Middle Men

Middle Men

Brendan O'Hara
Country USA
Language EN
Episodes 5
Latest 11.11.2026

Middle Men is a podcast created for men who don't fit neatly into society's straight or gay categories. The host, Brendan O'Hara, shares his own journey from identifying as straight to coming out as gay, and ultimately landing in the middle. The show offers a space without labels or judgment, where listeners can hear from other guys who understand their experience. It aims to build a community for those who feel caught between worlds, whether they are bi, curious, or simply unlabeled.

Episodes

  • He Skated With Madonna. Then His Partner's Drug Addiction Changed Everything - Ryan Allen Carrillo - #10
    He Skated With Madonna. Then His Partner's Drug Addiction Changed Everything - Ryan Allen Carrillo - #10 11.11.2026 1h 53m
    Ryan Allen Carrillo has skated with Madonna, broken world records, and raised three sons. But behind his extraordinary career is a story of family rejection, love, addiction, resilience, and learning when to choose yourself.In this episode of Middle Men, Ryan joins Brendan for a candid conversation about growing up as a Jehovah's Witness, coming out as gay at 21, and being shunned by his parents, who haven't spoken to him in 30 years.Now 51, Ryan is a three-time U.S. National Roller Figure Skating Champion, two-time world record holder, television personality, and entrepreneur who has performe...
  • I've Been Out for 25 Years. People Still Assume I'm Straight . — Ron Gray
    I've Been Out for 25 Years. People Still Assume I'm Straight . — Ron Gray 20.10.2026 1h 40m
    He's been openly gay for 25 years. He's comfortable with his sexuality. So why does 54-year-old Ron Gray still feel like he's searching for somewhere he belongs?In Episode 9 of Middle Men, Brendan sits down with Ron, a gay man living in rural Kentucky, for an honest conversation about sexuality, masculinity, friendship, loneliness, and the lifelong search for authentic connection.Ron shares what it was like discovering his attraction to men at 28, coming out to family and friends, and navigating everyday situations where people assume he's straight—even after 25 years of living openly as a gay...
  • Why It’s So Hard to Find Platonic Connection as a Gay or Bi Man | Michael Pezzullo
    Why It’s So Hard to Find Platonic Connection as a Gay or Bi Man | Michael Pezzullo 06.10.2026 1h 12m
    Has sex become the default language of connection among gay and bisexual men — and what happens when men want friendship, belonging, intimacy, and community without sex always being the entry point?In Episode 8 of Middle Men, Brendan sits down with therapist and life coach Michael Pezzullo for a candid conversation about gay men’s mental health, hypersexuality, loneliness, bisexuality, dating, masculinity, sexuality, identity, and the pressure some men feel to fit into a particular version of what it means to be gay or bi.They talk about why sex and physical attraction can sometimes get in the...
  • “It Took a Lot of Effort Not to Be Me” | Peter Marc Jacobson
    “It Took a Lot of Effort Not to Be Me” | Peter Marc Jacobson 23.09.2026 1h 21m
    Peter Marc Jacobson spent nearly 20 years married to Fran Drescher. Their love was real. Their sex life was real. So was his attraction to men.In Episode 7 of the Middle Men Podcast, Peter joins me for a candid conversation about what it was like growing up at a time when the only options seemed to be straight or gay, and spending years trying to make his actual experience fit into one of those boxes.Peter talks about the guilt and constant self-monitoring that came with being attracted to men while loving his wife, telling Fran that he thought he might be bisexual, entering gay spaces for the...
  • "My Wife Knew I Was Bisexual—But I Still Hid in Plain Sight" - Seth Duffy
    "My Wife Knew I Was Bisexual—But I Still Hid in Plain Sight" - Seth Duffy 09.09.2026 1h 29m
    Seth Duffy’s wife knew he was bisexual before they got married. But for years, Seth still felt like he had to bury part of himself — living publicly straight, privately questioning where he belonged, and never feeling completely at home in either straight or gay spaces.In this episode of Middle Men, Seth talks openly about growing up with attraction to both men and women, exploring that attraction as a teenager, getting married, being unexpectedly outed to his family on Facebook, dating both women and men, and what it’s like to constantly feel like you have to “edit” yourself depending on the...
