NAUGHTY GYM SHOW - Building Stronger Non-Monogamous Relationships
April and Scott
0
Naughty Gym Show is a podcast about non-monogamy, open relationships, swinging, polyamory, and building strong relationships beyond traditional monogamy. Hosted by Scott and April Shirley, it explores how couples and individuals can create honest, ethical, and emotionally resilient non-monogamous relationships. Episodes cover communication, jealousy, autonomy, intimacy, trust, and personal growth, with relational freedom as a central idea. The show draws on Wild Love Theory and treats relationships as something people can train for.
Episodes
-
Men Get Real About the Hardest Parts of Non-Monogamy | Live from Mancation Mountain 12.11.2026 55mWhat happens when your partner controls who you can play with? How much of yourself should you sacrifice to protect someone you love? And what do you do when your partner is genuinely trying to overcome their fears, but you're running out of patience? These aren't hypothetical questions. They're real struggles from real men navigating the complicated world of ethical non-monogamy. In this special live episode recorded at Mancation Mountain, Scott Shirley is joined by fellow non-monogamy advocate and favorite debate partner Scott Studham. With 21 men gathered for several days of honest conversa... -
MEN, STOP DOING THIS! | 3 Mistakes That Are Killing Your Non-Monogamy Game in the Lifestyle 27.10.2026 53mGuys, could you be sabotaging your own chances in the lifestyle without even realizing it? In this episode of the Naughty Gym Show, Scott and April tackle three common mistakes they see men making in the non-monogamous community, and why these seemingly harmless habits might be making you less attractive, less confident, and less successful at building the connections you actually want. From constantly putting yourself down to relying on your partner to break the ice, we're talking about the behaviors that can quietly work against you. And ladies, you're not entirely off the hook either! We di... -
You Want an Open Relationship. So Why Does It Hurt? | Ally Iseman, CRC 13.10.2026 59mWhen Your Mind Says Yes, But Your Body Says No You love your partner. You genuinely want them to experience freedom, pleasure, and connection with others. You've talked about it, made agreements, and decided you're ready. Then it happens. You see your partner flirting with someone, kissing someone, or enjoying an experience you've already agreed to, and suddenly your stomach drops. Your heart races. Every part of your body seems to be screaming that something is wrong. But is something actually wrong? In this episode of The Naughty Gym Show, we're joined by relationship coach and jealousy expe... -
The Non-Monogamy Check-In 30.09.2026 55mWhat if the real question isn’t, “Why can’t I handle non-monogamy?” but instead, “What else am I already carrying?”In this episode, Scott and April get unusually personal about something that has quietly affected their own non-monogamous relationship for years: capacity.Non-monogamy can be emotionally demanding. And when one partner is already overwhelmed by work, family, stress, responsibility, or an unequal relational load, there may simply not be much capacity left for jealousy, uncertainty, sexual exploration, or navigating new boundaries.But the conversation goes even deeper.Scott and Apr... -
Can Psychedelics Make You Better at Non-Monogamy? 15.09.2026 1h 2mCan psychedelics actually make you better at non-monogamy? Jealousy. Fear. Defensiveness. Insecurity. The urge to control what your partner does so you don’t have to feel something uncomfortable. These are some of the hardest parts of opening a relationship, and in this episode, Scott sits down with Dr. Chandra Khalifian and Dr. Kayla Knopp, co-founders of Enamory, to explore whether psychedelic-assisted therapy can help us respond to those challenges differently. Chandra and Kayla work at the intersection of couples therapy, expansive relationships, and psychedelic-assisted psychotherapy. Tog... -
Special Episode: Men Need Male Relationships 04.09.2026 19mWhat happens when a bunch of men who aren’t particularly interested in going to a men’s retreat actually spend a weekend together? Apparently, something none of us expected. When Mancation Mountain was created, the plan was pretty simple: get a group of guys together in an incredible Smoky Mountain mansion, eat great food, play poker and pickleball, drink, laugh, hang out, and squeeze in about 90 minutes a day talking about relationships. Because, realistically, how much “deep conversation” are a bunch of guys going to tolerate? Last year, those 90-minute conversations kept turning into four-h... -
