Movies That Made Us Gay

Movies That Made Us Gay

MTMUGPodcast
Country USA
Language EN
Episodes 356
Latest 12.11.2026

Movies That Made Us Gay is a podcast where hosts Scott and Pete revisit movies from their past that had a lasting impact on their gay lives. They talk about films they may not have been allowed to watch, often sneaking their parents' VHS copies under cover of night. Each episode looks back at memorable diva speeches, scenes, and movie moments they memorized and lip-synced. The show is a weekly nostalgic conversation about the films that shaped them.

Episodes

  • 346. Stepmom with special guest Joshua Clement
    346. Stepmom with special guest Joshua Clement 12.11.2026 1h 49m
    "You didn't ask me if I wanted a new mother. You didn't even ask me if I liked her!" We watched "Stepmom" with our friend Joshua Clement and we may have run out of tissues. The legend tells that Julia Roberts and Susan Sarandon were such good friends they were searching for a project to work on together and this film is the result of that journey. We really wish there was an old Hollywood-style feud behind the scenes with the two divas at each other's throats - but for all our internet sleuthing we just couldn't find any evidence! It would appear that this was in fact a pleasant set with two f...
  • 345. A Nightmare on Elm Street with special guest Gabe Muñoz
    345. A Nightmare on Elm Street with special guest Gabe Muñoz 30.10.2026 2h
    "Whatever you do... don't fall asleep." We watched "A Nightmare on Elm Street" with our friend Gabe Muñoz, and we've been having trouble sleeping lately. Of the '80s slasher icons, Fred Krueger holds a special place in our dark and spooky hearts. Freddy is a real comeback queen— and not solely based on the sheer number of sequels. As the series progresses, Freddy is always there with a sassy comeback, but in this first entry, he's darker and more sinister. Wes Craven wrote and directed this splatter horror classic based on a pastiche of personal memories and ripped from the headlines unexplain...
  • 344. An American Werewolf in London with special guest Billy Roach
    344. An American Werewolf in London with special guest Billy Roach 23.10.2026 2h 1m
    "A naked American man stole my balloons." We watched "An American Werewolf in London" with our friend Billy Roach, and we will, in fact, dust OFF the moors. What can we say about this horror classic that hasn't already been said? We are still dazzled by the visceral, gory, just plain icky practical transformation scenes; we are charmed by the chemistry between David Naughton and Griffin Dunne; and we are mesmerized by Naughton's buns. Naughton and Dunne's David and Jack bicker like a married couple, and we love the intimacy of their straight male friendship as they navigate this new plane of e...
  • 343. Coraline directed by Henry Selick and ParaNorman directed by Chris Butler
    343. Coraline directed by Henry Selick and ParaNorman directed by Chris Butler 16.10.2026 1h 51m
    "I want to be with my real Mom and Dad. I want you to let me go." We watched Coraline directed by Henry Selick and ParaNorman directed by Chris Butler, and we voted to bring back scary kids movies! As the first entry into Laika Entertainment's impressive catalog, "Coraline" set a pretty high standard. Not only is the movie beautiful, with a cool, eerie score, and some pretty stellar voice work - it's pretty scary. We are champions of scary kids movies, and this one is right up there with "Return to Oz" and "The Dark Crystal." We also talk about Laika's second film, "ParaNorman." We've got the...
  • 342. High Spirits with special guest Hiko Mitsuzka
    342. High Spirits with special guest Hiko Mitsuzka 09.10.2026 1h 37m
    "If I cannot send your payment, how on earth do you expect to transport an entire castle across the sea? The number of stamps alone is mind-boggling." We watched "High Spirits" with our friend Hiko Mitsuzuka and we'd consider risking it all for a ghostly Liam Neeson. They sure don't make horror comedies like they used to, and "High Spirits" really hearkens back to the greats like "Beetlejuice" and "Ghostbusters." The cast is full of '80s movie stalwarts like the dreamy Steve Guttenberg, stunner Beverly D'Angelo, and early turns from Jennifer Tilly, Peter Gallagher, and of course the ethereal D...
  • 341. Tremors with special guest Ashley Casseday from Keep It Weird
    341. Tremors with special guest Ashley Casseday from Keep It Weird 02.10.2026 2h 15m
    "Roger that Burt, and congratulations. Be advised, however, that there are two more, repeat, two more motherhumpers." We watched "Tremors" with our friend Ashley Casseday (with a special appearance from her husband Joe) from "Keep It Weird" and we would like nothing more than to visit Perfection, Nevada with this rag tag groups of survivors. This cast is so extremely well put together, we don't even know where to begin. Actually, Kevin Bacon and Fred Ward - this movie begins and ends with these two actors charming the pants off each other and us, the audience. Valentine (Bacon) and Earl (Ward)...
  • 340. Sky High with special guests Cullen and Hannah from Not My Fantasy
    340. Sky High with special guests Cullen and Hannah from Not My Fantasy 25.09.2026 1h 51m
