The Advantage with Mike Wystrach

The Advantage with Mike Wystrach

WiseTrack Co.
Country USA
Language EN
Episodes 1
Latest 11.11.2026

The Advantage is a weekly podcast for founders and operators in direct-to-consumer, consumer packaged goods, and e-commerce. Host Mike Wystrach shares lessons from building Freshly to $550M+ in revenue and its sale to Nestlé, and now invests in and builds consumer businesses. Each episode features candid, tactical conversations with founders and operators about fundraises, pivots, channels, hires, and the numbers behind them. New episodes are published every week.

Episodes

  • Nestlé Told Us It Couldn't Be Done. Then They Bought Us. | Carter Comstock, Alberto Lopez Toledo
    Nestlé Told Us It Couldn't Be Done. Then They Bought Us. | Carter Comstock, Alberto Lopez Toledo 11.11.2026 1h 37m
    Mike Wystrach, Carter Comstock and Alberto Lopez Toledo took Freshly from 2am shifts in a restaurant kitchen to more than a million fresh, never-frozen meals a week, and in 2020 Nestlé bought it for up to $1.5 billion. This is the first time the three co-founders have told the story together. Carter slept on a duct-taped air mattress, an 80-year-old pool hustler offered to double his check on one game, and Nestlé, Alberto remembers, said fresh couldn't be done.This episode is presented by Proppel. Hire A-player marketing and ops talent from the US and LATAM, and get 10% off your first hire: ht...
  • Nobody Wanted to Invest in Coterie. It Returned Our Fund. | Deborah Benton, Willow Growth Partners
    Nobody Wanted to Invest in Coterie. It Returned Our Fund. | Deborah Benton, Willow Growth Partners 04.11.2026 53m
    Nobody wanted to invest in Coterie. It was a diaper, a paper product, in a category owned by Huggies and Pampers. Deborah Benton backed it anyway, and in 2025 Mammoth Brands, the company behind Harry's, agreed to buy it. By her account, Coterie and Goodles, which Barilla agreed to buy this year, each returned Willow Growth Partners' fund. She learned what not to do first: she helped take eToys public before the 2000 crash, was COO of ShoeDazzle alongside Kim Kardashian, and was president of Nasty Gal when it raised from Index at what she calls a ridiculous multiple of revenue.This episode is p...
  • Everyone Calls It an Overnight Success. It Took 16 Years. | Midland
    Everyone Calls It an Overnight Success. It Took 16 Years. | Midland 28.10.2026 1h 8m
    Midland's first album went to No. 1 on the country albums chart, and "Drinkin' Problem" earned two Grammy nominations. Before any of that, the band spent close to two years in Texas with no record deal, playing for beer money, and played a New York label showcase to 15 people. Mark Wystrach, the band's lead singer and Mike's twin brother, says the overnight success took 16 years. Recorded backstage at TD Garden in Boston, hours before the show.This episode is presented by Proppel. Hire A-player marketing and ops talent from the US and LATAM, and get 10% off your first hire: https://www.wearepr...
  • Our CEO quit with a month of cash left. I took the job | Jordan DeCicco, Super Coffee
    Our CEO quit with a month of cash left. I took the job | Jordan DeCicco, Super Coffee 21.10.2026 54m
    Jordan DeCicco started Super Coffee in a college dorm room with a blender from Rite Aid. All five Sharks passed on it. By 2021 the company had raised $106 million at a valuation above $500 million, with Jennifer Lopez and Alex Rodriguez on the cap table. Three years later it had about a month of cash left, and the outside CEO quit on a Sunday call. Jordan took the job himself. This is the first time he has told that part.This episode is presented by Proppel. Hire A-player marketing and ops talent from the US and LATAM, and get 10% off your first hire: https://www.weareproppel.com/theadvantageF...
  • I built a drink company with Vanessa Hudgens | Oliver Trevena, Caliwater
    I built a drink company with Vanessa Hudgens | Oliver Trevena, Caliwater 14.10.2026 46m
