The Gilgo Beach Murders: The Case Against Rex Heuermann

The Gilgo Beach Murders: The Case Against Rex Heuermann

True Crime Today
Country USA
Language EN
Episodes 480
Latest 14.07.2026

For nearly two decades, the remains of young women kept turning up along the desolate stretches of Long Island — in the scrub brush off Ocean Parkway, in wooded areas out east, in places no one was supposed to find them. And for most of that time, no one was held accountable. I'm Tony Brueski, and this podcast is my deep dive into one of the most chilling serial murder cases in modern American history — the Gilgo Beach murders and the case against Rex Heuermann, the New York architect now charged with the killing of seven women spanning from 1993 to 2010. This isn't a case summary. It's the full picture — the women who were allegedly targeted and discarded, the investigative failures that let a suspected killer allegedly operate in plain sight for decades, and the forensic breakthroughs that finally led to an arrest in July 2023. I break down the evidence prosecutors have built — DNA analysis, cellphone data, digital files allegedly recovered from Heuermann's own computer — and the defense strategy aimed at dismantling it. I cover the courtroom battles, the rulings on evidence admissibility, and every development as this case moves toward its next chapter.

Episodes

  • Rex Heuermann's Therapist Hid THIS For Years
    Rex Heuermann's Therapist Hid THIS For Years 14.07.2026 18m
    This episode goes deeper into the detail from the Rex Heuermann case that's generated more questions than almost anything since his guilty plea: the therapist who worked closely with his family, and what she was reportedly hiding the entire time. Rex Heuermann pleaded guilty to eight murders and is now serving three life sentences plus a hundred years at Clinton Correctional. But according to reporting, the therapist involved with his family wasn't licensed, appeared on a Peacock special discussing details tied to her clients, and reportedly guided his wife toward living in the remodeled bedro...
  • Who Was Amber Costello Before She Became The Key To Rex Heuermann's Arrest?
    Who Was Amber Costello Before She Became The Key To Rex Heuermann's Arrest? 13.07.2026 30m
    Amber Costello was twenty-seven, from North Carolina, battling addiction, and living with roommates in West Babylon. Friends described her as generous and funny. Her sister said publicly she forgives Rex Heuermann — and that Amber would have too. And without her case, Heuermann might still be walking free. This look back puts Amber first — her life before the case file — and then traces how the evidence surrounding her disappearance became the key that unlocked the entire Gilgo Beach investigation.The night before Amber vanished, Heuermann was scammed at her address — her roommate ran a hustle...
  • Why Did Rex Heuermann Tell His Daughter The Two Worlds Never Crossed?
    Why Did Rex Heuermann Tell His Daughter The Two Worlds Never Crossed? 12.07.2026 38m
    She asked the question no daughter should ever have to ask: did you ever think about me when you were doing this? Rex Heuermann said no. The two worlds never crossed. Victoria Heuermann heard that answer sitting across from her father in a jailhouse room — after he'd just admitted to killing eight women in the house where she grew up — and she forgave him on the spot. This look back sits with both halves of that exchange and everything they reveal.Nobody thinks about the daughter of the serial killer. Victoria said that herself. And the documentary showed what living inside that identity looks...
  • Heuermann's Guilty Plea May Rest on THIS
    Heuermann's Guilty Plea May Rest on THIS 10.07.2026 17m
    Rex Heuermann confessed to eight murders in front of his ex-wife and daughter, in sessions run by a counselor who had no legal right to be there. Legal analyst Eric Faddis returns to dig deeper into what that could mean for Heuermann's case going forward, starting with the theory that could actually carry weight on appeal: did he plead guilty specifically to keep his family off the witness stand, and if the confession that drove that decision came from a deceptive setup, does the entire foundation of the plea come into question.Faddis is upfront that this wouldn't be a straightforward path to...
  • Heuermann's Treating Therapist Was Never Licensed
    Heuermann's Treating Therapist Was Never Licensed 10.07.2026 18m
    For nearly three years, Allison Winter sat across from Rex Heuermann inside the Suffolk County Jail, week after week, counseling him and his family through some of the most consequential moments of his case. She was there around the time he privately confessed to his son and wife. What she wasn't, according to prosecutors, was a licensed clinical social worker.Winter now faces eighteen felony charges, including grand larceny, scheme to defraud, and unauthorized practice of a profession, for allegedly billing Cigna, UnitedHealthcare, and Medicare for more than sixty thousand dollars while treat...
  • Is Rex Heuermann Still Controlling The Narrative From Behind Bars?
    Is Rex Heuermann Still Controlling The Narrative From Behind Bars? 08.07.2026 42m