  • Why Dating Apps Don’t Always Fix Loneliness | What We’re Really Searching For
    Why Dating Apps Don’t Always Fix Loneliness | What We’re Really Searching For 26.08.2026 17m
    Dating apps can give us more access to other people than ever before — so why do so many men still feel lonelyResearch on men who use dating and hookup apps suggests that spending more time searching doesn’t necessarily lead to more partners or more fulfillment. And among the men finding Middle Men, the same deeper need keeps showing up: not simply sex, but connection, understanding, and a place where they can be fully known.In this episode, I explore the dating-app loop — why Grindr, Scruff, Sniffies, Tinder, and other apps can keep us searching long after we’ve gotten what we originally open...
  • Why I never Felt Gay Enough — And What I Did About It
    Why I never Felt Gay Enough — And What I Did About It 05.08.2026 14m
    You can come out as gay and still feel like you don’t belong in the gay community.I know because I lived openly as a gay man for about 15 years—and still never felt fully at home in the most visible gay spaces available to me.According to the anonymous Middle Men Survey, I’m far from alone. Only 1 out of 24 gay and queer respondents said he felt very at home in the mainstream gay community. More than 45% said they didn’t really feel like they fit within the mainstream gay scene.Coming out of the closet and finding a home are not always the same thing.In this episode, I explore why coming out d...
  • You Don't Have to Pick a Side | Sexuality Is a Spectrum
    You Don't Have to Pick a Side | Sexuality Is a Spectrum 28.07.2026 9m
    You've been told your whole life that you have to pick a side. Straight or gay. One or the other.You don't. Not anymore.Sexuality runs on a spectrum, and it can evolve and change over time. I know because I've experienced it myself. And there's a place for the millions of guys like us out there who don't fit neatly into "straight" or "gay."In this episode I get into where that pressure to pick a side actually comes from; my personal experience of living a straight life, then a gay life, then landing somewhere in the middle; the challenges that accompany living life in the middle; and how to fi...
  • I Think I Might Be Bi. Now What? | What Nobody Tells You
    I Think I Might Be Bi. Now What? | What Nobody Tells You 21.07.2026 7m
    If you've ever typed "am I bi" into a search bar at 1am and then deleted your search history afterward, this one's for you.You're not the only one. Not even close.In this episode I get into the actual data on how many men live somewhere between "straight" and "gay" — the numbers that prove you're not rare, broken, or alone — and what the questioning actually feels like from someone who's lived it. Then, where to go from here: no label required, no coming out, no telling anyone anything.Maybe your life looks straight on the outside but isn’t as straight on the inside. Maybe you're bi or gay but...
  • I Lived Straight, Then Gay. Then I Landed in the Middle.
    I Lived Straight, Then Gay. Then I Landed in the Middle. 14.07.2026 13m
    I lived a straight life. Then I lived a gay life. Both were real. Then I kept going and landed somewhere in the middle, and that feels right. But it's not without its challenges.This is my story: growing up closeted in the 80s and 90s in Pennsylvania, coming out in Boston at 24, living fifteen years fully immersed in the gay world, then going back into the closet in my 40s and realizing I'm not straight or gay, but somewhere in the middle.And upon realizing this, being confused and anxious about it as I was acclimating to moving out West — I found myself hiding non-straight parts of me in some...
  • Middle Men: Season 1 Trailer
    Middle Men: Season 1 Trailer 05.07.2026 1m
    Middle Men is a podcast and community for men who don't fit neatly into society's straight or gay boxes.Maybe your life appears straight on the outside but isn't so straight on the inside. Maybe you're bi or gay, but don't fit neatly into the spaces designed for you. Maybe you don't have a word for what you are—and maybe you don't want one.Either way, you exist somewhere in the middle — and the world doesn't have a lot of space for that.Middle Men does.Honest conversation about identity, masculinity, relationships, social connection, and personal growth. No labels. No judgment. No pressure to...

Popular in

The podcast also appears in the podcast charts of these countries.