    Oliver Trevena says he was beaten nearly to death at 21, then used the compensation to move from England to Los Angeles. He became an actor and TV host, and when he started taking business meetings between shoots, his reps dropped him for it. Now he co-founds Caliwater with Vanessa Hudgens, backed by Gerard Butler, Glen Powell and Demi Lovato, and it has launched in Walmart nationwide.This episode is presented by Proppel. Hire A-player marketing and ops talent from the US and LATAM, and get 10% off your first hire: https://www.weareproppel.com/theadvantageFollow Mike on Instagram: @mikewystrac...
  • The LinkedIn Posting Formula That Took Him From 1,000 to 400K | Tobi Oluwole
    The LinkedIn Posting Formula That Took Him From 1,000 to 400K | Tobi Oluwole 07.10.2026 52m
    Tobi Oluwole applied to Shopify seven times before they hired him. At Shopify, he wrote one LinkedIn post using a storytelling framework from his onboarding and woke up to 200,000 impressions on 1,000 followers. He has posted every weekday since May 2020, now has about 400,000 followers, and works three days a week.This episode is presented by Proppel. Hire A-player marketing and ops talent from the US and LATAM, and get 10% off your first hire: https://www.weareproppel.com/theadvantageFollow Mike on Instagram: @mikewystrach ‚ https://instagram.com/mikewystrachIn this episode:- Why he won't qu...
  • I Back Celebrity Brands. Fame Is the Third Thing I Check | Scott Van den Berg, HotStart VC
    I Back Celebrity Brands. Fame Is the Third Thing I Check | Scott Van den Berg, HotStart VC 30.09.2026 37m
    Scott Van den Berg invests only in brands founded by celebrities and creators, and the celebrity is the third thing he checks. He started with $10,000 checks and no network in Hollywood. Now his portfolio includes brands from Selena Gomez, DJ Khaled, Jake Paul and Katy Perry.This episode is presented by Proppel. Hire A-player marketing and ops talent from the US and LATAM, and get 10% off your first hire: https://www.weareproppel.com/theadvantageFollow Mike on Instagram: @mikewystrach — https://instagram.com/mikewystrachIn this episode:◼ The 20% equity mistake founders make with celebrities◼ H...
  • I made $200K talking to strangers | Josh Suggs, StreetTalk
    I made $200K talking to strangers | Josh Suggs, StreetTalk 23.09.2026 1h
    Josh Suggs made $200,000 in profit his first summer walking up to strangers in New York parks with a microphone. No website, no personal brand, no connections, no investors. He was sleeping on a friend's couch in an apartment with no Wi-Fi, so every night he carried an SD card to an Apple Store and emailed a public Google Drive link to his one editor in Croatia. He had a 2.1 GPA and spent high school in special ed, in the same house as a twin sister who went to the University of Chicago on a full ride. StreetTalk is now more than 100 people and eight figures of revenue.This episode is presente...
  • She Got 1,000 No's Now Her Company Does $250M A Year | Katerina Schneider
    She Got 1,000 No's Now Her Company Does $250M A Year | Katerina Schneider 16.09.2026 1h
    Kat Schneider counted a 1,000 no's before Ritual worked. She was a venture partner running 70 companies for Troy Carter when she got pregnant, went looking for a prenatal vitamin, and could not find one that would tell her where the ingredients came from. She quit 4 months pregnant. One of the best known investors in LA told her to her face she could start a business or a family but there was no way in hell she was doing both. She has three daughters and a company that did more than $250 million in revenue in 2024.This episode is presented by Proppel. https://www.weareproppel.com/theadvantageF...
  • How to take the leap from corporate to entrepreneurship | Addison LaBonte
    How to take the leap from corporate to entrepreneurship | Addison LaBonte 09.09.2026 56m
    Addison LaBonte is the founder of Sweet Addison's, a gluten-free dessert brand she started in her apartment kitchen in January 2024 and still owns outright. She built the customers first and the company second.This episode is presented by Proppel. Hire A-player marketing and ops talent from the US and LATAM, and get 10% off your first hire: https://www.weareproppel.com/theadvantageFollow Mike on Instagram: https://instagram.com/mikewystrachA doctor told her she could have surgery for compartment syndrome or stop running for good. She took a third option, cut gluten, and ran again. Almost nothi...
