Evan & Tiki

Episodes

• 
  Wednesday Full Show: The Yankees Face Elimination Wednesday 07.10.2026 2h 27m

  The Yankees wake up today needing to go 1-0 to survive until Thursday. Odell signs elsewhere, the Jets AD Mitchell mystery continues, and much more.
• 
  Hour 1: Yankees Must Shake Up Lineup to Save Season 07.10.2026 35m

  The Yankees are down 0-2 to the Rays, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash demand changes with the season on the line. Aaron Boone cannot simply run back the same lineup after two ugly losses, sparking a debate over sitting Jazz Chisholm and Trent Grisham while turning to Anthony Volpe, Jose Caballero and Heliot Ramos for a desperately needed spark. Evan also floats an extreme way to get Aaron Judge back on the postseason roster, while Shaun finds renewed hope after nearly giving up on the season. Plus, Max Fried vows to make his Game 3 start regardless of what happens with the expected birth of his child, leading Evan, Tiki and Shaun into a revealing debate over choosing between a career-defining game and being there for childbirth.
• 
  Hour 2: Yankees’ Playoff Meltdown Sparks an Embarrassment Debate 07.10.2026 42m

  The Yankees’ ugly Game 2 loss ignites a heated debate over where it ranks among the franchise’s most embarrassing postseason performances. Evan argues that the 2024 World Series collapse will ultimately sting far more, while the conversation turns to lineup changes, Aaron Judge’s mysterious injury status and whether the Yankees could use an injury replacement to get him onto the roster. The Jets also enter unfamiliar territory as favorites against the Browns, putting even more pressure on Aaron Glenn to finally deliver a meaningful win. The crew examines Glenn’s repeated game-management problems, when the Jets might turn to Cade Klubnik and why firing Glenn during the season still makes little sense. Plus, Odell Beckham Jr. lands with Minnesota, the Giants protect another quarterback on their 53-man roster, and the sports-versus-childbirth debate gets wildly personal.
• 
  Hour 3: Curtis Granderson Says Citi Field Outroars Yankee Stadium 07.10.2026 40m

  Curtis Granderson joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber with the Yankees facing elimination and explains why New York pressure is real, why Tampa has been such a difficult environment for the Yankees and how they can finally wake up their struggling offense. Granderson also weighs in on Aaron Judge’s absence and delivers a verdict Mets fans will love: in his postseason experience, Citi Field was louder than Yankee Stadium. The focus then shifts to the Yankees’ must-win Game 3, with Max Fried under pressure to set the tone and Aaron Boone needing to push the right buttons. Plus, Tiki reflects on Lane Johnson’s sudden retirement as the Eagles take another major hit, opening the door even wider in a chaotic NFC East.
• 
  Hour 4: Eli Manning Dispels Rumors About Arch Manning and the Jets 07.10.2026 41m

  Tiki and Evan react to Eli Manning’s confirmation that Arch Manning would be open to playing for the New York Jets if drafted. They also address the New York Yankees' struggles with hitting and fielding as the team faces a potential sweep in Game 3 against the Tampa Bay Rays. (00:01:50) NY Fan Energy and Eagles Trade (00:06:04) Yankee Culture and Management (00:10:42) Giants Identity and Winning Ugly (00:14:35) LeBron James vs. Mike Breen (00:19:41) Yankees Facing Elimination (00:26:12) Sports Rivalry Trolling (00:32:15) Eli Manning on Arch Manning (00:38:37) Game 3 Final Predictions
• 
  LeBron James Calls Out Mike Breen 07.10.2026 15m

  LeBron James is pushing back on a story Mike Breen shared about Joel Embiid being late to practice, turning what sounded like praise for LeBron’s leadership into a bizarre controversy. Evan Roberts believes Breen’s account and argues that LeBron may be denying the story for a noble reason: protecting Embiid from criticism. Tiki Barber sees another possibility, that Breen was simply given bad information by his source. The debate becomes whether LeBron’s denial actually proves his leadership in a different way, with Evan arguing that he’s willing to absorb the controversy rather than let it fall on Embiid. Plus, the Yankees face elimination after two brutal offensive performances, Alex Cora passes on the Phillies job, and Rangers-Islanders trash talk heats up.
• 
  Giants Can Seize Control of the NFC East 07.10.2026 17m