    A man who spent decades organizing murder into checklists and phases may have organized his exit from the justice system the same way. This look back sits with the uncomfortable possibility at the center of Rex Heuermann's guilty plea: that it wasn't a confession — it was one last piece of planning.One thousand days of maintaining his innocence. Every motion denied. Every legal door closed. And then a calculated pivot — his attorney's own words. During a confidential session, Heuermann brought up Karen Vergata, a woman he was never charged with killing. Her case was folded into the deal. No se...
  • What Happens To Rex Heuermann's Family Now That He's Confessed?
    What Happens To Rex Heuermann's Family Now That He's Confessed? 07.07.2026 33m
    She sat in the last row. Her ex-husband stood at the front of a packed courtroom and admitted to killing eight women over seventeen years — while she shared a bed with him, raised their daughter with him, built what she thought was a life. Rex Heuermann's guilty plea is now the legal record. And Asa Ellerup, the woman who once called him her hero, walked out of that courtroom into a wrongful death lawsuit naming her and their daughter as defendants.This look back sits with the aftermath. The lawsuit, filed by the son of victim Valerie Mack, alleges the family profited from a documentary and sh...
  • Who Were Maureen And Melissa Before Rex Heuermann Took Their Lives?
    Who Were Maureen And Melissa Before Rex Heuermann Took Their Lives? 06.07.2026 28m
    Maureen Brainard-Barnes was a songwriter. Her sister said she never got to show the world how talented she was. She was twenty-five, a mother of two, facing eviction and fighting for custody when she rode the train from Connecticut to Manhattan in July 2007 because she had run out of options. Her daughter Nicolette was seven. Nicolette would later stand at the indictment hearing and speak publicly about growing up without her mother. Three years after Maureen disappeared, her remains were found in burlap along Ocean Parkway.Melissa Barthelemy graduated from cosmetology school in Buffalo and mo...
  • What Happened Inside The Heuermann Home When Rex Pleaded Guilty?
    What Happened Inside The Heuermann Home When Rex Pleaded Guilty? 05.07.2026 41m
    Asa Ellerup called Rex Heuermann her savior. Their daughter Victoria publicly said she believes he most likely committed the killings. And on April 8, 2026, he stood in a courtroom and confirmed it — pleading guilty to seven murders and admitting to an eighth while his ex-wife and daughter sat in the gallery. This look back sits with what that moment did to a family already fractured by opposite conclusions.Psychotherapist Shavaun Scott examines the psychology behind nearly three decades of "not knowing." Prosecutors alleged Heuermann engineered his crimes around his family's schedule. His wif...
  • Who Were Valerie Mack And Jessica Taylor Before Rex Heuermann Took Their Lives?
    Who Were Valerie Mack And Jessica Taylor Before Rex Heuermann Took Their Lives? 04.07.2026 33m
    Valerie Mack was born into loss. Placed in foster care as a child, adopted by the Mack family, estranged from her own son by her early twenties. She was working in Philadelphia when she vanished — and after she was found, it took twenty years for anyone to learn her name. Jessica Taylor was twenty years old, working near Port Authority in the same Midtown neighborhood where Rex Heuermann ran his architecture practice. She was the youngest of the women he was charged with killing. This look back puts them first — their lives before the case files, before the evidence, before the headlines.The f...
  • Who Was Sandra Costilla Before Rex Heuermann Pleaded Guilty To Her Murder?
    Who Was Sandra Costilla Before Rex Heuermann Pleaded Guilty To Her Murder? 03.07.2026 31m
    Sandra Costilla was twenty-eight years old when her remains were found in the woods of Southampton, Long Island, in 1993. For thirty years, her case sat cold. Investigators pursued the wrong suspect. Nobody connected her death to the Gilgo Beach killings. And then DNA technology that didn't exist during her lifetime linked her to Rex Heuermann — and pushed the entire timeline of his alleged crimes back by fourteen years.This look back puts Sandra first — her life before the case file, the decades her family spent without answers, and the forensic breakthrough that finally brought her name back...
  • What Did Rex Heuermann Say When Asked How He Killed Eight Women?
    What Did Rex Heuermann Say When Asked How He Killed Eight Women? 02.07.2026 37m
    One word. When prosecutors asked Rex Heuermann in a Riverhead courtroom how he killed eight women over seventeen years, he answered with a single word: strangulation. No emotion. No elaboration. Victims' families packed the gallery, weeping, while the man who had maintained his innocence for nearly three years matter-of-factly confirmed what investigators had spent decades trying to prove. This look back sits with that moment and everything that led to it.Heuermann pleaded guilty to seven counts of murder — three first-degree, four second-degree — and admitted to killing an eighth woman as par...
  • The One Line in Rex Heuermann’s Plea Deal That Protects Him in Three States
    The One Line in Rex Heuermann’s Plea Deal That Protects Him in Three States 28.06.2026 1h 9m
    Melissa Barthelemy’s sister answered a phone call from the man who had just killed Melissa. He described what he did. That detail emerged during the sentencing of Rex Heuermann — three consecutive life terms, a hundred years, families chanting ogre as officers removed him from the courtroom.The sentence is supposed to be the end. But inside the plea deal is a question the families can’t let go of. Heuermann confessed to killing Karen Vergata during a proffer session — a woman he was never charged with. He brought her up himself. He volunteered it for credit. The judge said “eight that we know...