    "In the end, my girlfriend became my arch enemy, my arch enemy became my best friend, and my best friend became my girlfriend. But, hey, it's high school." We watched "Sky High" with Hannah and Cullen from "Not My Fantasy," and yes, this is definitely unintentionally queer. The gayness that is fully embedded in this movie is most likely accidental, but it's pretty hard to miss. How else do you explain a full-on coming-out scene, color-coded wardrobes that create an entire rainbow, and the overall high-camp aesthetic? It may have been unintentional, but the queerness is there, and a generation...
  • 339. The Wizard directed by Todd Holland
    339. The Wizard directed by Todd Holland 18.09.2026 1h 56m
    "I love the Power Glove. It's so bad." We watched "The Wizard" directed by Todd Holland and we're still trying to pass "Super Mario Bros. 3." When this movie was released in 1989 it was the Superbowl, Christmas and Summer Vacation all wrapped into one. A move... about Nintendo... starring Fred Savage - there was no other choice than to Stan. While it's now a cult classic among adults of a certain age (read: Xenniells and older Millenials) it does suffer from an over written plot with a pretty depressing storyline. What could have been a run of the mill, 80's underdog competition movie along th...
  • 338. The Princess Bride with special guest Melanie Vartabedian
    338. The Princess Bride with special guest Melanie Vartabedian 11.09.2026 2h
    "Have fun stormin' da castle." We watched "The Princess Bride" with our friend Melanie Vartabedian and we're still shouting quotes from this movie at each other from across the room. This movie is an absolute classic but like, it's really deserving of that moniker. This cast is pitch perfect, the script is non-stop quotable gold, and the direction by gone too soon Rob Reiner is top notch. Who would have thought that Borscht-Belt humor would mix so well into a medeival fairy tale? Rob Reiner, that's who. The film adaptation of the book by William Goldman passed through many directors hands but...
  • 337. Little Children with special guest Devin Lotfi
    337. Little Children with special guest Devin Lotfi 04.09.2026 2h
    "My professors would kill me for even thinking this, but in her own strange way, Emma Bovary is a feminist." We watched "Little Children" with our friend Dev Lotfi, and we're unsettled but also… intrigued. We've asked this many times on the podcast, but this film really begs the question… are straight people OK? This film is a character study of modern American suburbia, but we would like to study Patrick Wilson's… character. Wilson and Kate Winslet play stay-at-home parents (to different families) drawn to each other through a mutual need of adult companionship. Jackie Earle Haley plays Ronni...
  • 336. Empire Records with special guest Espie Quintero
    336. Empire Records with special guest Espie Quintero 28.08.2026 1h 43m
    "Well, "Sinead O'Rebellion." Shock me, shock me, shock me with that deviant behavior." We watched "Empire Records" with our dear friend Espie Quintero, and we don't feel that we need to explain our art to you. We know this movie may be polarizing to viewers - it's the kind of film that if you didn't grow up with, you may not hold it as dear as those who did. We're okay with that. Yes, this movie is a series of needle drops and vignettes in which a group of tattooed weirdos lip sync to pop/rock songs of various levels of acclaim. Yes, this movie at times feels like a young adult/teen soap in wh...
  • 335. Jaws: The Revenge with special guest Paul Downey
    335. Jaws: The Revenge with special guest Paul Downey 21.08.2026 1h 52m
    "Bloody Hello! The breath on that thing!" We watched "Jaws: The Revenge" with author Paul Downey and we had a roaring good time. This film is the final entry in the "Jaws" franchise and we honestly had a great time with it. We know, this one has a reputation for going a little off the rails - the main character is Chief Brody's wife Ellen (Lorraine Gary), she has a dubious "psychic" connection to the shark and the shark itself followed her from Martha's Vineyard to the Bahamas. If this all sounds a little cuckoo, don't worry - the movie itself is quite watchable and at times, a lot of fun. Lor...
  • 334. Who's That Girl with special guest Robbie Barnett
    334. Who's That Girl with special guest Robbie Barnett 14.08.2026 1h 59m
    "I am Nikki Finn. I will not be denied. I will know vengeance!" We watched "Who's That Girl" with our friend Robbie Barnett, and we still remember the brief period in the '80s when Madonna was Latina. We all know Madonna has had a complicated history in the movie biz. While "Who's That Girl" was not necessarily well received by critics upon its first release, it's gone on to gain a cult following, not just from Madonna super fans. Griffin Dunne is as adorable as always as uptight tax attorney Louden Trott, and Madonna created an iconic character in Nikki Finn. Is she psychotic? An alien? Or ju...
  • 333. Heartstopper Forever with special guest Harper Thomson
    333. Heartstopper Forever with special guest Harper Thomson 07.08.2026 2h 1m