  Lane Johnson’s sudden retirement delivers another massive blow to an Eagles team already dealing with injuries and instability. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why walking away from football is such a personal decision, with Tiki recalling the moment during his own final season when he knew he was finished but never considered retiring immediately. Johnson’s departure also throws the NFC East even further into chaos. Philadelphia is weakened, Dallas has major defensive concerns and the Giants are sitting at 3-1 with a legitimate opportunity to contend for the division. Evan and Tiki debate whether the Giants can actually become the NFC East favorite and what they still need to prove before anyone fully buys in.
• 
  Curtis Granderson Warns Yankees Pressure Can Break Players 07.10.2026 23m

  Curtis Granderson joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber with the Yankees facing elimination and explains why playing under New York pressure can weigh heavily on players. The former Yankee and Met says the Yankees need to loosen up, find a spark offensively and take their comeback one game at a time rather than thinking about winning three straight. Granderson also breaks down the challenges of playing on Tampa’s turf, Aaron Judge’s difficult road back from a calf injury and whether the Yankees should consider getting Judge onto the postseason roster. Plus, Granderson settles a New York baseball debate from his own experience, revealing that Citi Field was louder than Yankee Stadium during his postseason runs.
• 
  Jets Loss Could Trigger the Cade Klubnik Conversation 07.10.2026 14m

  Aaron Glenn enters a critical spot with the Jets favored against Cleveland, their first game as favorites in nearly two years. Evan argues the Jets simply have to win if this season is going to mean anything, while the crew examines Glenn’s lack of a signature victory and why another loss could accelerate calls to see what Cade Klubnik can do at quarterback. The criticism of Glenn goes deeper than the record, with repeated game-management issues and his postgame uncertainty raising questions about whether he is improving as a head coach. The debate also turns to Frank Reich’s role and whether he could better support Glenn without a midseason firing. Plus, the Giants lose Braxton Berrios for the season and move Jake Haener onto the 53-man roster.
• 
  Yankees’ Playoff Humiliation Sparks a Furious Debate 07.10.2026 14m

  The Yankees’ disastrous Game 2 loss to Tampa Bay ignites a heated argument over whether it was really more embarrassing than their 2024 World Series collapse. Shaun Morash sides with the idea that this latest meltdown felt worse in the moment, while Evan Roberts argues that history will remember the World Series failure far more painfully. The infamous 2004 collapse against Boston also enters the debate. Then the focus turns to Aaron Judge and a growing mystery around his health. Evan questions whether Judge is more injured than the Yankees are admitting and examines whether the team could potentially use Giancarlo Stanton’s health issues to create a postseason roster opening if Judge becomes available.
• 
  Yankees Shakeup Targets Volpe, Jazz and Grisham 07.10.2026 13m

  The Yankees’ struggling lineup takes center stage as Evan, Tiki and Shaun Morash debate the changes needed to create an October spark. Anthony Volpe, Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Trent Grisham are all discussed as possible lineup casualties, while Ben Rice, Cody Bellinger and Austin Wells could take on bigger roles. Then the conversation goes completely off the rails over whether the birth of a child should ever lose out to a Super Bowl, with Tiki and Shaun defending the game while Evan strongly disagrees. Plus, Odell Beckham Jr. joins the Vikings’ practice squad, the crew revisits the Giants’ late interception return and how gambling changes the way fans watch end-of-game decisions.
• 
  Max Fried Puts Yankees’ Season Before Childbirth 07.10.2026 13m

  Max Fried is taking the ball with the Yankees’ season on the line, regardless of whether his girlfriend goes into labor. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash react to Fried’s firm commitment to his Game 3 start and debate one of sports’ toughest personal decisions: whether a player should ever miss the birth of a child for a postseason game. The conversation turns personal as Evan and Tiki share their own experiences around childbirth and work, while the Yankees remain at the center of everything. Despite an ugly 0-2 hole against the Rays, Evan argues the series is far from impossible to save, pointing to past Yankees teams that have successfully battled back from the same deficit.
• 
  Yankees Need One Win to Flip the Series 07.10.2026 9m

  The Yankees looked finished after falling behind 0-2 to the Rays, but the mood is starting to change before Game 3 at Yankee Stadium. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether there is still reason to believe, with Shaun going from wanting the season put out of its misery to embracing the possibility of a comeback. The focus remains on Aaron Boone making real changes. Anthony Volpe, Jose Caballero and Heliot Ramos emerge as potential answers, while Trent Grisham’s health and Ryan McMahon’s struggles create difficult decisions. With the Yankees back home and their season at stake, the message is simple: change the lineup, find a spark and win one game to make this a series again.
• 
  Yankees Must Blow Up the Lineup Tonight 07.10.2026 12m