  • What Rex Heuermann Wants FROM The FBI
    What Rex Heuermann Wants FROM The FBI 25.06.2026 17m
    Rex Heuermann is sentenced. Life without parole. Eight murders. It’s over. So why would he agree to sit in a room with the FBI’s Behavioral Analysis Unit and walk them through what he did?Former FBI behavioral analyst Robin Dreeke says the answer is simple: information is the only currency Heuermann has left. He’ll use it to stay relevant, to feel important, to maintain some sense of control from inside a cell. He’ll dribble out details and try to manage the flow. The FBI has known this dynamic since Edmund Kemper told Robert Ressler in a California prison that he could rip his head off before...
  • Asa Ellerup’s Phone Calls With Rex Heuermann Reveal WHAT About Her?!
    Asa Ellerup’s Phone Calls With Rex Heuermann Reveal WHAT About Her?! 25.06.2026 18m
    Rex Heuermann is serving life without parole for the Gilgo Beach murders. He confessed to eight killings. Seven happened in the Massapequa Park basement. He admitted it privately to Asa and Victoria before his courtroom plea. He told Victoria the victims were not real people to him.And Asa Ellerup is still talking to him. Still visiting. Still managing the relationship on his terms. The Peacock documentary captured phone calls where Rex directed the family from his cell, insulted Asa and Victoria’s ability to communicate, and still ran the room. And Asa’s response on camera — what she said abo...
  • Why Is Asa Ellerup Still Visiting Gilgo Beach Killer Rex Heuermann After He Confessed?
    Why Is Asa Ellerup Still Visiting Gilgo Beach Killer Rex Heuermann After He Confessed? 23.06.2026 21m
    Rex Heuermann sat across from Asa Ellerup and told her he killed eight women. Seven in their basement. He described the dismemberments. She filed for divorce to keep the house. Then she gutted the basement, put down new floors, hung a cross on the wall, arranged stuffed animals on the shelves, and moved in. She sleeps there. She has visited Rex in jail approximately twelve times since the confession. She told Peacock cameras she wants to understand his triggers.The audience has a simpler question: why? Why does someone keep going back to the man who confessed to serial murder? Why does the fam...
  • What Did Rex Heuermann Say When He Called His Victims Sister?!
    What Did Rex Heuermann Say When He Called His Victims Sister?! 22.06.2026 19m
    Amanda Funderburg stood in a Suffolk County courtroom and addressed the man who killed her sister, Melissa Barthelemy. She told the court about a phone call. A call Heuermann made to her after the murder. What he said on that call is not something you forget.Heuermann was sentenced to consecutive life terms. Judge Mazzei was visibly emotional. He asked Heuermann if he was sorry. Called him a disgusting, despicable small man and a coward. Ordered him removed from the courtroom as the families chanted ogre.That sentencing closed one chapter. The cooperation agreement opens another. Heuermann wil...
  • What Rex Heuermann Didn’t Answer For at Sentencing
    What Rex Heuermann Didn’t Answer For at Sentencing 19.06.2026 50m
    He answered for eight murders. He did not answer for Karen Vergata’s — even though he confessed to it in the same courtroom. He did not answer for the civil conspiracy his ex-wife now faces. And he did not answer for the women who disappeared near his properties in states that can execute him.Rex Heuermann’s sentencing gave the Gilgo Beach families a moment they earned. Three consecutive life sentences. A hundred years. A judge who said he was disgusting and ordered officers to remove him. It was the ending the case needed. It was not the ending the case got.The plea deal contains an uncharged...
  • Did Gilgo Beach Killer Rex Heuermann Really Ask About Butter?
    Did Gilgo Beach Killer Rex Heuermann Really Ask About Butter? 19.06.2026 14m
    According to reporting, Rex Heuermann sat in his cell at the Riverhead Correctional Facility six weeks after his arrest and wrote a letter. Not to a friend. Not to family. To Keith Hunter Jesperson — the Happy Face Killer — a man convicted of killing at least eight women during the 1990s.And one of the things the Gilgo Beach killer reportedly wanted to know? Whether Jesperson had butter for his bread in prison.The LISK — the man who admitted to strangling eight women and scattering their remains across Long Island — settling into jail life by asking another serial killer about food. According...
  • What Investigators Found Near Rex Heuermann’s Properties
    What Investigators Found Near Rex Heuermann’s Properties 19.06.2026 17m
    Missing women. In more than one state. Near property Rex Heuermann purchased during the same years he was killing on Long Island.That is the piece of the Gilgo Beach case that did not end with the sentencing. Heuermann pleaded guilty to eight murders in Suffolk County. He received three consecutive life terms plus a hundred years. He waived his appeal. The New York case is legally finished. But the judge made a point of saying it out loud: eight that we know of.Four lots in Chester, South Carolina. A woman who disappeared twenty miles away. A timeshare in Las Vegas. An escort who vanished two...

Popular in

The podcast also appears in the podcast charts of these countries.