    "We look after each other, don't we?" We watched "Heartstopper Forever" with our friend and fellow Heartstopper-head Harper Thomson, and we still haven't decided if we're a Nick or a Charlie. "Heartstopper Forever" is the series finale movie event, the would-be Season 4 of the oh-so sincere and very, very gay Netflix series "Heartstopper" based on the graphic novel series created by Alice Oseman. When the series first premiered in 2022, we were instantly hooked - Nick and Charlie and their rag-tag clique representing every color in the Pride Flag may have started out pretty chaste, but as the...
  • 332. Flowers in the Attic with special guest Michael Morgan
    332. Flowers in the Attic with special guest Michael Morgan 31.07.2026 1h 51m
    "She never meant for us to leave that attic." We watched "Flowers in the Attic" (1987) with our friend, the hilarious Michael Morgan, and we will not be eating those cookies. Based on the novel by the prolific V.C. Andrews, this film is melodramatic, American gothic, and just a little trashy. The Dollanganger children have been locked away in their grandparents' mansion by their scheming mother (Victoria Tennant) and uncaring grandmother, played by Nurse Ratched herself, the real queen diva Louise Fletcher. Every school kid in the 80s and 90s knew the dark secret the source novel, Flowers in t...
  • Episode Rewind 40th Anniversary edition: Legend directed by Ridley Scott
    Episode Rewind 40th Anniversary edition: Legend directed by Ridley Scott 18.07.2026 1h 47m
    It's our last week of summer vacation on the podcast, and we picked another one of our favorite episodes for a movie that's turning 40! Well, Ridley Scott's Legend had its United Kingdom release in December of 1985, but the United States didn't get it until the spring of the following year! Enjoy this classic MTMUG episode orginally released November 11th 2021. "What is light without dark?" We watched Legend (1985) directed by Ridley Scott and what we wouldn't give to run around the forest hugging woodland creatures and get wine drunk with fairies. This movie is HIGH fantasy and we are here fo...
  • Episode Rewind 40th Anniversary edition: Labyrinth with special guest Jared Anderson
    Episode Rewind 40th Anniversary edition: Labyrinth with special guest Jared Anderson 10.07.2026 1h 44m
    It's Summer Vacation and we're taking 2 weeks off to recharge. In the meantime, enjoy these rewind episodes reviewing a couple of our favorite films that just happen to be turning 40 this year! Enjoy this classic MTMUG episode originally released April 15, 2022. "Turn Back, Sarah. Turn back before it's too late." We watched Labyrinth (1986) with our good-Judy Jared Anderson and we wish the Goblin King would come and take you away… right now. Sixteen-year-old Sarah (Jennifer Connelley) faces off against Jareth the Goblin King (David Bowie) and a generation's sexual awakening began. Bowie is giv...
  • 331. Boys on the Side with special guests Anne & Ashley from "How Do You Drew"Podcast
    331. Boys on the Side with special guests Anne & Ashley from "How Do You Drew"Podcast 03.07.2026 2h 11m
    "She's holding you back, man. Everybody says so. She's like Yoko with bangs." We watched "Boys on the Side" with Ashley and Anne from "How Do You Drew" and we'll be right back after we gas up the minivan. Drew Barrymore is the common denominator of this Podcast Crossover event - and our dearest Drew is in peak form in this film. The barrel-curled bob is as iconically '90s as you can get, and she is a short year away from her biggest career comeback yet in "Scream," but her work in this film about the power of female friendship really shows her star power. Hot on the heels of a certain other fi...
  • 330. Now and Then with special guest Michael Valvo
    330. Now and Then with special guest Michael Valvo 26.06.2026 2h 11m
    "All women have a garden, and a garden needs a big hose to water it... or a small hose... as long as it works." We watched "Now and Then" with a friend of the pod, Michael Valvo, and we'd like to speak to the spirit of Dear Johnny. This movie will forever be iconic and not just as the girl version of "Stand By Me." The comparisons are inevitable, but reductive - especially once you've actually watched the movie, Tamar. The legacy and cultural impact of "Now and Then" are undeniable and thanks in no small part to the cast - millennials grew up with Christina Ricci, Gaby Hoffmann, Thora Birch, a...
  • 329. Scream 4 with special guest Joshua Tonks
    329. Scream 4 with special guest Joshua Tonks 19.06.2026 2h 6m
    "You forgot the first rule of remakes, Jill. Don't F**k with the original." We watched "Scream 4" with our friend Joshua Tonks and we might just have to re-evaluate our ranking of the Scream Franchise. This movie was a reset for the Franchise and it holds a special place for many in the fandom. The opening scene in any Scream movie is iconic (obviously) but this entry really blows the roof off the joint and lets the audience know we're in for a ride. The first 3 movies work so well as a trilogy but 4 is like a factory reset and really feels like we're being setup for a new storyline. As it hap...

Popular in

The podcast also appears in the podcast charts of these countries.