  The Yankees need a spark with their season on the line, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash agree Aaron Boone cannot simply run back the same lineup for Game 3 against the Rays. They debate sitting Jazz Chisholm, Ryan McMahon and Trent Grisham, while giving Anthony Volpe, Jose Caballero and Heliot Ramos a chance to change the series. Then Evan takes the desperation to another level. With Aaron Judge off the roster, he argues the Yankees should find a way to create an opening and get their superstar back for a must-win game. Tiki wonders whether Judge’s injury is more serious than the Yankees have let on as their season reaches the brink.
• 
  Worst Season Ever Mailbag Edition | 'Rico Brogna' 07.10.2026 46m

  In a end of the year Mailbag, Evan dives into your questions and comments. One of the biggest ones being "Was this the worst season ever"? P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠Breakingt.com/products/the-rico Email [email protected]
• 
  Tuesday Full Show: Yankees Errors Push Them to Brink of Elimination 06.10.2026 2h 51m

  It is a vent session for all Yankees fans after an inexplicable fundamental loss in Game 2.
• 
  Hour 1: Yankees Defensive Meltdown Leaves Their Season on the Brink 06.10.2026 39m

  The Yankees are staring at a 2-0 hole against the Rays after a stunning defensive meltdown that Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber struggle to explain. Four official errors, additional costly miscues and another lifeless offensive performance have the Yankees looking like a team that short-circuits when the postseason pressure rises. Evan and Tiki debate whether the turf played a role, how much responsibility belongs to Aaron Boone and whether the Yankees’ lack of accountability has become an organizational problem. With just five hits and two runs through two games, the offense is every bit as concerning as the defense. The series technically isn’t over, but after a loss this ugly, it certainly feels that way.
• 
  Hour 2: Yankees’ October Failures Put Aaron Boone on Notice 06.10.2026 41m

  Mariano Rivera delivers a blunt message with the Yankees down 0-2 to Tampa Bay: the series isn’t over, but the mental mistakes have to stop. The Hall of Fame closer explains how the Yankees can fight back, why returning to Yankee Stadium matters and what separates physical errors from unacceptable mental miscues. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate the Yankees’ lack of accountability after costly decisions from Austin Wells and Jazz Chisholm, and whether their recurring October problems point directly to Aaron Boone. They examine why the Yankees keep losing the same way in the postseason, whether pressure is exposing them and how much longer Boone can survive without getting this team over the top.
• 
  Hour 3: Yankees’ Playoff Defense Has Become a Nightmare 06.10.2026 37m

  The Yankees’ defense melted down again in Tampa, leaving Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber wondering why the same fatal flaws keep resurfacing under Aaron Boone. Cam Schlittler delivered a fascinating postgame message, first saying the Yankees “didn’t show up” before taking the blame himself, while Tiki’s criticism of Boone’s lack of accountability from 2024 suddenly sounds just as relevant today. The hour also ranks the Yankees’ brutal defensive miscues, revisits their painful history of postseason near-miss home runs and debates whether this team can actually recover. Plus, John Harbaugh admits he regretted an aggressive two-point decision, Tiki celebrates his victory on The Weakest Link, and Shaun Morash delivers a bleak prediction for when the Yankees might win again.
• 
  Hour 4: Could the Yankees 'Fake' an Injury to Activate Aaron Judge? 06.10.2026 45m

  Yankee fans are in a state of panic as the team falls into a 0-2 hole against Tampa, leading to radical suggestions for roster changes. Tiki and Sean weigh in on Aaron Boone's managerial decisions, the struggles of the offense, and whether Gerrit Cole or Carlos Rodón should lead the charge in a potential Game 4. They also explore the controversial idea of manipulating the injured list to get Aaron Judge back into the lineup for a do-or-die stretch. (00:01:50) Giants Wide Receiver Issues (00:05:30) Caller Slams Aaron Boone (00:08:35) Brian Cashman's Job Security (00:13:15) Alex Cora Managerial Rumors (00:20:50) Tri-State Sports Focus Update (00:26:30) Faking Injuries For Judge (00:34:15) Volpe Moving To Third (00:44:30) Schlittler Pitch Count Debate