Why Won't You Date Me? with Nicole Byer
Headgum & Nicole Byer
0
Comedian Nicole Byer hosts this multi-award-winning podcast about love and dating. She explores romantic highs, lows, and everything in between with comedians, experts, and sometimes an ex. New episodes drop every Friday.
Episodes
-
Going to Jail (w/ Nicole Paige Brooks) 13.11.2026 54mDrag queen icon Nicole Paige Brooks (Drag Race S2, All Stars 10) joins Nicole to talk about going to jail with her ex, and finding out he was cheating while he was locked up. She shares how she once got lost in the prison system, how her husband proposed with his benefits, and the Paris proposal she ended up planning herself. Plus, her duties as a drag mother to a whole lot of children, and the vows she makes lesbian couples say when she marries them. Nicole shares the time she got sent to Macy’s jail, and why she’s now in couples therapy.Watch this episode on our YouTube channel at https://ww... -
A Twink Is Born (w/ Mistress Isabelle Brooks) 06.11.2026 54mDrag icon Mistress Isabelle Brooks (Drag Race S15, All Stars 10) returns, and she isn’t afraid to cause a little mayhem. She sits down with Nicole to talk about how she broke the rules of her All Stars season, and how her Drag Race sisters almost blew her cover. Mistress comes out as bisexual, explains her twink rebirth at 28, and shares how losing nearly 200 pounds in a year cost her a few relationships. Plus, the new legal name she’s picking out, organizing a Last Supper before her surgery, and why straight audiences can’t get enough of her cheerleader alter ego, Eleanor Charles. Nicole reve... -
Getting Intimate with AI (w/ Bridget Todd) 30.10.2026 50mIf you caught your partner sexting an AI, would you break up with them? 1 in 7 people in committed relationships have a secret AI partner on the side. Tech journalist Bridget Todd (host of There Are No Girls on the Internet) shares her reporting on why so many people are falling in love with chatbots. She breaks down why AI chatbots are built to pull you into an intimate place, how dating apps are already using AI on you without you knowing, and why tech companies are betting on you being lonely and horny. Plus: the wildest AI love story she's come across, how to actually use AI to improve you... -
Date with a Dominatrix (w/ Adam Conover) 23.10.2026 1h 13mThree weeks after ending a 15-year relationship, comedian Adam Conover (Adam Ruins Everything, Factually!) went on a date with a 6'3" dominatrix whose first question was how he wanted to be dominated. He joins Nicole to share his side of the breakup with Lisa Hanawalt and dive into his newly single life, including exploring his sexuality, rediscovering himself, and experimenting with power dynamics in the bedroom. Plus, he shares stories from the messy dates he’s been on along the way, explains why he thinks straight men are the most sexually repressed people in America, and reveals how he’s l... -
I Wanna Be a Slut (w/ Lisa Hanawalt) 16.10.2026 42mIllustrator and friend Lisa Hanawalt (Bojack Horseman, Tuca & Bertie) returns to the podcast to chat about starting fresh in the dating scene after a 15-year relationship with Adam Conover, and what happened when they tried opening things up before they parted ways. Lisa explains wanting to be a slut while still needing to feel safe, her dates with a pathological liar who claimed he’d survived three train crashes, and what it’s like explaining PMDD mood swings to a new partner.Next week, Adam Conover joins Nicole to share his side of things.Lisa Hanawalt's new book, I Can’t Stop Thinking About... -
Are YOU The Problem? (w/ Darlene Mitchell) 09.10.2026 1h 3mDrag queen Darlene Mitchell (Drag Race S18) joins Nicole for a chat about finding love in the Instagram DMs, pulling off a tear-jerking surprise proposal, and coming out to her conservative family via a massive group text right before leaving to film reality TV. Darlene spills on a disastrous first date with an aspiring news anchor who was stuck in his persona, and dumping a college crush after finding out he was making out with someone ugly. Plus, they discuss why weaponized therapy speak on social media is ruining modern dating, and why you actually might need to change who you are for a par... -
Grilling Nicole's Man (w/ Ms. Pat) 02.10.2026 45mComedian Ms. Pat joins Nicole to reveal the true secret to surviving a 33-year marriage, shares the brutal realities of menopause nobody talks about, and interrogates Nicole and the nice man in her life about why they aren't married yet. Plus, they dive into why a casual courthouse wedding beats a pricey party, the difference between taking care of people and being taken advantage of, and learning to finally advocate for yourself in relationships.Check out Ms. Pat's new book, MS. AMERICAN DREAM: https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Ms-American-Dream/Patricia-Williams-Lee/9781668044216Watch t... -
