The Trail Went Cold

The Trail Went Cold

Robin Warder
Country USA
Language EN
Episodes 550
Latest 18.11.2026

The Trail Went Cold is a true crime podcast where writer Robin Warder examines unsolved mysteries and offers his own theories as to what really happened.

Episodes

  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 509 - Jennifer Barton, Debra Stewart, and Brenda Moore
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 509 - Jennifer Barton, Debra Stewart, and Brenda Moore 18.11.2026 51m
    May 16, 1976. Austin, Texas. After speaking with two men in a bar who have supposedly offered to pay her for sex, 20-year old Jennifer Barton vanishes without a trace. Rumours circulate that Jennifer’s disappearance is connected to the murder of her pimp boyfriend, which took place nearly three months earlier, but five days after Jennifer goes missing, a 19-year old University of Texas student named Debra Stewart vanishes before her abandoned car is found. There is speculation that Jennifer and Debra’s cases are connected and might also be linked to the disappearance of 20-year old Brenda Moor...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 508 - Stephanie Crane
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 508 - Stephanie Crane 11.11.2026 48m
    October 11, 1993. Challis, Idaho. After leaving a bowling alley, nine-year old Stephanie Crane says she is planning to retrieve her backpack from the school across the road before she walks home, but she winds up going missing. An extensive search effort fails to find Stephanie and the only major lead are eyewitness sightings of a yellow pick-up truck which was seen in the school parking lot around the time of her disappearance. Over the years, investigators look at a couple of different persons of interest, including a man who was responsible for abducting and sexually assaulting another girl...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 507 - The Hinterkaifeck Murders, Part 2
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 507 - The Hinterkaifeck Murders, Part 2 04.11.2026 58m
    March 31, 1922. Waidhofen, Germany. Four victims are bludgeoned to death with a mattock inside a barn at the Hinterkaifeck farmstead: 63-year old Andreas Gruber, his 72-year old wife Cazilia Gruber, their 35-year old daughter Viktoria Gabriel, and Viktoria’s seven-year old daughter, Cazilia Gabriel. Two additional victims - Viktoria’s two-year old son, Josef Gabriel, and the family’s 45-year old maid, Maria Baumgartner - are fatally bludgeoned inside the farmstead’s residence and the victims’ bodies are not discovered until four days later. Over the next several decades, a number of individual...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 506 - The Hinterkaifeck Murders, Part 1
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 506 - The Hinterkaifeck Murders, Part 1 28.10.2026 55m
    March 31, 1922. Waidhofen, Germany. Four victims are bludgeoned to death with a mattock inside a barn at the Hinterkaifeck farmstead: 63-year old Andreas Gruber, his 72-year old wife Cazilia Gruber, their 35-year old daughter Viktoria Gabriel, and Viktoria’s seven-year old daughter, Cazilia Gabriel. Two additional victims - Viktoria’s two-year old son, Josef Gabriel, and the family’s 45-year old maid, Maria Baumgartner - are fatally bludgeoned inside the farmstead’s residence and the victims’ bodies are not discovered until four days later. Over the next several decades, a number of individual...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 505 - Nori Amaya
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 505 - Nori Amaya 21.10.2026 42m
    October 31, 2009. Washington D.C.. After spending Halloween night frequenting some nightclubs, 38-year old Nori Amaya takes a taxi back to her apartment complex during the early morning hours. After not hearing from her for nearly two days, Nori’s siblings visit her apartment and discover that she has been strangled to death on her bed and the perpetrator has cut off her fingernails in an apparent effort to dispose of DNA evidence. While a male DNA profile is recovered from Nori’s body and used to exclude a number of men from her personal life, it cannot be matched with anyone and the crime re...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 504 - Howard Green & Carol Marron
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 504 - Howard Green & Carol Marron 14.10.2026 46m
    December 16, 1979. West Paterson, New Jersey. The bodies of 51-year old Howard Green and his 33-year old girlfriend, Carol Marron, are discovered next to a road and they have been bound, mutilated and bludgeoned to death. The couple lived in a basement apartment in Brooklyn and were believed to have been murdered less than 24 hours before they were found and it’s alleged that someone used a veterinary syringe to drain most of the blood from their bodies. Investigators express their belief that the murders are connected to Satanism and the occult and at one point, the crime is unexpectedly link...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 503 - Dwayne McCorkendale and Trevor Angell
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 503 - Dwayne McCorkendale and Trevor Angell 07.10.2026 47m