Barcelona Recap & Our Two-Year Transparency Misunderstanding 01.09.2026 1h 2mWe’re back from Europe, and somehow we came home with more than great food, unforgettable stories, and a ridiculous amount of sweat. In this episode, we recap our eight-day Naughty Gym/Aya Society trip outside Barcelona with 29 friends, including connection circles, skinny dipping at a 500-year-old villa, late nights in the Gothic Quarter, an unforgettable drag show in Sitges, April watching her grandson being born over FaceTime while standing outside Sagrada Família, and a few lessons about what happens when Scott attempts to navigate European public transportation. Then we head to Rome, wher... -
Jealousy in Non-Monogamy: Invisible Contracts & Unspoken Expectations 11.08.2026 52mWhat happens when you really click with another person or couple, maybe even have great sex, and then find yourself hurt or jealous when they connect with someone else? In Episode 83, April and Scott talk about the invisible agreements we sometimes create in non-monogamy without ever discussing them. Maybe you’ve played together before and assumed it would happen again. Maybe you went to an event together expecting to spend the night together. Maybe you felt close to someone and were surprised by your jealousy when they met someone new. Problems can arise when those assumptions affect how we t... -
Menopause Unfiltered: Pelvic Health, Better Sex & the Power of Women’s Community 28.07.2026 1h 1mPerimenopause and menopause can affect far more than your cycle—they can reshape your sleep, strength, confidence, sexuality, and relationships. In this candid episode, April and co-host Catherine of Expansive Connection explore how women can move through this transition feeling informed, empowered, and fully connected to their bodies. Pelvic-floor specialist Cara explains why common symptoms shouldn’t simply be dismissed as “normal,” how breathing and mobility support pelvic health, and why the pelvic floor matters for movement, pain, sexual function, and stronger orgasms. Returning Wild & Wi... -
We’re Getting Divorced… to Celebrate Our Love? Our Biggest Announcement Yet 14.07.2026 56mAfter six years, Naughty Gym is becoming Aya Society. In this episode, we share why we’re making the biggest change our business has ever seen, what the new name means, and why this feels like the next chapter of everything we’ve been building. We also announce the upcoming release of Wild Love Theory, our new book about building relationships that are rooted in freedom, authenticity, and intentional commitment. And yes… we’re also explaining why we’re legally divorcing, and why, for us, it has become one of the deepest expressions of our commitment to each other. In this episode we discuss: *... -
Naughty Gym Invades X-Club: Inside A Lifestyle Weekend In Toronto 30.06.2026 1h 7mWe just got home from hosting our first Naughty Gym weekend at X Club, and we are telling the whole story.In this episode, Scott, April, and Andy recap four days at one of the most impressive lifestyle clubs they have visited. They share what surprised them about X Club, why it felt welcoming for both first-timers and longtime lifestyle people, how the club separates partying from play, and why that setup made the entire experience feel safer, easier, and far less overwhelming.They talk pool parties, late-night dancing, Luna Matatas’s workshops, a packed Saturday-night crowd, the people they m... -
Dealing With Fears & Insecurities in Non-Monogamy 09.06.2026 53mFear, jealousy, and insecurity are normal in the lifestyle. But should every fear become a rule? In this episode, April and Scott talk about how couples in swinging, open relationships, and ethical non-monogamy often handle insecurity by creating rules, limits, and boundaries. Sometimes those rules help. But sometimes they become permanent cages that prevent real growth. We break down the common R.U.L.E. Pattern and offer a healthier alternative with the F.R.E.E. Framework, a practical tool for processing jealousy, reexamining the story fear creates, asking for care without control, and expand... -
The Bad Prophet: You’re Probably Not as Good at Reading People as You Think 21.05.2026 1h 6mHow good are you really at reading people? Most of us like to believe we are above average at detecting lies, sensing energy, reading body language, picking up on vibes, and knowing what someone “really means.” But the research tells a very different story. In this episode, April and Scott unpack one of the most quietly destructive patterns in relationships: the confidence we place in our own interpretations, especially when fear gets involved. They begin with a hilarious and painfully revealing self-test. Are you better than average at spotting a liar? A better driver? Less biased than most p... -
