Small Town Murder
James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman
1
Two comedians examine a small town, its unique characteristics, and a murder that occurred there. Through in-depth research, they explore the tragic event while adding their comedic perspective. New episodes are released every Thursday.
Episodes
-
Burning Desire For Murder - Murphys, California 19.11.2026 3h 9mThis week, in Murphys, California, when a young man is killed, it seems like a tragic, unavoidable accident, but a look into the dead man's father's past, changes everything. It turns out, this man's family was almost wiped out, years ago, in another situation where death seemed like a tragic accident. But detectives start to see these "accidents" as something much more sinister. The killer's wife ends up being the key to setting him up, and getting some anwers to these horrible murders!! Along the way, we find out that not all of California is the beach, that insurance policies are not meant... -
Maniacal Revenge Massacre - Berlin, Vermont 14.11.2026 1h 14mThis week, in Berlin, Vermont, a crazy, bloody, and murderous day takes place, after a woman has seemingly had enough of everyone who she feels has wronged her. Two different murder scenes, with 4 total victims shocks the entrie area. The most insane part is, she doesn't deny it, or have a drop of remorse. A case so wild that it sent a prosecutor into a PTSD related leave of absence! Along the way, we find out that one ear of corn for an acre of land seems like a gret deal, that when someone is killing in public & in broad daylight, they have definitely lost it, and that you have to really mes... -
The Many Marriages Murderer - Steamboat Springs, Colorado 12.11.2026 3h 5mThis week, in Steamboat Springs, Colorado, a woman with more than 10 marriages is the center of this incredibly strange murder story. She seems to just have bad luck, when husband number 3 is murdered. But when another husband meets a violent end, detectives think it can't be a coincidence. What they unravel is a twisted story of betrayal, mistrust, and a fake mustache that ends up being the big clue!! Along the way, we find out that people will really pay anything for houses, if skiing is nearby, that one dead husband is bad luck, but more dead husbands is suspicious, and that a mother has to... -
The Secret Serial Killer - Bald Knob, Arkansas 07.11.2026 1h 22mThis week, in Bald Knob, Arkansas, we do an extra long serial killer episode! After a horribly bloody crime scene is discovered, detectives get the shock of their lives, when the most unexpected thing ever happens, while phographing the scene. This leads to even more surprises, when it eventually comes out that this killer isn't exactly who they think he is. He's actually much worse, with more brutal, and terrifying murders in his past!! Along the way, we find out that you should really think hard before naming your town, that sometimes an ordinary, everyday killer turns out to be a serial kil... -
The Widow & The Deer Hunter - Belfast, Maine 05.11.2026 3hThis week, in Belfast, Maine, after a cold blooded murder, in a family driveway, detectives can't quite figure out who the killer could be. They suspect the dead man's widow, since she also has a questionable fire, in her past. But they could never imagine how twisted the actual plot was. Finally, a sting operation, with an undercover detective, gets all the answers, and even unravels this small town's criminal underworld!! A truly strange, and wild story!! Along the way, we find out that we don't want to spoil the secret of nice Maine towns, that even small towns have a network of criminals,... -
Bloody Triple Murder Madness - El Rancho, New Mexico 30.10.2026 1h 16mThis week, in El Rancho, New Mexico, when a family member arrives for a celebration, and finds everyone who lives there has been brutally murdered, with particularly nasty weapon. This bloody, and disturbing scene ends up leading detectives in many wrong directions. Was it the daughter, and son in law? An enemy? A stranger's random act of violence? It turns out that it's someone that the family has helped quite a bit, in the past. How many people did it take to butcher a family? The answer is surprising!! Along the way, we find out that a huge government facility, nearby, can really raise your... -