    November 12, 1988. Chandler, Oklahoma. While transporting a shipment to Oklahoma City, 27-year old truck driver Dwayne McCorkendale pulls over at a rest area to phone his wife, but he is fatally shot in the back before he is robbed. During this time period, numerous truck drivers report being harassed by the occupants of a brown Ford Pinto, who allegedly made remarks over their CB radio about having killed a trucker. Three decades later, investigators explore the possibility that a deceased woman known only as the “El Dorado Jane Doe” was involved in Dwayne’s murder, but even though she is eve...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 502 - Robert Kope
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 502 - Robert Kope 30.09.2026 43m
    October 7, 2015. La Grange, California. After he fails to return to his home in San Jose from a motorcycle trip to Oroville, 53-year old Robert Kope is found dead by the side of a remote country road. Robert has been strangled to death with a zip tie, but there are no apparent signs of struggle and his motorcycle is located down the road a quarter-mile away from his body. Seven years earlier, Robert had been engaged to be married to a woman who died after being strangled with a zip tie, but her death was ruled to be a suicide and investigators are unable to uncover a connection between the two...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 501 - Jamie Fraley
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 501 - Jamie Fraley 23.09.2026 46m
    April 9, 2008. Gastonia, North Carolina. After having spent the previous day suffering from a stomach virus, 22-year old Jamie Fraley speaks to a friend on the phone from her apartment during the early morning hours. She says that someone has shown up to give her a ride to the hospital, but after the call ends, Jamie is never heard from again. Suspicion turns towards her fiancée’s father, Ricky Simonds Sr., who lived at Jamie’s apartment complex and had allegedly displayed inappropriate behavior towards her. Two months later, Ricky Sr. is found dead after trapping himself inside the trunk of h...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 500 - The Lauterbach Hardware Axe Attacks and the West Coast Video Murders
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 500 - The Lauterbach Hardware Axe Attacks and the West Coast Video Murders 16.09.2026 1h 4m
    March 18, 1981. Springfield, Illinois. An unknown assailant walks into the Lauterbach Cottage Hardware Store to commit a robbery and grabs an axe from the shelf to bludgeon three victims: the 48-year old co-owner, Yvonne Lauterbach; a 37-year old sewing machine repair shop owner, Floyd Giddings; and a 64-year old customer, John Ewing. While John is pronounced dead at the scene, Yvonne and Floyd manage to survive, but are left with debilitating injuries. Numerous witnesses describe seeing a light-skinned man leaving the store right before the bodies were discovered, but even though a psychiatri...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 499 - Patty Chesher
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 499 - Patty Chesher 09.09.2026 43m
    June 17, 1969. Albuquerque, New Mexico. 12-year-old Patty Chesher leaves her residence in order to go door-to-door and sell some raffle tickets, but after her next-door neighbour purchases a ticket, she vanishes without a trace. While the police initially suspect that Patty ran away voluntarily, her family does not believe this and when she fails to resurface, investigators start exploring the possibility that she was the victim of foul play. Four decades later, it is announced that no less than four persons of interest popped up on the radar after drawing suspicion with some questionable beha...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 498 - Jeffrey Mitchell
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 498 - Jeffrey Mitchell 02.09.2026 44m
    October 27, 2006. Sacramento County, California. While performing his overnight patrol duty for the Sacramento County Sheriff’s Department, 38-year old Deputy Sheriff Jeffrey Mitchell sends a message to dispatch that he has pulled over a white Chevrolet van with no plates in a rural area. Minutes later, a clicking noise is heard on the radio and Jeffrey is soon found dead on the ground behind his patrol car, as it turns out he had gotten into a violent struggle before he was shot in the head with his own service revolver. Twelve hours later, a white Chevrolet van containing the bodies of 43-ye...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 497 - Jane Hart
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 497 - Jane Hart 26.08.2026 51m
    October 8, 1976. Benton County, Indiana. A farmer discovers a large cardboard shipping box in his cornfield which contains the body of an elderly woman who has been shot through the head. Since the victim cannot be identified, she remains a Jane Doe and is nicknamed “The Box Lady of Benton County”. Nearly 50 years later, genetic genealogy finally identifies the victim as 69-year old Jane Hart, who lived in Chicago around the time of her death, but the identity of her killer and the motive for the crime remain unknown. On this week’s episode of “The Trail Went Cold”, we explore the unsolved mur...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 496 - Margaret Kilcoyne
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 496 - Margaret Kilcoyne 19.08.2026 1h 3m