  • How to hire fast in a startup | Leandro Cabrini
    How to hire fast in a startup | Leandro Cabrini 02.09.2026 56m
    We turned the six moves from this episode into one free PDF, The Cabrini Playbook → https://mikewystrach.com/get/leandro-playbookPresented by Proppel. Get 10% off your first hire: https://www.weareproppel.com/theadvantageFollow Mike on Instagram: https://instagram.com/mikewystrachIn this episode Mike and Leandro cover the task list that has to exist before the job description, the purpose every interview stage needs, the test project, the onboarding almost nobody builds, and the time zone trick for founders with no process yet. The rule underneath all of it is the one Mike has hired by for a d...
  • Your time is worth more than your wealth | Kenny Santucci
    Your time is worth more than your wealth | Kenny Santucci 26.08.2026 46m
    Kenny Santucci did nine seasons of MTV's The Challenge. Today he trains Bon Jovi, guys from the Knicks, and whichever WWE wrestlers are in town, out of two New York gyms he owns.Presented by Proppel — hire A-player marketing and ops talent from the US and LATAM. Get 10% off your first hire: https://www.weareproppel.com/theadvantageFollow Mike on Instagram: https://instagram.com/mikewystrachCHAPTERS00:00:00 The Month He Lost Under Armour And HYROX00:01:45 Nine Seasons On MTV's The Challenge00:04:02 Start Before You Know What You're Doing00:08:09 What A Two-Year Lawsuit Teaches You About Partner...
  • $600M Operator: Start in a Niche. Just Don't Plan to Stay There. | Sam McBride
    $600M Operator: Start in a Niche. Just Don't Plan to Stay There. | Sam McBride 19.08.2026 1h 3m
    Sam McBride is the CEO of Kettle & Fire and the founder of Colter Ventures, where he writes $40 to $150 million checks into a handful of businesses at a time.This episode is presented by Proppel. Hire A-player marketing and ops talent from the US and LATAM, and get 10% off your first hire: https://www.weareproppel.com/theadvantageFull show notes and everything mentioned: https://mikewystrach.com/podcast/sam-mcbrideA year out of school and working in healthcare M&A, McBride sold a $10 million piece of business to a division he did not work in. He asked his MD what that was worth to him and got...
  • Navigating the Creator Economy | Vitalii Dodonov, Stan
    Navigating the Creator Economy | Vitalii Dodonov, Stan 12.08.2026 49m
    Vitalii Dodonov is the co-founder and CTO of Stan, a creator commerce platform that's generated over $600M for it's creators. Every other platform in the category takes 10 to 20 percent of what a creator sells. Stan takes nothing.Presented by Proppel. Hire A-player marketing and ops talent from the US and LATAM, and get 10% off your first hire: https://www.weareproppel.com/theadvantageMike's IG: https://www.instagram.com/mikewystrach/In late 2022 Stan was doing roughly $1 million a year, and a slice of that was commission. They had added the cut for the reason everyone adds it: the rest of the...
  • The Best Hire beehiiv Almost Never Made | Daniel Berk
    The Best Hire beehiiv Almost Never Made | Daniel Berk 05.08.2026 52m
    Daniel Berk is giving you the Owned Audience Playbook · beehiiv's first sales hire on betting on yourself Presented by Proppel · A-player marketing and ops talent, 10% off your first hire → https://www.weareproppel.com/the-advantage-proppelDaniel Berk built a $78,000-a-year podcast working one hour a week. He learned the system as beehiiv's first sales hire, joining at 12 employees and under $1M in revenue. The company now reports $30M ARR. This conversation covers the entire playbook: the offshore clipping engine, packaging your personal audience for sponsors, why guests outperform banter, th...

Popular in

The podcast also appears in the podcast charts of these countries.