The Opportunity: Investing In A Lifestyle Resort & The Power Of Why In Non-Monogamy 05.05.2026 45mYes, we’re part of a new lifestyle resort project in Florida, and in this episode we bring on Jimmy Thorpe to talk about the vision, the opportunity, and what could become one of the most exciting lifestyle destinations in the United States. But the real story is bigger than the property. This conversation is about where non monogamy is headed. For a long time, a lot of lifestyle spaces have been built around the same basic formula: drinks, DJs, sex, and weekend parties. And while there is absolutely a place for that, we believe the community is ready for something more. We talk about creating... -
Wild Love Retreat - What Really Happens When You Live This? 28.04.2026 58mIn this episode, April, Scott, and therapist Catherine from Expansive Connection unpack the raw, surprising, and powerful reality of the very first Wild Love Theory retreat. They share what shocked them most, what couples struggled with, what breakthroughs happened in real time, and why the weekend felt deeper than any of them expected. From vulnerable men opening up, to hard conversations about freedom, boundaries, burdens, trust, and emotional work, this is an honest behind-the-scenes look at what happens when relationship theory gets tested in real life. They also talk about who this retrea... -
April On The Non-Monogamy Hot Seat: Questions To Argue About 14.04.2026 1h 2mIn this episode of the Naughty Gym Show, April and Scott pull back the curtain on one of the biggest shifts in their relationship so far: removing boundaries, testing freedom in real life, and learning what trust actually looks like when it is no longer theoretical.They talk openly about a major miscommunication that turned into a powerful experiment in non-monogamy, what happened when April gave Scott full freedom for 30 days, and how two unexpected real-world experiences challenged both of them to regulate, trust, and grow.From there, Scott puts April in the hot seat with raw, unfiltered que... -
Rewriting Our Relationship Rules: Rethinking Boundaries Together 31.03.2026 1h 18mIn this raw and deeply personal episode of The Naughty Gym Show, April and Scott pull back the curtain on one of the hardest parts of open relationships and relational freedom: how couples actually revisit rules, boundaries, jealousy, and emotional capacity in real time. Using a powerful tool from their upcoming Wild Love Theory book and workbook, they walk through the exact process they use to identify hidden relationship rules, examine fear-based restrictions, and decide what freedom they are actually ready for. Along the way, they share a live, vulnerable conversation about private texting,... -
Starting Non-Monogamy - A Real Couple's Experience 17.03.2026 54mBefore we jump into today’s conversation, we share a major announcement: after months of quiet work behind the scenes, we reveal that we’ve been involved with a group that is under contract to acquire what many consider one of the premier lifestyle resorts in Florida. Because of SEC rules, we have to be careful about what we say publicly, but we’re excited to share the project, the vision, and the role we hope to play in helping shape its future. After that, we sit down with two very special guests, Clint and Danine, our first-ever Naughty Gym members and longtime friends, for a candid convers... -
Angry Feminist Era Activated: Unlearning Purity Culture & Defensive Masculinity 03.03.2026 53mThis week on The Naughty Gym Show, April takes the wheel for a real-time life update that starts with a chaotic wine-night incident (yes—April fell down 13 of 15 stairs in plush slippers… and Scott’s first response was to laugh 🙃) and turns into one of your most honest conversations yet. From there, you unpack what’s been swirling behind the scenes: launching your Patreon (with tiers starting at $3/month), opening bookings for your November retreats (aka “Naughty Gym Month”), and the stress of college + military academy decisions as your youngest son heads toward a major next chapter. Then th... -
The Spectrum of Compersion: From Neutrality to Joy, Without Toxic Positivity, w/Dr. Marie Thouin 17.02.2026 57mWhat if the goal is not to erase jealousy, but to stop letting it drive the car? Dr. Marie Thouin joins April and Scott to define compersion in clear, grounded terms, and to explain why it can show up as an emotion, an attitude, or even simple supportive neutrality. They talk about the spectrum from “I can handle this” to genuine joy, the “second arrow” of self-inflicted suffering, and the conditions that make compersion more likely: security in self, security in the relationship, supportive community, and more. The episode also explores how autonomy and trust intersect with boundaries, when “...
Popular in
The podcast also appears in the podcast charts of these countries.