Dating a Short King (w/ Marcella Arguello) 25.09.2026 56mWe’ve all heard the persistent dating mandate that the ideal man needs to be over 6ft tall. But what happens when you’re a 6"2 woman facing a dating pool of tall men who have coasted by on their height alone? According to comedian Marcella Arguello, it's time to abandon the tall man propaganda - and finally give short kings the respect they deserve. Marcella returns to the podcast to break down the brutal body standards we face in the dating pool. Nicole and Marcella also discuss the tragedy of having big dicks attached to bad people, and debate whether lying can actually keep the peace in a r... -
Finally Ready to Confess (w/ BenDeLaCreme) 18.09.2026 50mDrag queen icon BenDeLaCreme (Drag Race 6, All-Stars 3) joins Nicole to spill some major breaking news: they've been secretly separated from her partner of 8 years. They talk about the effort it takes to try to stay friends with an ex, the confusing reality of jumping back into the LA dating pool in your mid-40s, and why it's impossible to tell if a guy wants to date you or just wants exclusive Drag Race gossip. Plus, DeLa breaks down her brilliant move to self-eliminate on All-Stars 3, and Nicole reveals the unhinged manifestation trick she used to lock down the nice man in her life.See The J... -
The Most Chaotic Friendship Ever (w/ Meatball and Big Dipper) 11.09.2026 1h 14mWhy Won't You Date Me is taking a quick break this week while Nicole is out of town filming, but we'd never leave you high and dry! Instead, Nicole is sharing one of her all-time favorite episodes of her other podcast, Best Friends. Best Friends Nicole and Sasheer are joined by two very special guests and hosts of the podcast Sloppy Seconds, Big Dipper and Meatball! Consider this a wild masterclass in relationships and how hard it is to maintain a bond with someone, featuring wild stories about naked meetings at gay resorts, eating ribs nude in bed, and bombing TV auditions in a speedo. Normal... -
The AI Dating Dystopia (w/ Jarvis Johnson) 04.09.2026 51mYouTuber Jarvis Johnson (Host of Sad Boyz) joins Nicole to discuss the dystopian reality of how AI has changed the dating landscape, from people now dating their AI and the trend of men using ChatGPT to automatically swipe and chat with women for them. Jarvis opens up about his regret about having a public relationship and why he now chooses to keep his life private after a very public internet breakup. They also discuss how neurodivergence impacts relationships, why undiagnosed ADHD can hold someone back, Rejection Sensitive Dysphoria (RSD), medication they are taking, and how Nicole is manag... -
The Catfish Who Wanted to "Teach Me a Lesson" (w/ Onya Nurve) 28.08.2026 48mDrag queen superstar Onya Nurve (Winner of RuPaul's Drag Race S17) joins Nicole to talk about the time she was catfished on a dating app by a high school creep! Onya also sets the record straight on her true dynamic with the Season 17 girls, revealing why she felt like an outsider navigating the cast's social circle. She shares how her current girlfriend started out as her college bestie, the friction of taking her on tour as an assistant, and her journey to realizing she was pansexual.Plus, they debate whether sharing your location is the ultimate red flag, discuss the crazy movie Obsession,... -
Juggling A 7-Man Harem (w/ Kim Newmoney) 21.08.2026 48mNicole's photographer, Kim Newmoney (VOGUE, #VERYFAT #VERYBRAVE) chats with her about the logistics and managing a harem of 7 hot men. They talk about men who claim they want casual relationships but get territorial when another guy whose interest, and Kim shares what it took to walk away from a 7 year relationship with mismatched life goals.As a professional photographer, Kim drops her advice on taking your dating app profile pictures, getting comfortable on camera, and looking effortlessly sexy. Plus, Kim and Nicole reminisce the guerrila-style shooting behind Nicole's book, #VERYFAT #VERYBR... -
Dating a Hollywood Scammer (w/ Bresha Webb) 14.08.2026 43mComedian Bresha Webb (Run the World, Hacks) joins Nicole to share her terrible experience accientally dating a Hollywood scammer. Bresha also shares the story of a guy who paid for their dinner using a coin purse full of laundry quarters, what happens when you livestream a terrible first date on Instagram so your followers can roast the man, and the incredibly romantic 30-day Zoom courtship that led to her marriage. Plus, Nicole and Bresha reminisce about auditioning for SNL together and discuss the unhinged challenges on Love Island that will definitely haunt those contestants forever.Check o... -
The Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Date (w/ Eliot Glazer) 07.08.2026 59mComedian and writer Eliot Glazer (Broad City, New Girl) returns to the podcast! He shares how a group blind date quickly turned into a one-on-one nightmare with a horrible, drunk Jubilee "celebrity." Plus, Elliot and Nicole talk about what it's like to date an NPC, ask what happened to the whimsy in men's fashion, and discuss learning to be a better gay.Check out Eliot's new book, The Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Gay, out Aug 11th.Watch this episode on our YouTube channel at https://www.youtube.com/@WhyWontYouDateMePodcastSupport this podcast by checking out our sponsors:• Hers: Spons... -
The 'Goblintimacy' Dating Trend (w/ Devon Walker) 31.07.2026 59mComedian Devon Walker (SNL, Big Mouth) returns to the podcast to join Nicole for a chat about "goblintimacy", the new dating trend where you skip putting your best foot forward. Nicole shares the details of her terrifyingly chaotic NYC taxi ride, the wild energy of the city after the Knicks championship win, and addresses those recent internet comments about her hair. Plus, they conduct a very important investigation into Willem Dafoe's notoriously huge hog, Nicole breaks down the extensive list of Hollywood actors in her romantic "stable," and they discuss the importance of knowing your STD s... -
The Truth About TV Showmances (w/ Lydia B Kollins) 24.07.2026 45mDrag queen Lydia B Kollins (Drag Race S17, All Stars S10) joins Nicole to spill the behind-the-scenes tea on her iconic Drag Race showmance with Kori King. Find out just how strict production really is when it comes to off-screen flirting, what it was like having their first kiss during a lip sync for your life, plus the reason why she fully ghosted Kori after filming wrapped.Plus, Lydia opens up about her history of dating women and "dabbling in the puss." She explains why she believes it's easier to love a woman than a man, and why she builds her live shows specifically for her sapphic fans.... -
Sharing Trade (w/ Willam Belli) 17.07.2026 59mDrag queen icon Willam (Drag Race S4, host of Race Chasers) returns! She joins Nicole to break down the mathematical formula for the optimal orgy, the proper etiquette for passing good trade around to your drag sisters, and what really goes down inside LA's underground sex dungeons. Willam also reveals her pro tips for scheduling multiple hookups in one night and confesses the absolute kinkiest thing she's ever done. Plus, hear the hot story of how she met her 6'6" lawyer ex-husband at the door of Micky's, why she turned to OnlyFans to pay her two mortgages, and why she simply has to stop hook... -
My Career Ruined my Relationships (w/ June Jambalaya) 10.07.2026 47mDrag queen June Jambalaya (Drag Race S14) joins Nicole to discuss hiding her drag career from her dates, being engaged twice, and leaving her fiancé to compete on Drag Race. Plus, Nicole and June discuss the best city to be depressed in, reveal the wildest things they've done to impress a man, and June shares her amazing date after being set up by Kerri Colby.Watch this episode on our YouTube channel at https://www.youtube.com/@WhyWontYouDateMePodcastSupport this podcast by checking out our sponsors:• Warby Parker: Our listeners can buy one prescription pair and get 20% off any additional pair... -
Hiring a Zoom Stripper (w/ Liza Treyger) 03.07.2026 1h 1mComedian and friend Liza Treyger (Night Owl, host of That's Messed Up) returns to the podcast! She shares her sobering experience hiring a Zoom stripper for a bachelorette party, how Heated Rivalry changed her life, and the struggle of making friends easily while her dating life remains in the dumps. Liza tells the story about how she got scammed by a stylist while making her Netflix special, her goal to quit weed for a relationship, and why she believes it's an actual safety hazard to date a man who isn't completely obsessed with you.Watch Liza's special, Night Owl on Netflix.Watch this episo...
Popular in
The podcast also appears in the podcast charts of these countries.
-
Namibia
-
El Salvador
-
Albania
-
Tanzania
-
Zambia
-
Kenya
-
Hungary
-
Azerbaijan
-
Benin
-
Angola
-
Cambodia
-
Chad
-
Philippines
-
Ecuador
-
Bermuda
-
Bulgaria
-
Cameroon
-
Ghana
-
Estonia
-
Latvia
-
Liberia
-
Slovenia
-
Malta
-
Jamaica
-
Sri Lanka
-
Bahamas
-
Romania
-
Barbados
-
Iceland
-
Costa Rica
-
Mali
-
Belize
-
Grenada
-
North Macedonia
-
Greece
-
Ukraine
-
Senegal
-
Trinidad and Tobago
-
Dominican Republic
-
Serbia
-
Cayman Islands
-
Mozambique
-
Montenegro
-
Cabo Verde
-
Sierra Leone
-
Rwanda
-
Niger
-
Botswana
-
Lithuania
-
Mongolia
-
Kyrgyzstan
-
Laos
-
Guyana
-
Zimbabwe
-
Nigeria
-
Bosnia and Herzegovina
-
Democratic Republic of the Congo
-
Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
-
Uruguay
-
Myanmar
-
Antigua and Barbuda
-
Honduras
-
Ivory Coast