    January 26, 1980. Nantucket, Massachusetts. The brother of 49-year old Margaret Kilcoyne wakes up and discovers that she is missing from her vacation home, even though her car, coat and winter boots have been left behind. Prior to her disappearance, Margaret had completed a scientific research breakthrough at her job in New York City, but was also displaying erratic behaviour to suggest she was suffering from mental health issues. Over one week later, some of Margaret’s personal items, including her wallet and passport, are discovered in a swamp area about a mile from her residence, though the...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 495 - Terry Bowers
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 495 - Terry Bowers 12.08.2026 49m
    April 26, 1970. East Pikeland Township, Pennsylvania. While on a weekend camping trip with his Boy Scout troop, eleven-year old Terry Bowers is discovered dead inside his sleeping bag after having been stabbed four times during the early morning hours. Even though Terry was sleeping outside and there were nearly 30 other people at the campsite, no one reported seeing or hearing anything unusual and the murder weapon cannot be found. An extensive investigation turns up some leads, but no solid suspects, so Terry’s murder is never solved and the motive for the crime remains unclear. On this week...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 494 - The Be-Lo Murders
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 494 - The Be-Lo Murders 05.08.2026 47m
    June 6, 1993. Windsor, North Carolina. After a Be-Lo supermarket closes for the night, a gunman emerges from a hiding spot and forces the two employees - 47-year old manager Grover “Bud” Cecil and 36-year old casher Joyce Coburn Reason - to hand over $3,000 from the safe. The gunman then orders the employees and four members of an after-hours cleaning crew - 48-year old Johnnie Rankins, 40-year old Sylvester “Tony” Welch”, 48-year old Thomas Hardy and his 50-year old brother Jasper Hardy - to the back of the store, where they are bound and stacked on top of each other before they are shot. Whi...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 493 - Margaret Ellen Fox and Kim Leggett
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 493 - Margaret Ellen Fox and Kim Leggett 29.07.2026 56m
    June 24, 1974. Burlington, New Jersey. 14-year old Margaret Ellen Fox boards a bus to travel to the nearby township of Mount Holly in order to meet a man named John Marshall and never returns home. Days earlier, Margaret had placed an ad in the newspaper offering her services as a babysitter and received a phone call from Marshall, who offered her a job babysitting his son, but it seems apparent this was a set-up. Margaret’s family receives a phone call and a pair of letters demanding a $10,000 ransom for her safe return, but the kidnapper eventually ceases all communication and Margaret is ne...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 492 - The Adelaide Oval Abductions and the Beaumont Children, Part 2
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 492 - The Adelaide Oval Abductions and the Beaumont Children, Part 2 22.07.2026 1h 21m
    August 25, 1973 Adelaide, Australia. While attending a football match at the Adelaide Oval stadium alongside their respective families, 11-year old Joanne Ratcliffe and four-year old Kirste Gordon leave their seats to go to the toilet together, but never return. After Joanne and Kirste are reported missing, numerous eyewitnesses report having seen them in the company of a middle-aged man wearing a wide-brimmed hat and since the two girls appeared to be in distress, they were likely the victims of an abduction. Over the years, a number of known pedophiles are looked at as potential suspects in...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 491 - The Beaumont Children, Part 1
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 491 - The Beaumont Children, Part 1 15.07.2026 1h 2m
    January 26, 1966. Adelaide, Australia. Three children from the Beaumont family – nine-year old Jane, seven-year old Arnna and four-year old Grant – leave their residence in order to travel to the beach in the suburb of Glenelg, but they never return home. A number of eyewitnesses report having seen the children in the company of an unidentified man before they went missing and this person is believed to be responsible for their disappearances. Over the years, investigators explore a number of potential suspects and perform excavations at various locations, but no trace of Jane, Arnna or Grant...
  • The Trail Went Cold - Episode 490 - Eric Haider
    The Trail Went Cold - Episode 490 - Eric Haider 08.07.2026 48m
    May 24, 2012. Dickinson, North Dakota. After making a 100-mile commute to a worksite alongside a construction crew from Cofell’s Plumbing & Heating, 30-year old Eric Haider disappears in the middle of his shift and his crew returns back home without him. Nearly three years later, Eric’s remains are found buried at the former construction site in Dickinson inside a trench where he had last been seen working on a pipeline during his final shift. While it is suspected that Eric’s co-workers buried him alive and orchestrated a cover-up, the authorities do not believe they have the necessary eviden...

Popular in

The podcast also appears in the podcast charts of these countries.