Mystery Of The Disappearing Man - Belgrade, Montana 29.10.2026 3h 8mThis week, in Belgrade, Montana, a man disappears, seemingly into thin air, but a friend of his says he doesn't want to be found. This friend says the man ran away to start a new life, with a blonde, in a small red car. This is a major surprise to the missing man's wife, who doesn't belive the disappearing story, for a second. Will some lies, and a piece of brain found in a curtain tell a different story??? Along the way, we find out that you need to have a major television deal to afford to live in a lot of Montana, that you never want to be a "forest bride", and that people normally don't ha... -
The Bloody Dollar Murder - Perry, Utah 23.10.2026 1h 15mThis week, in Perry, Utah, a strange encounter with a middle of the night gas station attendant leaves a college student holding a bloody dollar bill, and having a bad feeling. This leads to the discovery of an absolutely brutal, and bloody murder. Detectives have multiple suspects, that seem to be together, but the real killer is completely off their radar. This real killer has excuses, but no remorse!! Along the way, we find out that Utah is full of ghost stories, that vandalizing a dead man's room is in poor taste, and that when your gas station attendant has blood all over his shoes, you m... -
The Charming Susan Strangler - Demarest, New Jersey 22.10.2026 3h 3mThis week, in Demarest, New Jersey, something seems to be up, when two women disappear. Both are found brutally murdered, within days of each other, and near the same area. The crazy part is, it turns out that both of their names were Susan, and that's not the only thing that thet end up having in common. The other thing is a connection to a local man, nicknamed "The Charmer", who is supported by a rich aunt, and always in trouble for increasingly violent behavior. Will his family money keep him out of trouble?? Along the way, we find out that when the Army used to run out of space, the soldie... -
The Sweater Letter Murder - Ontonagon, Michigan 16.10.2026 1h 15mThis week, in Ontonagon, Michigan, an unlikely couple seems to be making it work, until a strange series of events make it seem like something is out to get the wife. A large cinderblock falls on her, from the roof of their home. There's a suspicious fire, when only she is home. And she finally ends up dead, during a family gathering, with her own mother finding her, on a wooded trail. Finally, a letter, found in the sleeve of a sweater makes the whole wild tale make sense!! Along the way, we find out that you don't want to end up in the "Busking Barn", that one attempt on your life could be a... -
Fine Line Of Lunacy - Wenham, Massachusetts 15.10.2026 3h 3mThis week, in Wenham, Massachusetts, a wealthy doctor and his wife seem to have the perfect life, until deep secrets start to emerge, leading to one of them being brutally murdered, and the other becoming an absolute public sideshow. Affairs, strange dressing habits, and "parading around naked" is just some of the strange behavior, leading up to the horrific murder. But the behavior after the murder is just as odd, and even scary!! Along the way, we find out that this area will certainly judge your clam chowder, that being a huge success doesn't make you immune from losing your mind, and that... -
The Bragging Brute - Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio 09.10.2026 1h 16mThis week, in Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio, when a man starts bragging to his friends, that he commited a terrible murder, the friends don't quite believe him, until he brings them to the body of a beloved local woman, who used to babysit the killer. Those friends tell police, and detectives walk into an awful scene, with starnge weapons used for the killing. Finally, the killer tells a cell mate what his true intentions were, which may be more disturbing than the actual murder!! Along the way, we find out that there are Italian people in Ohio, that asking if your friends "want to see a dead body" is... -
Chasing The Devil - Franklin, Louisiana 08.10.2026 3h 4mThis week, in Franklin, Louisiana, an awkward exchange between an ex couple, involving a secret Wal Mart meeting, and a home pregnancy test, leads to a wild night of carnage. A woman is taken for a scary ride, being told she certainly won't survive what's about to happen, which somehow unfolds into even more murder, and one of the craziest chases that a murderer has ever tried to pull off. Who survives, and who will admit to what are major questions, and the answers are crazy!! Along the way, we find out that black bears are endangered in Louisiana, that if someone that you're scared of invite... -
