman lied to him for over an hour. Al... -
Who Were The Delphi Suspects That Richard Allen's Jury Never Heard About? 31.05.2026 39mAccording to the defense's appellate filings, one suspect sat across from Delphi investigators four days after the murders and admitted to practicing pagan rituals involving bloodletting. He owned a .40 caliber firearm — the same caliber as the round found at the scene. They recorded his interview. The tape was erased. They never collected the gun. His employer offered surveillance footage to check his alibi. Officers declined and marked him cleared.In 2018, this suspect allegedly created a painting of Odin hanging upside down — right leg tucked behind the left. That is how one of the victims... -
Delphi: The Judge Blocked Everything That Told a Different Story Than the State's 29.05.2026 21mThe defense at Richard Allen's trial tried to introduce Blair's composite sketch of Bridge Guy — a man in his twenties with poofy hair, rated 10 out of 10 for accuracy, who looks nothing like Allen. Excluded. An expert to challenge the State's bullet methodology — excluded. Audio of Allen's psychotic episodes during solitary — excluded. Expert testimony that the confessions were false — excluded. A ritualistic crime expert to explain the crime scene — excluded. Evidence about alternative suspects connected to pagan rituals, the victim, and the crime scene symbolism — excluded. Evidence about t... -
Delphi: The State of Indiana Tortured Richard Allen For 13th Months To Force Confession 28.05.2026 27mBefore solitary confinement, Richard Allen told investigators he didn't do it. Said it repeatedly under pressure. Said it to his wife. Said it emphatically: "I am not going to say something I did not do." Five months later, his words to his wife had changed: "I think I did it." According to the defense filings, Allen had been held in the most restrictive solitary cell in Westville for thirteen months despite IDOC's thirty-day policy for inmates with his mental health diagnosis. He weighed 135 pounds. He was gravely disabled, psychotic, forcibly injected with antipsychotics. He confessed to sho... -
Delphi: The Affidavit Allegedly Said Bloody — The Witness Never Used That Word 27.05.2026 15mAccording to the appellant's brief, Detective Tony Liggett secured the search warrant against Richard Allen with an affidavit that allegedly omitted and altered key witness statements. Blair described Bridge Guy as a young man in his twenties with brown poofy hair and sketched a car that looked nothing like Allen's Ford Focus — details Liggett allegedly left out. Carbaugh reportedly said tan jacket and muddy; the affidavit allegedly read blue jacket, muddy and bloody. Blair and ISP both said on the record these were two different men. And Allen, according to the defense, never admitted to wear... -
Delphi: An ISP Trooper Raised the Alarm — His Superiors Shut It Down 26.05.2026 24mThe defense's appellate filings lay out what may be one of the most troubling chapters in the Delphi investigation: two men with documented connections to the victim, to pagan rituals, and to the symbolism at the crime scene — investigated so poorly that the evidence trail was destroyed before it could lead anywhere. One admitted to bloodletting rituals and owned a .40 caliber firearm matching the round at the scene. His interview was taped over. His gun was never collected. His alibi was based on a badge swipe that officers refused to verify with video that was offered to them. The other told... -
Delphi: Five Years of Lost Evidence, Ignored Tips, and Cleared Suspects 25.05.2026 23mWhen Richard Allen came forward voluntarily in February 2017, he told law enforcement he'd walked the Monon High Bridge Trail the same afternoon Abby and Libby disappeared. He answered their questions. He wasn't hiding. And then his report was filed under the wrong name and buried in a box until a volunteer found it in September 2022. According to the appellant's brief, that wasn't the only thing the investigation lost. A recorded interview with a suspect who admitted to practicing pagan bloodletting rituals and owning a .40 caliber firearm was taped over by Delphi Police. The weapon was never... -
What Happens to the Delphi Murder Weapon If the Search Warrant Gets Thrown Out? 17.05.2026 47mThe .40-caliber pistol is the centerpiece of the physical evidence against Richard Allen. The search warrant that produced it now faces de novo review at the Indiana Court of Appeals — meaning three judges owe no deference to Judge Fran Gull on that issue. If they rule the warrant was deficient, the weapon is gone. Not suppressed for this appeal. Gone from any retrial. Gone from the case permanently.Defense attorney Bob Motta walks through the de novo standard with Tony Brueski and what it means that this is the one issue where the appellate panel starts from scratch. He also addresses what th...
Popular in
The podcast also appears in the podcast charts of these countries.