Stormy, Deadly Night - Selma, North Carolina 02.10.2026 1h 16mThis week, in Selma, North Carolina, when two men head out into the dark & stormy night, while sniffing a very crazy substance, and looking for trouble. A strange turn of events finds these wild men horribly murdering an unsuspecting victim, in his own home, with little for the killers to gain. It's a mystery to detectives, until an entire trailer full of people seem to know some serious details about the killing!! Along the way, we find out that the local festival has WAY too many pageants, that people should really be more careful about the substances they inhale, and that you shouldn't tell... -
Murder From The Shadows - Stab, Kentucky 01.10.2026 3h 8mThis week, in Stab, Kentucky, when a shot rings out from a grassy knoll, killing a beloved local figure, a mob of residents in pick up trucks chase the killer down. This all leads to a twisted and strange story of crazy motivations, and wild conspiracy that no one can even believe is real. Especially in such a small town. But it turns out, sometimes conspiracies can actually be real, and this murderous tale proves it!! Along the way, we find out that a "karst fenster" is something to do with water, that even if you're the town hero, there's going to be some people who want you dead, and that s... -
Guilty Google Search Murder - Winchester, Indiana 25.09.2026 1h 13mThis week, in Winchester, Indiana, a man is found brutally attacked, with several bags on his head, and some strange clues scattered around the house & his prize show car stolen. Detectives don't have much to go on, until an enormous clue drops into their lap, leading to a friend of the dead man, who has a scary history of fires & kidnapping. But he won't be easy to find, because he goes on the run, seemingly disappearing into thin air. This leads to even more crimes, and a very scary man on the loose!! Along the way, we find out that Indiana apparently loves Hawaiian music, that you should ne... -
Savage Murder & Strange Milkshakes - Arab, Alabama 24.09.2026 3h 9mThis week, in Arab, Alabama, when a woman is brutally murdered, stabbed almost 50 times, the case seems like a pretty easy one to solve. There is even DNA evidence, that points right to the suspect that police were looking at as the killer. He's arrested, and that strong evidence makes for an easy conviction. But that's only the start of this mess. Could he actually be innocent? Could his DNA have been planted? It sounds far fetched, until you hear about one person's desire for a certain horrifying milkshake, and habit of collecting bodily fluids, among other things!! Along the way, we find ou... -
Black Candle Murder Party - West Liberty, Iowa - Part 2 18.09.2026 1h 20mThis week, in West Liberty, Iowa, we finish this wild story, with detectives completely baffled by the mystery murder, and the case going cold. That is, until a detective's chance meeting with a witness, who was 9 years old, when the murder happened. She says she saw one of the suspects performing some kind of ritual, with black candles, and apologies to the dead. There ends up being more than one trial, bringing the case to a close. But did they get the right person?? Along the way, we find out that you should always check for 4th graders, when performing a death ritual, that most people are... -
A Web Of Deceit, Sex & Murder - Keeling, Virginia 17.09.2026 3h 3mThis week, in Keeling, Virginia, a bloodbath, with two butchered people, and some ominous last words lead to one of the craziest murder conspiracies, ever. A bagged lunch, in the victim's fridge is one headscratching clue, with several more that only make sense if one particular murder scenario happened. These strange clues lead to an unlikely pair of planners, and their recruited team of losers & screwballs, with murder on their minds!! Along the way, we find out that you can base a small town festival on yarn, that your coworkers apparently pay close attention to your lunch choices, and that... -
The Brutally Batted Bartender - West Liberty, Iowa - Part 1 11.09.2026 1h 12mThis week, in West Liberty, Iowa, we messed up! There was just too crazy of a story to fit into one episode. A young man, who is the small town's most popular & beloved bartender, is horribly beaten to death, in his own bed. The problem with solving this case, is that there are just too many suspects. The victim had at least 4 girlfriends, and a fiance. Plus, he's dabbles in some recreational drugs, and other extracurricular activities. Was it a angry girlfriend? One of their angrier husbands? The possibilities are nearly endless!! Along the way, we find out that you might not want to call you...
Popular in
The podcast also appears in the podcast charts of these countries.